Which sign-up offers grow the list without attracting discount hunters?
Our answer
Offer a small welcome discount, about 10% off, as a unique one-time code. Test the pop-up before a bigger discount, and judge each offer on what its sign-ups buy at 30, 60 and 90 days.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 2 controlled tests
- 2 official rules, 4 datasets, 5 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 14 statements
- H
PKACM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA discount code lifts sign-ups, and 10% off works as well as more. Across 28,674 campaigns, Popupsmart, a popup software maker, found discount popups converted 1.46% of displays against 0.75% without, and bigger discounts did no measurably better than 10% off.
Premium buyers respond more to exclusivity and early access than to small cuts, Data Revolt, a marketing agency, concludes, without results by offer. Klaviyo suggests a free gift where the product costs little to make, and says unique codes are harder to share or misuse.
Testing the pop-up can lift opt-ins without a bigger discount. HexClad's opt-in rate was stuck at 5 to 6% until it tested pop-up messaging, design and timing. Opt-ins then nearly doubled.
Our judgment
Because bigger discounts did not convert measurably better in Popupsmart's data, we hold the welcome discount at about 10% off rather than raise it. We guard against discount hunters with a unique one-time code and cohort checks at day 30, 60 and 90, not by dropping the offer. We test the pop-up's wording, design and timing one change at a time, each for at least 2 full weeks, before a bigger discount, going by HexClad's account and Convertibles' 2 to 3 week pop-up tests (Running A/B tests on the store).
Our judgment, built from Popupsmart, Klaviyo, AdBeacon, HexClad and Convertibles: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
14 statements from 13 sourcesKlaviyo's coupon forms can give one static code or unique one-time codes, which are harder to share. Klaviyo suggests a free gift with purchase over a discount for cheap-to-make, high-price products like skin care.
“unique codes are harder to share or misuse”
Jon Loomer reports Meta can add promo codes to Sales ads on its own, with no per-ad off switch, and run email sign-up offers that disable your site's pop-up. Both are turned off in Commerce Manager.
“There's no way to remove promotions from an individual ad while this setting is on.”
AdBeacon, which sells attribution, says compare discount-acquired and full-price customers at 30, 60 and 90 days on repeat rate, returns and contribution, then subtract CAC. Its example numbers are illustrative.
“Product mix inside the promo often matters more than the percentage.”
In a sponsored piece, HexClad's Connor Rolain says testing pop-up messaging, design and timing two to three times a week nearly doubled email opt-ins from 5 to 6% and lifted evergreen flow revenue 68%.
HexClad says its 2024 sweepstakes opt-ins took 86 days on average to first purchase, and it ties extra entries to purchase size to deter unserious entrants. A Ridge guest calls such leads very unqualified.
“The value of those emails is obviously questionable. It's a very unqualified lead that you're gathering at that point.”
Attentive's 2025 data: people who signed up during Cyber Week were 0.8% of brands' lists but drove 22% of Cyber Week revenue, and sign-up units with a discount drew about 55% more subscribers.
Taylor Sicard's scan found 152 of 235 top online brands showed a welcome popup, mostly percent-off at a median 15%. Across 2,833 sites, only 3.3% mentioned anything after the first order. No outcome data.
Popupsmart, which sells popups, found across 28,674 campaigns that signup popups with a discount convert 1.46% vs 0.75% without, but bigger discounts didn't convert measurably better. Sign-ups only.
“start from the smallest code you're comfortable offering.”
Ridge says sweepstakes leads are less qualified, but list growth and visibility pay off for months; it tags entrants and tracks what they buy. Lift is strongest for lower-priced items. No purchase rates are given.
“Tag everyone who enters and track what they buy over the next few months. Many free entries convert later, often during your next big sale.”
In Maestra's two-week test for one apparel brand across about 20,000 visitors, a $15 off pop-up converted 24% better than the old 12% off offer and drove 22% more revenue.
“Both dollar variants outperformed the percentage control.”
Recharge's data on 29.8M new subscriptions: first-renewal rate falls from 65.0% with no first-order discount to 62.9% at 20-40% off and 53.4% at 90% or more. Deep discounts also cut 12-month value.
“Past 75% off, value drops sharply.”
Data Revolt, an agency, tested Meta Instant Forms against a signup page for several brands: forms cost about 8x less per lead, but those leads barely bought, while 5-35% of leads captured on site ordered.
“near-zero purchase conversion from Meta leads”
Skio, which sells subscription software, claims discount-acquired subscribers churn 18-35% faster than full-price ones and recommends store credit over percentage discounts. No method or sample.
“discount-acquired subscribers churn 18-35% faster than full-price subscribers”
Convertibles says to run a popup A/B test until it reaches 95% confidence, with at least 1,000 visitors per variation, which takes 2 to 3 weeks for most Shopify brands.
“Until you hit statistical significance at 95% confidence. Minimum 1,000 visitors per variation.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer