Which conversion window, attribution model and counting settings should our Google conversion actions use (click, engaged-view and view-through windows; primary or secondary actions)?
Our answer
Make only the sale or qualified lead primary and keep other actions secondary. Count every purchase but one lead per click, start with a 30-day click and 1-day view-through window, and keep data-driven attribution.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 14 Google rules
- 10 practitioners, 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 15 sources
- 31 statements
- G
PL
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentGoogle bids only on primary actions in a campaign's goals, and a secondary action in a custom goal still counts. Adgenix finds it the setting most often wrong, and Sarah Stemen and Brandrocket call wrong primary actions common.
Google counts every conversion for sales and one per click for leads. It defaults to 30 days of click and 1 day of view-through and advises at least 7 days of click. PPC Rebels fits the window to 90 to 95% of your time lag.
Longer windows credit sales other channels made. Social Surge says click windows of 60 to 90 days and view-through windows of 7 to 14 days do this. Adgenix keeps every purchase and lets the transaction ID drop duplicates.
Our judgment
- Make one action per business outcome primary and leave the rest secondary. Google advises one default goal per funnel, and Adgenix, Sarah Stemen and Brandrocket each find add to cart, page views or checkout starts set primary as the commonest error. Brandrocket also finds real calls and forms left secondary.
- Count every purchase and remove duplicates with the transaction ID. Google's one-per-click setting records only one conversion per ad click, which would drop a second real order from the same click.
- Start from Google's 30-day click window and change it only from your own time lag report. Google's default and Social Surge's ecommerce rule agree on 30 days, and PPC Rebels sets the window where 90 to 95% of conversions have landed. Make the change in a quiet period, because it applies only going forward and sends the strategy back into learning.
- Keep view-through at 1 day, engaged-view at Google's default and data-driven attribution on. This matches YouTube and Demand Gen for sales. A longer view-through window usually raises the count Google records, Google does not export these conversions to other systems, and Social Surge caps the two at 1 and 7 days. Data-driven is Google's default, last click is the only alternative left, Google says the two can give the same results depending on data, and the setting also changes what bid strategies optimize on.
- For lead and local businesses, make the deepest outcome that still gives each campaign enough conversions primary, such as a booked appointment, a qualified lead or a real call, and upload the later sale from your CRM. Cardinal Digital Marketing wants 20 to 30 conversions per campaign a month on the signal it bids on and uses offline CRM outcomes. PPC Rebels keeps a fast qualifying action primary and uploads the final sale, and Google counts one lead per click. Keep Maps direction clicks and other local engagements secondary, since a direction click is not money in the business by itself. Google offers local actions as a goal in Performance Max for store goals, which is built to drive visits. The same settings apply at every monthly spend, because the sources set them by outcome, time lag and conversion counts rather than spend.
Our judgment, built from Google, Adgenix, Sarah Stemen, BrandRocket, Social Surge, PPC Rebels, Relevant Audience and Cardinal Digital Marketing: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
31 statements from 15 sourcesGoogle says Search Journey Awareness is a built-in Smart Bidding upgrade with no opt-in. It advises tracking shallow and deep conversions, bidding to the deepest as primary, and keeping conversion delays under 7 days.
“This is an enhancement to Smart Bidding and no action is required to opt-in.”
One Reddit advertiser's Google Ads account reported 436 conversions in 9 days, but 403 were Maps actions and 7 real lead forms. A commenter advises counting only lead forms and longer calls as primary.
“lead form submit plus calls from ads with a minimum duration (60 seconds is a common cutoff) as primary”
Menachem Ani, an agency owner, says one client's 243 extra add-to-carts came almost entirely from a Demand Gen campaign on kids' YouTube channels. Add to cart is a soft signal the system fills cheaply.
“Add to cart is a soft signal, and the system will find the cheapest way to produce it.”
Brad Geddes lists common Google Ads tracking mistakes: not tracking calls, appointments and chat leads, and wrongly marking conversions as primary or secondary, which skews Smart Bidding.
“incorrectly classify conversions as primary or secondary”
Google says primary conversion actions are reported and used for bidding, while secondary ones are for reporting only unless part of a custom goal. Conversions imported from Google Analytics start as secondary.
“are for observation only. They are used for reporting in the “All conversions” column in your reports, but not for bidding”
Google recommends optimizing all campaigns toward the same account-default conversion goals, and for a shoe retailer setting Purchase as the default. It calls custom goals advanced and not recommended in most cases.
“If you have multiple standard conversion goals tracking different stages of the same conversion funnel, we recommend that you set only one of them as the account-default goal.”
Google says count every conversion for sales and one per click for leads; changes to counting apply only to future reporting.
“Any changes to conversion count settings will only apply to future conversion reporting.”
Google's default conversion windows are 30 days for clicks, 3 days for engaged views and 1 day for views. It recommends at least 7 days for clicks, and changes apply only going forward.
“Note that windows of at least 7 days are recommended, because they provide a richer set of conversion data.”
Google's beta multi-source conversions add backend data, such as a CRM, to a tag-based conversion action. Duplicates are removed only within one conversion action, and the backend becomes the source of truth for value.
“Google Ads only removes duplicate data within a single conversion action (between the tag and the additional data source), not across two different conversion actions.”
Greg Finn says to turn on the Action optimization column in Google Ads' new All Conversions tab to see whether a conversion action is primary or secondary.
“It's a column that you need to enable when you use this called action optimization. And that's where their primary or secondary lives.”
Greg Finn says Google Ads' new All Conversions tab makes it easier to audit conversion settings, such as mismatched attribution windows and inconsistent counting across actions.
“Being able to see all that in one spot, that we haven't even made a change to a campaign yet. Just being able to lay everything out and see apples to apples comparison.”
Google recommends at least 10 locations for Performance Max store visit goals (5 for local actions), 30 days minimum, and 1 to 2 conversion cycles before judging.
“Wait for 1-2 complete conversion cycles before fully evaluating your campaign performance”
Google counts an engaged-view conversion after 10 seconds of a skippable in-stream ad or 5 seconds of an in-feed or Shorts ad, and includes them in the Conversions column.
“You’ll find Engaged-view conversions included in both the “Conversions” and the “All conversions” columns”
Google says view-through conversions exclude people who interacted with your other ads and, outside a few campaign types, are for reporting only. A longer window usually records more of them.
“A longer view-through conversion window will usually increase the number of view-through conversions Google Ads records.”
Google says view-through conversion bidding is on by default for new Demand Gen campaigns, counting views of 1 pixel on screen. It recommends a 1-day window and warns longer ones inflate reported conversions.
“The recommended window for primary VTCs is 1 day. If you set it at a higher window, you can expect a surge in primary VTCs reported.”
Google says Smart Bidding's Learning status lasts up to 7 days while ads keep serving, budget or target changes never trigger it, and results should be judged over 2 conversion cycles or 2 weeks.
“If you have past conversion data in your account, Smart Bidding never starts from scratch.”
An Australian Google Ads agency says an ecommerce primary conversion should be a completed purchase counted once per order with its value; add to cart and views belong in secondary. No counts.
“For an ecommerce store, a primary conversion in Google Ads should be a completed purchase, recorded once per order, with the order value attached.”
Google's data-driven attribution, the default for most conversion actions, splits credit across your Google ad interactions. Any volume qualifies, but Google recommends 200 conversions and 2,000 interactions in 30 days.
“Depending on data availability, the last click and data-driven attribution models can have the same results in certain situations.”
Google has dropped first click, linear, time decay and position-based attribution, moving those conversion actions to data-driven; last click remains. The model also changes what bid strategies optimize on.
“The first click, linear, time decay, and position-based attribution models are no longer supported by Google”
Search Engine Roundtable reports a new Google help document on multi-source conversions (beta), which connects a website conversion action to a backend source such as a CRM or order database.
“Multi-source conversions allow advertisers to connect an existing website conversion action with an additional backend data source, such as a CRM or order database”
Arin Gharapetian says lead gen conversion tracking should fire only once per lead, not several times, so the bidding system isn't confused.
“let's say for a lead, you only want to have make sure the conversion fires once not more than once.”
Savvy Revenue, a Google Ads agency, says to import profit as a secondary conversion for 30 days, set the first target at the profit return you already get, then switch in weekly steps. Skip it under heavy promotions.
“you cannot simply set your target to the new POAS number on day one”
BrandRocket, which sells Google Ads management, says from 76 audits of 66 accounts that only actions that by themselves mean money, like a purchase or quote request, belong as primary conversions.
“does this, by itself, represent money in the business? If not, it belongs in secondary.”
PPC Rebels says to set each conversion window where the time-lag curve reaches 90 to 95% of conversions, and warns that changing a window breaks the data series and restarts learning.
“A window change is a break in the data series.”
Craig Graham says not to set different actions, like add to cart and purchase, as primary conversions in Google Ads. Feed bidding as much end-goal data as possible.
“I don't necessarily agree with is having multiple primary conversion actions that are for different things”
Relevant Audience, relaying Google, says Demand Gen view-through bidding becomes video-only, expands to the Display Network, and is on by default for new campaigns. Google gave no rollout dates.
“Separate the conversion column you report on from the one you optimise on.”
Google Analytics now lets you set click-through conversion windows to any whole number from 1 to 90 days and engaged-view windows from 1 to 30 days (previously fixed at 3 days).
“Edit EVC conversion windows to any integer from 1 to 30 days (previously fixed at 3 days).”
Social Surge, an agency, sets ecommerce Google windows at 30-day click, 7-day engaged view and 1-day view, saying longer windows over-credit Google. Expect reported ROAS to drop after the change.
“Expect reported ROAS to drop after the change, and hold your nerve.”
Cardinal Digital Marketing says to optimize toward the deepest signal with enough volume, at least 20 to 30 conversions per campaign a month, using CRM outcomes since some booking tracking overcounted 60%.
“The goal is always to optimize toward the best signal you can get enough volume from”
Sarah Stemen says Smart Bidding should have one primary conversion tied to revenue, with cart adds and clicks kept secondary, and to allow 7 to 14 days after changes, or 30 days after a full cleanup.
“Confirm a single primary conversion that maps directly to revenue.”
Measured, which sells incrementality tests, says across hundreds of tests 62% of view-optimized YouTube conversions were net new against 46% for Demand Gen, and urges turning on view-through optimization.
“Pair it with an incrementality test to validate the new signal is driving results.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer