Should we run Google Demand Gen campaigns, and how should a first one be set up next to Performance Max?
Our answer
Add Demand Gen once Search and Performance Max pay off. Fund at least $100 a day, about $3,000 a month, as one campaign for new customers on a purchase goal. Judge it by a holdout on total sales.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 9 Google rules
- 4 datasets, 4 practitioners
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 17 statements
- G
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentDemand Gen and Performance Max do different jobs. Demand Gen runs image and video ads on YouTube, Discover, Gmail, Maps and the Display Network, with hard audience targeting and channel choice. Performance Max spans every Google channel, Search included, with no hard targeting (Google).
Run for sales, Demand Gen pays about like your other channels. In Haus's geo tests it returned 0.98 times what the same brands' other channels did. Measured, a testing firm, found a median incremental ROAS of $1.81 for ecommerce brands.
A thin budget never learns. Google asks for at least $100 a day per ad group and 20 times your Target CPA, and says not to judge before 50 conversions. Fospha, a measurement firm, suggests about $130 a day per campaign.
It fails where buyers decide fast or goals are soft. AdwService, a Google Ads agency, found no significant effect in one low-margin store and wants margin above 25% first. One client's 243 extra add-to-carts came from kids' channels (Menachem Ani).
Our judgment
We add Demand Gen only after Search and Performance Max pay off, following Tsvi Machluf's advice not to add it while Shopping is unprofitable or the account gets about 30 conversions a month. That matches the 10 to 20% share Splitting spend across Google campaign types gives it once funded. We budget to Google's stricter 20 times Target CPA over the 10 times on its overview page, since its product manager's $100 a day and Fospha's $130 a day also point higher. We put the first campaign on purchases rather than the add-to-basket events Google's overview suggests, because Menachem Ani's client saw a soft goal filled from kids' channels.
Our judgment, built from Tsvi Machluf, Google, Fospha and Menachem Ani: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
17 statements from 10 sourcesGoogle says Demand Gen gives more control over audiences, creative testing and placements on YouTube and Discover than Performance Max, and recommends a budget of at least 10 times Target CPA.
“For campaigns using target CPA bidding, Google Ads recommends setting a budget that's at least 10 times your target CPA.”
Menachem Ani, an agency owner, says one client's 243 extra add-to-carts came almost entirely from a Demand Gen campaign on kids' YouTube channels. Add to cart is a soft signal the system fills cheaply.
“Add to cart is a soft signal, and the system will find the cheapest way to produce it.”
Google's Demand Gen advice: use optimized targeting on prospecting, remarketing for first-party segments, the new customer acquisition goal for new buyers, and wait for 50 conversions before judging.
“Do not evaluate performance until the campaign has generated at least 50 conversions.”
Google says Display Ads campaigns are moving into Demand Gen as Google Display Network. New ones can only be created there, and existing ones stay editable until migrated. Timelines may change.
“New Google Display Ads campaigns can only be created within Demand Gen.”
Google's Demand Gen guide says include at least 3 images or videos in each aspect ratio per ad group, favor native vertical video for Shorts, and swap out low performers.
Google says Demand Gen value-based bidding needs 50 conversions with value in 35 days (10 in the last 7), or 100 across the account. It advises a tROAS 20% below your historical average and no changes for 14 days.
“Set tROAS 20% lower than your historical average ROAS to initiate your campaign.”
Google's Demand Gen A/B experiments test creative, audience, feed or bidding, not budget, with a 50% split. Results need at least 50 conversions per arm, so Google suggests shallow goals like Add to Cart.
“We don't recommend testing the budget as a variable at this time.”
Google says view-through conversion bidding is on by default for new Demand Gen campaigns, counting views of 1 pixel on screen. It recommends a 1-day window and warns longer ones inflate reported conversions.
“The recommended window for primary VTCs is 1 day. If you set it at a higher window, you can expect a surge in primary VTCs reported.”
Google advises Demand Gen budgets of at least 20 times your target CPA, and says at least $100 a day per ad group helps avoid a cold start. Ad groups with more than 50 conversions perform better.
“a minimum daily budget of at least $100 USD per day, per ad group will help avoid a cold start.”
Haus's geo tests find YouTube Demand Gen returns about the same as a brand's other channels (0.98x), and a brand's first YouTube test now lands at 0.92x, up from 0.64x. Haus calls these comparisons directional.
“In the Demand Gen era, Demand Gen tests land right at parity with the brand's other channels (0.98x).”
A Google product manager called a $100 daily budget the bare minimum best practice for a Demand Gen campaign; PPC Land notes that is about $3,000 a month.
“described a $100 daily budget as the minimum best-practice level for a Demand Gen campaign”
smec data reported by PPC Land says product feed use in Demand Gen rose from 16% in 2024 to 35% in 2026, and smec warns feed-based Demand Gen overlaps heavily with Performance Max.
“Demand Gen has drifted down the funnel and increased its channel overlap with PMax”
Fospha, a measurement vendor, found across 25 retail ecommerce brands that those putting 10 to 20% of Google budget into Demand Gen had 100% higher Google ROAS than those at 0 to 5%. That is association, not cause.
“the strongest results come from funding it with incremental investment rather than reallocating from PMax or Search.”
Tsvi Machluf, a Google Ads consultant, says Demand Gen fills a mid-funnel remarketing gap between PMax and Shopping, but needs 1,000+ users and enough conversions, and doesn't pay for cheap quick buys.
“If your Shopping campaigns are not yet profitable, adding Demand Gen is spending money to build awareness you cannot convert.”
AdwService, which sells Google Ads management, found no significant Demand Gen effect on sales in one e-commerce account over about 18 months. It says only a holdout can prove incremental value.
“we found no statistically significant effect of Demand Gen on conversion rate, sales, or lower-campaign attribution value.”
Brett Curry, relaying Haus's study of 190 tests, says in-platform reporting undercounts YouTube by about 70%. One retail matched-market test showed about 25% sales lift over eight weeks.
“If you see a one ROAS in platform for YouTube, you're probably actually getting a 3.4 ROAS”
Measured, which sells incrementality testing, found 86% of 68 Demand Gen studies showed significant sales lift; for ecommerce, conversion-optimized Demand Gen returned a median $1.81 incremental ROAS.
“In-platform reporting can underreport the incremental value of YouTube placements by as much as four times.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer