All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

How do we move subscribers to a new subscription app without losing renewals?

The PrevailingPublished Nov 17, 2026

Our answer

Before you set a date, find out where each subscriber's card is stored. Then switch billing on one day, keep the old app installed with billing off, and point every portal link at the new app.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
8 official rules
3 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
Sources
8 sources
13 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Cards saved in Shopify stay with the store, and the new app bills them (Everboost, Skio). Cards at an outside gateway, common on legacy Recharge checkout, must be moved over. Shopify's paid card migration can't move PayPal billing agreements or wallets such as Apple Pay.

A new app copies each subscription as a fresh contract, since one app can't take over another's (Skio). Until the old app stops billing, both can charge the same subscriber. Uninstall it too early and Shopify cancels its live contracts after 48 hours.

Subscribers are lost after the move, not in the transfer. Kaspian Fuad, a Shopify consultant, finds dead portal links and failed first charges without retries cause the churn. The Night Marketer, a Shopify subscription agency, finds most problems at the first two renewals.

Our judgment

  • Treat where each card is stored as the question that sets the plan. Cards saved in Shopify need no move, cards at an outside gateway need a secondary gateway and a token transfer, and anything else needs a new card from the customer before the next charge. This reconciles Craftshift’s warning that tokens don’t move freely between apps with the point that cards saved in Shopify stay with the store.
  • Send subscribers a short email before cutover even though Loop runs a silent switch, because the portal link changes and a subscriber who can’t find it cancels.

Our judgment, built from Shopify, Skio, Loop Subscriptions, Everboost, Craftshift, Kaspian Fuad and The Night Marketer: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

13 statements from 8 sources
  • ShopifyUndatedSupports

    Shopify says cards vaulted in Shopify need no migration to change gateways, but with a secondary gateway, payment methods move one at a time as customers update them, which can take months or years.

    “it can take months or even years to fully migrate all payment methods”

    Read it on help.shopify.com

  • ShopifyUndatedSupports

    Shopify's developer docs say that 48 hours after a subscription app is uninstalled, the subscription contracts it owns that haven't been terminated are cancelled, including active and paused ones.

    “48 hours after a user uninstalls a subscription app, any subscription contracts that are owned by that app and that haven't been terminated are cancelled.”

    Read it on shopify.dev

  • ShopifyUndatedSupports

    Shopify's help page says a CSV file can move subscription contracts from a third-party subscriptions app into Shopify Subscriptions, or export them to another Shopify store with the app.

    “You can use a CSV (comma-separated values) file to import contracts from a third-party subscriptions app”

    Read it on help.shopify.com

  • Loop SubscriptionsUndatedSupports

    Loop, a subscription app maker, says its migration is a silent switch with no customer notices. Shopify won't move payment tokens between two stores, so those customers are asked to update their cards.

    “No customer will be notified during the migration. It’s a completely silent switch.”

    Read it on help.loopwork.co

  • Loop SubscriptionsUndatedSupports

    Loop's guide to moving from Recharge says Loop cancels the Recharge contracts in bulk after migration so no one is charged twice, and warns the migrated count will be lower than Recharge reports.

    “The migrated subscription count will be lower than the count reported in recharge.”

    Read it on help.loopwork.co

  • Loop SubscriptionsUndatedSupports

    Loop says Shopify vaults payment tokens but billing stays with your outside provider until a customer updates their card in Shopify. Token import works from six listed providers, and Adyen tokens can't be migrated.

    “Shopify vaults the tokens, but billing will continue with your external provider unless the customer updates their payment method natively in Shopify.”

    Read it on help.loopwork.co

  • The Night MarketerOct 29, 2026Supports

    The Night Marketer, an agency that sells subscription migrations, advises recording renewals first, switching off old billing first on a quiet day, and keeping the old app until two billing cycles check out.

    “Pick one cutover moment, switch off old billing first, and keep the old app installed until two billing cycles check out.”

    Read it on thenightmarketer.com

  • EverboostJul 22, 2026Supports

    Everboost, an agency with Loop partner links, reports Recharge bought rival Skio on 30 April 2026 for a reported $105 million and no pricing promises were made. It says month-to-month terms are worth the premium now.

    “Month-to-month is worth the premium right now.”

    Read it on everboost.co.uk

  • Kaspian FuadJun 28, 2026Supports

    Kaspian Fuad, a Shopify consultant who sells migration work, says apps move the contracts but subscribers churn over theme issues like a hard-to-find portal. He expects 14 to 21 days to the first billed cycle.

    “This is the single biggest silent churn driver, because a subscriber who cannot find how to skip or swap a delivery does not email you. They cancel.”

    Read it on kaspianfuad.com

  • CraftshiftApr 10, 2026Caveat

    Craftshift, which sells other Shopify apps, says start with Shopify's native Subscriptions app and move to Recharge or Loop when subscriptions pass about 30% of revenue. Payment tokens do not transfer freely. No data.

    “Starting from zero? Use the native Shopify Subscriptions app.”

    Read it on craftshift.com

  • SkioMar 18, 2026Supports

    Skio says it copies subscriptions rather than moving them, since Shopify contracts can't be taken over by another app, and it won't bill migrated subscriptions until the old platform has stopped charging.

    “Shopify subscription contracts created by one app are not able to be "taken over" by a different app.”

    Read it on help.skio.com

  • RechargeDec 16, 2025Disagrees

    Recharge, grading its own migration service, says it handles payment token transfer so customers needn't re-enter payment details, and claims thousands of migrations. No method or data shown.

    “customers don’t need to checkout out again, or re-enter their payment info”

    Read it on getrecharge.com

  • SkioNov 20, 2025Caveat

    Skio says moving subscriptions to a different Shopify store needs each customer to have a valid payment method saved in the new store, and it cannot migrate Shop Pay payment methods between stores.

    “The Skio team is unable to migrate ShopPay payment methods from store A to store B.”

    Read it on help.skio.com

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Subscriptions