How should we handle unengaged subscribers?
Our answer
Send less as subscribers go quiet. After about 180 days with no clicks, visits or orders, send a sunset flow of 1 to 3 emails. Then suppress, not delete, anyone who still doesn't respond.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 official rules
- 1 dataset, 4 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 14 statements
- KL
GYOZDS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentKlaviyo's sunset segment flags profiles at least 180 days old that have never opened, clicked, visited or ordered. It limits the flow to 1 to 3 emails and keeps anyone who clicked or bought in the last 6 months.
Sending less can raise clicks. After a rewarm, one brand cut monthly email sends about 75% and got nearly its most real clicks of the year, with revenue up. When it about doubled volume again, real clicks fell about 20% (Pilothouse).
Mailing people who don't read hurts delivery, Yahoo says. Google tells bulk senders to keep spam rates below 0.1% and never reach 0.3%.
Suppress people who don't come back. Litmus (email testing software maker) advises that, and advises trying older addresses only in very small increments. Top Growth Marketing sunsets anyone unengaged for 180 or more days.
Our judgment
Start the sunset at about 180 days without clicks, site visits or orders. That applies Klaviyo's sunset segment, which takes never-engaged profiles once they are 180 days old, and Top Growth Marketing's sunset after 180 or more days unengaged to subscribers who have gone quiet, with Omnisend's 90 days as the point to start sending less. Judge quiet on clicks, site visits and purchases rather than opens alone, because Klaviyo says Apple Mail Privacy Protection can record an open without a read and Litmus says proxy opens skew opens. Suppress rather than delete. Klaviyo's email suppression stops marketing email and takes the profile off the active profile count while it can still receive texts, and Litmus advises suppressing those who don't re-engage.
Our judgment, built from Klaviyo, Top Growth Marketing, Omnisend and Litmus: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
14 statements from 9 sourcesGmail requires senders of 5,000+ messages a day to authenticate and offer easy unsubscribe, and says to keep spam rates below 0.1% and never reach 0.3%. It recommends honoring unsubscribes within 48 hours.
“senders should keep their spam rate below 0.1% and should prevent spam rates from ever reaching 0.3% or higher”
Yahoo tells senders to mail only active, engaged recipients, remove invalid addresses promptly, reconfirm inactive subscribers now and then, and keep bulk complaint rates below 0.3%.
“Sending email to users who are not reading them, or who report them as spam, will harm your delivery metrics and reputation.”
Pilothouse describes one brand whose email click-through had fallen to about 0.2%. Cutting September volume about 75% brought near its highest real clicks of the year, and doubling volume in October cut clicks about 20%.
Selzy's data from 388,431 campaigns on its platform shows 83.5% of unsubscribers who gave a reason were no longer interested, and 6.8% said emails came too often. Silent non-openers are not counted.
“There is one important limit: people who simply stop opening emails do not appear in this data.”
Litmus, which sells deliverability tools, says to clean lists before the holidays, suppress people who ignore a re-engagement campaign, and start the volume ramp in September.
“Start your ramp-up in September, not October”
Litmus, part of deliverability seller Validity, says engagement is mailbox providers' main trust signal, spam complaints should stay below 0.1%, and invalid addresses should be removed promptly.
“A list full of disengaged subscribers doesn’t just waste budget, it hurts your sender reputation.”
Top Growth Marketing, which sells Klaviyo management, says unengaged subscribers should get about one campaign a month and be sunset after 180+ days, and soft-bounced addresses excluded to protect domain reputation.
“Subscribers who’ve soft-bounced 2-3 times should be excluded temporarily, as continuing to send hurts your domain reputation.”
Klaviyo's help page says a sunset flow phases out unengaged customers, then deletes or suppresses non-responders so they do not count toward your active profile limit. Suppression does not stop SMS.
“Email suppression does not affect a profile’s ability to receive SMS messages or push notifications.”
Ben Zettler, a Klaviyo consultant, says sending on opens can hurt deliverability because opens are unreliable, and wide sends should exclude subscribers who got many messages without engaging.
“These exclusions protect deliverability, reduce wasted sends, and improve relevance.”
Klaviyo warns that Apple Mail Privacy Protection can record opens nobody read, and suggests a separate re-engagement segment for lapsed subscribers and tighter criteria if clicks fall or complaints rise.
“Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) can record an open without the recipient reading your email.”
Klaviyo suggests sending by engagement: for a brand sending 3 times a week, 3 a week to people engaged in 60 days, fewer as engagement ages, and a sunset flow for profiles silent past 180 days.
“Sending too often to unengaged profiles will hurt your sender reputation, whereas sending too infrequently to engaged customers is leaving money on the table.”
Klaviyo suggests starting SMS at 2-4 sends a month, ramping to 4-7, up to 1 to 2 a week for highly engaged subscribers, and excluding people with no click in 150 days from most campaigns.
“Do not send SMS every day unless the subscriber knowingly opted in to daily reminders”
Omnisend, which sells email and SMS, defines engagement segments as active (opened or clicked within 30 days), disengaged (nothing in 30 days) and inactive (90 days or more). No data behind the windows.
“Customers who haven’t engaged with your emails for 90 days or more”
Klaviyo defines an engaged segment as opened or clicked in 30 days or subscribed in 15, says sending to unengaged lists hurts deliverability, and shows how to filter out Apple privacy opens.
“Sending to unengaged subscribers puts your sender reputation and deliverability at risk.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer