Should we run email and SMS in house or with an agency?
Our answer
Run email and SMS yourself under about $20,000 a month in store revenue. Above that, rent a specialist agency or fractional expert. Bring the work in-house once it is a top revenue channel, by $5 to $10M a year.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 practitioners
- 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 8 statements
SAMFDN
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentSmall stores struggle to pay back a retainer. Below about $20,000 a month in store revenue, one of $2,500 or more is hard to earn back, and most published retainers run $2,500 to $10,000 a month (Sorted Agency, a Klaviyo agency).
One in-house hire costs more than most retainers. An email manager runs $11,200 to $13,200 a month with benefits (Maestra, an email and SMS platform), and a full-time hire takes 3 to 6 months to fill (MarketerHire).
Brands bring email, SMS and CRM in-house by $5 to $10M in revenue, because tooling is cheap and the iteration loop is short (Eightx, a fractional CFO firm).
Our judgment
Rent email and SMS work until it is large enough to fill a full-time role, then bring it in-house. That combines Sorted Agency's revenue floor for a retainer, the gap between a retainer and one in-house manager in Maestra's and Sorted Agency's figures, and Eightx's insourcing point. Pay a fixed fee rather than a share of attributed revenue. The attribution window that sets the share is a setting an agency can widen, and the attributed figure includes sales that would have happened anyway (Measuring email and SMS revenue). This fits Agency, freelancers or your own team, where strategy and measurement stay in-house and execution is rented. Email and SMS move in-house earlier than paid media buying, which Eightx keeps agency-heavy through $50M.
Our judgment, built from Sorted, Maestra, Eightx and MarketerHire: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
8 statements from 7 sourcesDarkroom, a retention agency, puts in-house email at $102K to $167K a year against $75K to $144K for a mid-tier agency, and says bring strategy in-house only past $20M revenue with retention at 35% or more of revenue.
“once you reach $20M+ in revenue and retention is generating 35%+ of total revenue, bringing strategy in-house and using an agency for execution or specialized projects often makes sense”
Sorted, a Klaviyo agency, puts published retainers at $2,500 to $10,000 a month and says below about $20,000 a month in store revenue, build core flows yourself or hire a freelancer.
“Below about $20,000 a month in store revenue, a $2,500+ retainer is hard to pay back.”
Maestra, an email platform vendor, puts Klaviyo agencies at $2,500 to $10,000 a month and one in-house email manager at $11,200 to $13,200, and warns against paying agencies on revenue share.
“An agency paid on attributed revenue has every reason to widen it”
MarketerHire, which sells fractional marketers, puts a Klaviyo agency at $8K to $20K a month and a fractional expert at $4K to $10K, and says fractional help is faster for brands under $10M when speed is the bottleneck.
“Revenue-share with no floor gets expensive fast if you scale.”
Nick Shackelford of The DTC Podcast predicts agencies will return to a fractured, specialist model, with brands hiring separate experts for CRO, paid, email and content instead of one full-service agency.
“I think you're going to get back into a very commoditized split.”
Eightx, a finance firm for consumer brands, says email and SMS are the clearest function to bring in-house, typically by $5 to $10M in yearly revenue, while paid media stays mostly with agencies through $50M.
“Insource by $5 to $10M.”
Eightx, a DTC finance firm, says the usual 2026 setup is one in-house operator owning brief, budget and weekly read, with an agency running execution; Meta and Google bidding stays agency-led through $50M revenue.
“One in-house operator owns the brief, budget allocation, and weekly read. The agency owns the execution at scale.”
Foundr says that for a client spending $100,000 a month on paid media and handling email in-house, agency fees should run between $5,000 and $7,500.
“someone's running paid media, $100,000 spend client, they're doing their email themselves, you're going to spend on an agency between $5,000 and $7,500.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer