Should we boost posts or run ads from Meta Ads Manager, and is boosting ever worth it?
Our answer
Run anything meant to sell from Ads Manager, where you can optimize for purchases, exclude buyers and test ads. Boost only a post already doing well organically, on a small budget for a few days, to buy reach.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 Meta rules
- 1 dataset, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 10 statements
- M
LBCM3HA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentA boost can't chase sales. Meta lets boosted posts focus on website clicks, Page engagement and local promotion, and keeps the sales objective and website-conversion optimization for ads built in Ads Manager or Business Suite.
Boosting mostly buys reach. Across 355 Instagram brands, boosted posts reached about 4 times as many people for Reels and 10.5 times for images, but boosted Reels drew 2,443 engagements from the paid audience against 8,381 organically (Dash Social).
Ads Manager does the jobs a boost skips, argues Relevant Audience, an ad agency. A boost can't optimize for Pixel-tracked purchases, exclude existing customers or test creatives, and boosting every post on small budgets scatters spend.
A boost has no set price. You choose the budget, and Meta's minimums vary by country and objective. Paying in the Facebook or Instagram iPhone app can hand Apple a 30% service fee.
Our judgment
Keep always-on spend that should sell in Ads Manager and use boosts only as short reach flights on posts that already work, applying Meta’s split of objectives and Dash Social’s finding that boosting mostly buys reach, consistent with Awareness and Traffic campaigns versus Sales. A boost is a reasonable first step for a small business that sells in chat or wants local reach, as long as someone answers messages fast and it runs with an end date.
Our judgment, built from Meta, Dash Social, Relevant Audience, Enrich Labs and Lilach Bullock: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 8 sourcesMeta says boosted posts optimize for engagement or awareness, while Ads Manager offers objectives such as leads and sales and more targeting, including lookalikes.
“some detailed targeting features are only available in Ads Manager.”
Meta says that since February 2024, boosting a Facebook post from the iOS app may add Apple's 30% service fee on the ad payment, kept by Apple.
“This fee is retained by Apple, not Facebook or Meta.”
Meta says minimum budgets vary by country and objective, and optimizing for purchases may need more budget than optimizing for landing page views. It gives no single minimum figure.
“Minimum budgets may vary by country and objective.”
Enrich Labs, an AI marketing tool vendor, says boosts suit light reach on organic winners but are a weak default for performance, so build purchase or lead campaigns in Ads Manager.
“is fine for light reach on organic winners. It is a weak default for performance marketing.”
Lilach Bullock says Instagram Boost suits putting a modest budget behind a post that's working, but comparing audiences, Reels-only placement or website retargeting needs Ads Manager.
“Boosting can't do those jobs.”
CreatorFlow says Instagram boosts suit profile visits, site visits and messages, while Ads Manager suits sales and leads. Adding funds in the iOS app may carry a 30% Apple fee.
“Boost fits profile visits, website visits and messages. Ads Manager fits sales and leads.”
Relevant Audience, an agency, says boosts and Ads Manager ads enter the same auction at no special price. Boosting suits proven posts, but wastes money when the goal is website sales or leads.
“has no special price, cheaper or dearer.”
Hasib Ashad says boosting Facebook posts only promotes a post temporarily and is not a sustainable way to run or scale ads.
“That's not really running ads. That is just promoting your post temporarily.”
Dash Social's data on 355 Instagram brands found boosted posts had 77% more organic engagement before any spend than never-boosted posts (136% for Reels). Images were the exception.
“Images were the only Instagram format where the boost drove more engagement than the post had earned organically.”
Momentum 360 says boosting posts and hoping for results is not a Meta ads strategy.
“people boosting posts and hoping for results and that's just not a strategy”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer