Should we offer free shipping, and where should the free shipping threshold sit relative to our average order?
Our answer
Offer free shipping above a threshold about 15 to 25% above your typical order, within reach of one add-on. Show it on product pages and in the cart, and test it on margin per visitor.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 4 datasets, 4 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 13 statements
BCDABI
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA threshold earns more than free shipping on every order. In a model of a $60 order store at 60% margin, margin per order peaks at a $70 threshold, at $37 against $22 for free shipping on every order (Eightx).
Shoppers rank free shipping above price. Of 1,010 US adults, 57% put free shipping first when choosing where to shop, ahead of lowest price at 45%, and 56% expect it once they spend $25 to $49 (Bizrate Insights).
The free shipping threshold is easy to set wrong in both directions. Jones Road cut its threshold from $85 to $55 after pushing order value to about $110, and it went too high and too low (Cody Plofker).
Our judgment
- Anchor the threshold to the median or most common order, not the mean. Blend Commerce and Digital Applied both say large orders pull the mean up. We set it 15 to 25% above, where Eightx's model peaks and inside Blend Commerce's 10 to 30% gap.
- Make a threshold the default and free shipping on every order the exception. Eightx's model finds free shipping on everything the worst option for a $60 order store. Bizrate Insights and Baymard Institute show that shipping charges shoppers did not expect drive them away.
- Keep a free standard option and price faster delivery separately. In ICSC's survey, 90% would accept slower shipping to save money and 40% would pay nothing for faster delivery.
- Recheck the threshold against your own orders and parcel costs rather than raising it because others do. Most retail executives in Deloitte's survey plan to raise theirs, while Jones Road found it had gone too high and too low.
Our judgment, built from Eightx, Blend Commerce, Digital Applied, Bizrate Insights, Baymard Institute, ICSC, Deloitte and Cody Plofker: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 13 sourcesPPC Land says a free shipping threshold far above the typical basket is ignored, while one at or below it pays for delivery on orders that would happen anyway. DHL: 67% of 29,000 shoppers abandoned a cart over delivery.
“A threshold far above the typical basket is ignored. One at or below it pays for delivery on orders that would have been placed anyway.”
Cody Plofker says Jones Road cut its free shipping threshold from $85 to $55 after raising order value to about $110, going too high and too low. Winks launched at $86 and needed lower prices to get signal.
“we went too high and too low”
Over Labor Day 2026, 34% of 3,000+ Shopify brands ran an offer. Discounters' revenue lift fell to 22% from 31%, brands without offers gained 3%, and 20%+ discounts lifted revenue 89%. Revenue, not profit.
“a token discount costs you margin and buys you nothing. Go meaningful or skip it.”
Zach Stuck lists page fixes he says lift conversion for his clients: show subtotal, shipping and total in the cart drawer, make free shipping obvious, and show a ship-by date and payment options. No figures.
“your draw cart should probably show the subtotal, the cost of shipping, and then the total”
ICSC's May 2026 survey of 1,000 US adults: 90% would accept slower shipping to save money, the median maximum wait for free standard delivery is five days, and 40% would pay nothing for faster delivery.
“Seventy percent of consumers who shop online frequently or occasionally abandon carts because of shipping costs”
Blend Commerce, which sells Shopify CRO, says to set a free shipping threshold from the median order plus a common add-on price, so the gap is 10 to 30% of the median. A rule of thumb with no data.
“Use MEDIAN, not average. The median shows typical order; AOV is skewed by large outliers.”
Avi Mascowitz says segmenting by cart value and buyer type and A/B testing free shipping thresholds lets his team raise average order value 18%.
“we're able to increase the average order value by 18%.”
Eightx, a CFO firm, advises a free shipping threshold about 15 to 25% above current AOV; its model, on assumed inputs, has margin per order peaking at a $70 threshold for a $60 AOV.
“Set your free shipping threshold about 15 to 25 percent above current AOV, not at it.”
Digital Applied says to set a free shipping threshold a step above the most common basket, not a multiple of the average order, and that if over 80% of orders clear it you are giving shipping away.
“Set the threshold a tractable step above the mode, not a generic multiple above the outlier-inflated mean.”
Bizrate's March 2026 survey of 1,010 US adults: 57% rank free shipping first when choosing where to shop, ahead of lowest price at 45%, and 56% expect it once they spend $25 to $49.
“Retailers who set their free shipping threshold above $50 are likely triggering abandonment”
Baymard puts average cart abandonment at 70.22%. Of US shoppers who left, 39% cited unexpected extra costs and 19% forced account creation, so it recommends guest checkout as the default.
“Prioritize guest checkout as the default path, deferring registration until after the order is confirmed.”
Deloitte's survey of 330 retail executives found 73% plan to raise prices gradually, 72% to shift mix toward higher-margin items and 67% to raise free shipping thresholds. These are plans, not results.
“Nearly all executives surveyed anticipate higher costs in 2026 due to changes in global trade policies.”
In one 8-figure adult wellness brand's sitewide Intelligems test, a $59 free shipping threshold beat $49 on profit per visitor ($4.36 vs $4.09), while $75 did worse ($3.97). Sample and significance not given.
“The goal: find the threshold that maximizes profit per visitor, not just conversion or just AOV.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer