When sales close weeks or months after the lead, which early actions best predict a lead will close, and how do we prove one before optimizing on it?
Our answer
Optimize for the latest CRM step that arrives within 7 days on Google or 28 days on Meta and reaches about 50 a week per ad set. Check its timing and fit on past leads, then test it.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 controlled tests
- 13 official rules, 9 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 12 sources
- 26 statements
- GM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentMeta sets volume bars for stages. It asks for 200 leads a month and a stage 1% to 40% of leads reach within 28 days. Jon Loomer aims for about 50 optimized events per ad set a week. Loomer plans on 25 to 50.
Google wants one funnel stage as the bid goal, with at least 15 conversions in 30 days across the account, ideally within 7 days of the click. Its product manager wants the lowest action that has volume and strongly signals value.
Agencies rank a qualified step above the form fill. Silverback Strategies, PPC Rebels and Prose Media favor qualified leads, booked consultations or sales-qualified leads. Advertisers sending CRM data see about 21% lower cost per quality lead on Instant Forms (Meta's own figure).
Our judgment
- Treat a step as a candidate only if your CRM records it the same way for every lead. It must also arrive within the platform's window and keep enough volume. Prose Media says a stage sales does not use consistently should not drive bidding.
- Check fit on past leads before switching. Compare the step's rate with the sales those leads later made, campaign by campaign or keyword by keyword. A step whose rate moves with sales is a usable stand-in. One that holds up as sales fall is the trap Kalungi describes, and SaaS Hero found one keyword at a 2% rate of sales-qualified leads against another at 35%.
- Measure the lag from lead to step and from step to sale by month. Set the conversion window where most of it has arrived. PPC Rebels sets it on the day the cumulative curve reaches 90 to 95%, and Google takes uploads up to 90 days after the click, 63 with hashed customer data.
- Prove the CRM step you pick in a split beside the current setup rather than switching the whole account. Run it long enough for the step and some sales to arrive, and judge both sides on cost per closed sale from the CRM. Google asks for daily uploads for one to two conversion cycles first and evaluation over 2 conversion cycles or 2 weeks. Flighted reads closed deals over 60 to 90 or more days.
- On Google, send every step as its own conversion action and bid on one. Journey-aware bidding, which Google now runs in every Search campaign on Smart Bidding, can then learn from the rest. Attach the value from Sending lead value to Meta and Google to the step you bid on, using Lead Journey Mapping to lay out the stages.
Our judgment, built from Prose Media, Meta, Google, Jon Loomer, SaaS Hero, Kalungi, Silverback Strategies, PPC Rebels, Flighted and PPC Land: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
26 statements from 12 sourcesGoogle says Search Journey Awareness is a built-in Smart Bidding upgrade with no opt-in. It advises tracking shallow and deep conversions, bidding to the deepest as primary, and keeping conversion delays under 7 days.
“This is an enhancement to Smart Bidding and no action is required to opt-in.”
Google says to bid on a lead goal like qualified lead or booked appointment with at least 15 conversions in 30 days, ideally within 7 days of the click, uploading offline data daily and not mixing stages.
“Make sure the action generated at least 15 conversions in the last 30 days at the account level.”
Google says to bid on one funnel stage with a short delay and at least 15 conversions a month, and to allow at least 2 weeks or 3 conversion cycles before judging a value-based bidding test.
“allow for a ramp-up period of at least 2 weeks or 3 conversion cycles before evaluating performance”
Google suggests enhanced conversions for leads, optimized to qualified or converted leads, with uploads at least daily for 1 to 2 conversion cycles before bidding on them. A spreadsheet can stand in for a CRM.
“Upload conversions at least daily.”
Google Ads won't import offline conversions uploaded more than 90 days after the last click, or 63 days for enhanced conversions for leads. The longer clicks take to convert, the longer full numbers take.
“To validate whether your conversion imports are working, use the "All conv. (by conv. time)" column.”
Google says budget or target changes take effect at the next auction without triggering learning, but advises against several target changes in one conversion cycle and judging over 2 cycles or 2 weeks.
“Avoid making multiple target changes within a single conversion cycle unless there is a clear business need.”
To optimize lead ads to a CRM stage, Meta requires at least 200 leads a month, a stage that 1% to 40% of leads reach within 28 days, and CRM uploads at least daily. It gives no performance figures.
“Generate at least 200 leads per month”
Jon Loomer found an undocumented Meta option that credits a lead only when a first and a final event happen in order; eligibility seemed to need about 30 optimized events in 7 days.
“if you're barely getting 50 optimized leads per week per ad set now, you may not get enough data”
Google says journey-aware bidding is in beta for Search campaigns on Target CPA and Maximize conversions, and is turned on by importing the conversion actions in your lead journey.
“This backend upgrade is now available in beta for Search campaigns with Target CPA and Maximize conversions.”
Silverback Strategies, a lead gen agency, says lead-to-sale lag runs from days to months and shifts by season (one client: 70 days in September, 7 in April), so optimize to qualified leads once volume allows.
“One education client we work with sees a 70-day average lag for leads generated in September and a seven-day lag for the same programs in April”
PPC Rebels says to set each conversion window where the time-lag curve reaches 90 to 95% of conversions, and warns that changing a window breaks the data series and restarts learning.
“A window change is a break in the data series.”
Kalungi says qualified leads and dead signups often fire the same event, so Meta finds more of both; one B2B client's lead volume held for months as qualified conversations fell. Send a separate qualified-lead signal.
“A real, qualified lead and a completely dead signup both fire the same event, worth the same amount, to Meta's algorithm.”
Google's case study says an education provider bid on CRM-qualified leads in Search and reported 4X more registrations. Several changes ran together, with no control.
“ultimately driving a 4X increase in downstream student registrations”
Google's Lead Journey Mapping is a visual tool for mapping lead stages, delays and offline events; Google says it doesn't change performance by itself but helps find tracking gaps.
“In the short term, your Lead Journey Mapping doesn’t directly change campaign performance.”
Jon Loomer says to start lead forms with the fewest questions and add controls like SMS verification only once data shows a quality problem, aiming for 50 optimized events per ad set per week.
“Your goal should always be to get 50 optimized events per ad set per week.”
WEBRIS's Ryan Stewart says a Texas injury law firm optimizes Meta to signed cases, not leads, since 90 to 95% of leads are unqualified; results settle in months five and six, at about $1,500 per signed case.
“If you are optimizing for leads instead of signed cases you are telling the algorithm to find you the cheapest form fills, not the best clients.”
Flighted, an agency, says B2B advertisers should send Meta a lead event and a qualified-lead event, feed deals back through the Conversions API, and not judge results before a 60 to 90+ day sales cycle plays out.
“Feed Meta two conversion signals: a Lead event and a down-funnel Qualified-Lead event.”
Make, a CRM connection vendor, relays a Meta A/B test of 1,031 advertisers: Instant Form ads using Conversions API for CRM with the Conversion Leads goal had 21% lower cost per quality lead than the Leads goal.
“an average 21% lower cost per quality lead”
Zapier relays Meta: CRM-connected lead campaigns averaged 21% lower cost per quality lead on Instant Forms, with no sample. Optimize for a stage one-third to one-half of leads reach.
“roughly one-third to one-half of your leads”
Google announced journey-aware bidding in beta: Search campaigns on Target CPA can learn from both biddable and non-biddable goals across a tracked lead-to-sale journey. No results given.
“When you track your full lead to sales journey, Search Ads campaigns optimizing to a Target CPA will be able to learn from both biddable and non-biddable conversion goals.”
Jon Loomer says his own tests don't show Instant Forms bringing lower-quality leads; he tags leads who click an email within 30 days as quality leads and sends that event to Meta, with mixed results.
“my own tests do not reflect this quality drop-off”
Prose Media, an ad agency, says to bid on the latest lead stage that still has usable volume, often SQL or opportunity, rarely MQL, and to expect raw conversions to dip before quality improves. No data.
“Pick the latest stage that still gives you usable volume and shows up fast enough to matter this quarter.”
PPC Land relays Google Ads product managers: bid to the lowest funnel step that still has volume and signals value, which for long or sparse sales cycles may mean a qualified lead rather than a closed one.
“the lowest conversion action in the customer journey that will have volume and is a high-quality indicator of value.”
In a home services company's A/B test, bidding to CRM-recorded sale value instead of lead volume gave 335% more validated sales and 11% higher blended ROAS than control. No baseline, length or split given.
“A/B testing was leveraged to compare the old lead-focused (tCPA) strategy against the new revenue-focused (tROAS) model”
SaaS Hero, a B2B SaaS agency, cites one client keyword at $45 a lead with a 2% SQL rate against another at $120 a lead with 35%, and reports lead-to-SQL rate by campaign.
“Lead-to-SQL conversion rate by campaign, so underperforming segments are visible before budget compounds the problem”
Meta's guide says the Conversion Leads goal works only with Instant Forms and fits best with 200+ leads a month, daily CRM uploads, and a target stage reached within 28 days by 1% to 40% of leads.
“The Conversion Leads performance goal is currently only compatible with Facebook/Instagram’s Lead Ads (Instant Forms).”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer