How do we stop affiliates and coupon sites from claiming sales we would make anyway?
Our answer
Switch off your biggest coupon or cashback partners in one market to see if total sales fall. Bar bidding on your name plus coupon, and forced clicks. Pay coupon partners less than partners who bring new customers.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 8 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 9 statements
HGTLBBBES
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentLast-click reports credit coupon and cashback partners with buyers already at checkout. When one global consumer brand switched off its US cashback and loyalty partners for 7 weeks, Haus (incrementality testing platform) measured no change in US revenue against 7 markets left on.
Some partners claim sales without a click at all. Bloomberg reports Phia's extension set its cookie automatically from December 2025 to July 2026. Ben Edelman (advertising consultant) measured affiliate clicks in more than 50% of its checkout sessions, up from less than 10%.
Coupon sites also win the last click through search. Shoppers leave checkout to search your name plus coupon and an aggregator becomes the last stop (Loren Baker, SEO agency founder). Track360 advises barring partners from bidding on those searches, since you pay twice.
Coupon partners still have a place. Hamster Garage (affiliate agency) argues they add sales on clearance, new program launches and exclusive offers, and advises paying them 3 to 5% against 8 to 10% for content partners where a test shows they mostly catch existing buyers.
Our judgment
Start with the largest coupon or cashback partner and switch it off in one market against markets left on, since Haus says these partners can’t be split by user or region. Set each partner’s rate on what a test shows rather than on last-click sales, paying coupon and cashback partners less or only on first-time buyers. Treat clicks fired without a shopper’s action as a breach of contract to enforce through your network, with commission reversed, since network rules already forbid them and Impact.com reallocated commissions Phia had not been paid.
Our judgment, built from Haus, Hamster Garage, Track360, Ben Edelman, Bloomberg and Shopifreaks: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
9 statements from 9 sourcesGoogle AI Overviews, ChatGPT and other AI engines now give shoppers merchant coupon codes in their answers, so shoppers can skip coupon sites. One observer tells brands to post current codes on their own promo page.
“put the real, current code on your official promo page. Otherwise AI will pick whatever it finds on Reddit.”
Hamster Garage, an affiliate manager, says affiliate credit can be non-incremental and suggests pausing cashback partners in one market for four to six weeks. It warns against writing off whole affiliate types.
“A conversion can be attributed to an affiliate and still be non-incremental.”
Loren Baker, whose agency sells SEO, says an empty promo code box sends shoppers to coupon affiliates, who can take 10% to 20% of an order the brand already won; he suggests a brand-owned promo page.
“When shoppers see an empty promo code box, many leave the site to search for a discount.”
Shopifreaks reports MegaLag's finding that after the Honey affiliate cookie scandal, Honey lost 7M Chrome users and about 7,000 merchant partners, and Rakuten, Impact.com and Awin suspended it.
“Rakuten Advertising, Impact.com, and Awin Group suspended Honey from their networks”
Bloomberg reports Phia's shopping extension was built to claim credit for sales it didn't drive. A Phia estimate, which the company disputes, put cookie stuffing at about 51% of June sales it claimed.
“was also designed to report that the startup drove a sale even when its product was never used”
Ben Edelman, an advertising consultant, found Phia's extension fired its affiliate link when users closed its slider. One tracking service saw affiliate clicks in Phia cart sessions jump from under 10% to over 50%.
“Clearly networks had trouble uncovering Phia’s violations, even when tipped off.”
Track360, which sells affiliate software, says discount codes leak to coupon sites that may also claim commission, and the best defense is partner-locked or single-use codes.
“The strongest defense against code leakage is to issue partner-locked or single-use codes rather than reusable public codes.”
Two affiliate publicists, who gain when brands keep paying affiliates, argue cashback sites are acquisition channels, pushing back on the view that cashback only pays for sales you'd get anyway. No data.
“Cashback platforms are acquisition channels when evaluated correctly.”
Haus, a testing vendor reporting its own test, says one brand switched off its US cashback and loyalty affiliates for seven weeks, with seven other countries as control, and saw no measurable change in US revenue.
“The result: no measurable change in US revenue during the shutoff.”