Offers, shipping and returns

Protect full price and margin with free shipping just above your typical order and sitewide discounts kept to a few planned moments. Show shipping, returns and tax terms where shoppers decide.

11 answers · 1 new or changed since Nov 16 · Data as of Nov 22, 2026

Answers for any spend, own site only, general category, United States.

The short version

Our judgment, drawn from the 11 answers below.

Offer free shipping above a threshold about 15 to 25% above your typical order, and test it on margin per visitor.

From Free shipping and the threshold

Keep sitewide discounts to a few planned moments a year, keep hero products at full price and use product or segment offers in between.

From Sitewide, product or loyalty discounts

Offer a return window of about 30 days, at least 14 in the EU and UK, and show the terms by the buy button and in the cart.

From Return policy and how to show it

Show a delivery promise or take pre-orders only when you can keep the date.

From Shipping speed and delivery promises, Pre-orders and back-in-stock alerts

The 11 answers

Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:

Shape the offer

Discounts, subscribe and save, gift cards and pre-orders.

  1. Should we run sitewide discounts, product-level offers or loyalty rewards, and how often?

    Keep sitewide discounts to a few planned moments a year. In between, use product or customer-segment offers for a stated job. Keep hero products at full price, and favor loyalty perks over points that become discounts.

    Medium confidence · 13 sources

  2. Should we offer subscribe-and-save, and how should it look on the product page?

    Offer subscribe and save only on products reordered on a cycle. Show it as a stacked choice beside one-time purchase, with price, frequency and cancellation terms inside. Test preselecting it on revenue per visitor.

    Medium confidence · 15 sources

  3. Should we offer gift cards, and how should we sell them?

    Offer digital gift cards, which Shopify includes on every plan at no added fee. Link them from the main menu, promote them before gifting dates and after shipping cutoffs, set no expiry date and follow up recipients after they redeem.

    Medium confidence · 7 sources

  4. How should we run pre-orders and back-in-stock alerts?

    Take pre-orders only with a confirmed ship date you show and can refund against. Otherwise collect back-in-stock signups. In the US, ship by the stated date, or within 30 days if you state none, or offer a delay or refund.

    Medium confidence · 13 sources

Price shipping

Free shipping thresholds, heavy items, delivery speed and shipping protection.

  1. Should we offer free shipping, and where should the threshold sit?

    Offer free shipping above a threshold about 15 to 25% above your typical order, within reach of one add-on. Show it on product pages and in the cart, and test it on margin per visitor.

    Medium confidence · 13 sources

  2. How should we price shipping for heavy or oversized products?

    Price heavy and oversized items from what each one costs to ship. Give them their own shipping profile, keep them out of storewide free shipping, size boxes under carrier surcharge lines and show the cost on the product page.

    Updated Nov 17 Medium confidence · 11 sources

  3. How fast must we ship to compete, and should we show delivery speed promises?

    Aim to deliver free standard orders within 2 to 3 days. Charge for faster delivery rather than making it free. Show a delivery promise only when your cutoff, handling and carrier data let you keep it.

    Medium confidence · 11 sources

  4. Should we charge for shipping protection or package insurance at checkout?

    Charge for shipping protection only if you will pay claims fast. Offer it as an unticked add-on in the cart with its price and cover shown. Never pre-check it or imply shoppers are unprotected without it.

    Medium confidence · 7 sources

Handle returns and tax

Return policy, returns portals and exchanges, and how to show tax and duties.

  1. How generous should our return policy be, and how should we show it on the site?

    Offer a return window of about 30 days (at least 14 in the EU and UK). Keep returns free or charge a small fee stated before purchase. Show the terms by the buy button and in the cart.

    Medium confidence · 16 sources

  2. Should we use a returns portal app, and does offering exchanges first cut refunds?

    Start with your store's built-in self-serve returns and add a returns app once return volume pays for it. Offer an exchange or store credit with a small bonus before the refund, while keeping refunds easy to choose.

    Medium confidence · 9 sources

  3. How should we handle sales tax and duties shown to the buyer?

    Show prices the way each market expects. List US prices before sales tax, with the tax or an estimate in the cart. Include VAT in the UK and EU, and collect duties at checkout or build them into cross-border prices.

    Medium confidence · 15 sources

More in Store

91 answers in 9 subjects

Guides that use these answers: How to launch a Shopify store

See all 91 Store answers in one list