Should we recruit Instagram creators who tag our Amazon listings, or send creator traffic to our own site?
Our answer
Use both. Let creators tag your Amazon listings for single products that already convert there, and give them a tagged site link for bundles and subscriptions. Judge creators on site and Amazon sales together.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 2 Amazon rules
- 1 dataset, 4 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 9 statements
- MCM
SLSA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentCreators choose the destination more than brands do. In a survey of 1,000 US creators, 45.5% would send shoppers to Amazon by choice, and 7.1% follow the brand’s requested destination (Levanta, creator affiliate platform).
Creators can tag your Amazon listings without any deal with you. A tap opens the Amazon app, and Amazon pays the commission (Meta). Paying them more through Creator Connections costs at least 10% of credited sales, with no say over which creators join (Canopy Management).
Your site wins where the offer or the customer matters. SalesDuo, an Amazon agency, sends creator shoppers to the site for bundles and subscriptions, and to Amazon for a simple purchase. Moving a site customer to Amazon is not automatically an extra sale (Stack Influence).
Creator demand can reach Amazon even when creators link elsewhere. Skullcandy saw its heavier TikTok creator and affiliate investment lift its own site and TikTok Shop, then Best Buy and Amazon sell-through within weeks.
Our judgment
- Give creators both links rather than picking one destination. Creators route shoppers mostly by their own choice, and SalesDuo and Stack Influence give the two destinations different jobs.
- Fund a Creator Connections bonus only on products that clear a 15% commission with room left for ads. Leave the Brand Referral Bonus out of creator math unless your bonus report shows it.
- Judge each creator on site and Amazon sales together, with a separate Attribution tag per creator. This stays consistent with Amazon Attribution for outside traffic and Crediting Meta for Amazon and retail sales.
- Point paid spend behind creator content at your site when it has a working pixel, consistent with Meta or Google ads to Amazon listings. Instagram’s Amazon tags open the Amazon app, and Meta’s pixel never sees an Amazon sale.
Our judgment, built from Levanta, SalesDuo, Stack Influence, Canopy Management, Amazon, Skullcandy and Meta: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
9 statements from 7 sourcesAmazon's Brand Referral Bonus pays an average 10% of qualifying sales from outside traffic tagged with Amazon Attribution, as credits against future referral fees, for US Brand Registry sellers.
“you can earn a bonus averaging 10% of qualifying sales when you drive traffic to products in the Amazon store from search, social media, and other sources.”
Instagram now lets eligible US creators add Amazon affiliate links to reels and feed posts. Taps open the Amazon app, Amazon pays the commission, and Instagram takes no cut.
“It’s free to add product links, and Instagram doesn’t take a cut of your affiliate earnings.”
Instagram says product links on creators' reels and posts drew about twice the clicks of links in their bio, per its internal September 2026 data. Clicks only, with no sales or method shown.
“In fact, product links on creators’ reels and posts drew about twice as many clicks as the links in their bio.”
Canopy Management, an Amazon agency, says Creator Connections means a fixed cost of sale: at least 10% commission on net price, a $5,000 budget, no choice of creators. It suits products with margin at 15% or more.
“It’s a poor fit for thin-margin products, because the rate can’t be lowered once the campaign is live.”
Canopy Management, an Amazon and Meta agency, says Meta's pixel never sees Amazon sales, so brands without a real DTC operation should send traffic direct with Attribution tags and judge on Attribution sales.
“Judge Meta campaigns on Attribution sales and new-to-brand purchases, never on Ads Manager’s view of the world.”
Stack Influence, an influencer agency, says moving a customer from your own store to Amazon is not an extra sale. Send shoppers to the exact product page, give each creator their own link and judge the whole path.
“Moving an existing customer from Shopify to Amazon is not automatically an additional sale.”
SalesDuo, an Amazon agency, says to give creators two links: Amazon for a simple purchase and your own store for bundles or subscriptions. Judge each by margin, returns and repeat value, not revenue alone.
“Do not judge the 2 destinations by revenue alone. Add creator commission, BRB credits, returns, fulfillment costs, and anticipated repeat margin.”
Levanta, a creator affiliate software vendor, surveyed 1,000 US creators: 45.5% would send shoppers to Amazon given a free choice, and just 7.1% follow the brand's requested destination.
“36.4% of creators said they decide brand by brand based on what pays best, the largest single response.”
Skullcandy's ecommerce head says more creator and affiliate investment on TikTok lifted its site and TikTok Shop, then Best Buy and Amazon sales within weeks; product registration data sent to ad platforms lifted TikTok conversion about 40%.
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer