Should we offer student, military or first-responder discounts?
Our answer
Offer one only to groups that already buy from you, as a verified and limited offer. Check eligibility on your own site with light details, never a national ID number. Judge it on the new customers it adds.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 3 datasets
- 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 5 sources
- 5 statements
- FSCRLPPI
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA student discount mostly wins students who were already considering you. Students most often find discounts through friends or at checkout rather than by searching, flytedesk (campus advertising platform) found in its student survey. So the discount converts more than it acquires.
How you verify matters more than how many steps it takes. In a survey for SheerID, 43% of consumers said they would drop a discount check that asks for a Social Security or national ID number, against 12% over too many steps.
Many large brands cap or narrow their military discounts. Of 58 brands checked against their own terms, 18 publish a limit, such as The Home Depot's $400 a year, and six offer none, including REI and Best Buy (Claim Raven, veterans claims data firm).
Our judgment
Offer the discount only to groups that already show up among your buyers, because flytedesk found student discounts mostly convert students who were already considering a brand. Check eligibility with light details on your own site and cap the savings per order or per year, from SheerID’s survey on what makes people abandon verification and the limits large brands publish on their military programs. Judge it on margin given away per added new customer, from a holdout as for any discount (Measuring the cost of discounts), against what paid ads cost per new customer, because a discount that mostly reaches buyers already in the market costs margin on sales you would have made, combining Proxi.id’s program metric with flytedesk’s finding.
Our judgment, built from flytedesk, SheerID, Claim Raven and Proxi.id: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
5 statements from 5 sourcesIn a SheerID survey of 2,001 consumers, 43% said they would abandon a discount if asked for an ID or SSN, and 67% prefer to verify on the brand's site. These are stated intentions, not purchase data.
Lorenzo Pravata's read of AG1's ads finds five customer personas, each sent to its own landing page so the ad's promise matches the page's first screen. It has no traffic or conversion data.
“Each persona gets its own landing page, so the promise in the ad matches the first screen of the page.”
Claim Raven checked 58 heavily searched brands: 52 offer a military discount, 22 of them online only, and 18 publish a limit such as a yearly cap. Terms only, no sales or abuse figures.
“ID.me and SheerID check that you served. They don't decide who the brand includes.”
Proxi.id, a discount verification vendor, says to treat verified group discounts as an acquisition channel and compare their cost per new customer with paid acquisition cost. Its figures are rules of thumb.
“The mistake is setting the discount by what you can afford rather than by what changes behaviour for that specific group.”
flytedesk, a campus ad seller, says 70% of students redeemed a student discount, mostly found through friends or at checkout, so discounts convert rather than acquire. No sample size given.
“Student discounts are typically doing retention and conversion work, not acquisition”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- What the research saysWhat academic research adds, kept apart from the answer
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer