If we sell through both our website and our own app, should Meta ads send clicks to the site, the app, or let Meta choose for each click?
Our answer
Keep your website campaign as the base, and test Meta's website-and-app option as a separate campaign against it. Send app clicks with a website fallback. Move budget to whichever earns more web and app revenue.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 3 Meta rules
- 2 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 9 statements
- M
BWSLSCSD
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentLetting Meta choose web or app for each click beat both fixed routes, by Meta's own figure. Per-click routing added 0.54% advertiser value against always opening the web. Sending every click to an app lost 1.05%.
The website beat the app store where an operator tested both. Built With Science sends about 90% of its Meta traffic to a web quiz, which beat the App Store head to head. Simply instead pairs each ad and placement with its own destination.
Run each route as its own campaign and judge both on the same revenue, advises Admiral Media, an app marketing agency. Samet Durgun, an app growth consultant, advises analyzing web and App Store buyers apart because they convert and retain differently.
Meta's Marketing API requires a website-and-app campaign to use automatic destination selection or a compatible manual destination. From October 27, 2026, ads set to always open the website can no longer be attached to those campaigns.
Our judgment
Keep the website as the default route. The only figures for per-click routing are Meta’s own and small, and the one operator that compared routes head to head chose the web. Test Meta’s option as its own campaign on combined revenue, applying Admiral Media’s and Durgun’s practice for app routes to a business that sells in both places. Prefer a website fallback to the app store for people without the app, since Built With Science’s web route beat the App Store and Meta makes the app store the default when app links are present.
Our judgment, built from Meta, Built With Science, Social Led Growth, Admiral Media and Samet Durgun: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
9 statements from 6 sourcesA Meta research paper found routing each ad click to web or app, rather than always to web, raised advertiser value 0.54% in three-week tests. Always sending clicks to the app lowered it 1.05%.
An operator says a fitness subscription app scaled Meta to $100,000 a month in profitable spend, sending about 90% of traffic to a web quiz instead of the App Store. Cold traffic converts trial-to-paid at about 25%.
“About 90% of our traffic is actually going to our website, and we have a really long personalized quiz that we send all leads to”
Meta's API changelog says creatives set to web only can no longer go in campaigns using Website and App conversion locations, for all API versions from October 27, 2026.
“Use automatic destination selection or a compatible manual destination.”
Arun Gellela's Meta setup guide says most sales campaigns should pick Website under the single conversion location, choosing App or message destinations only if sales run there. No data.
“For most sales campaigns, select Website under Single.”
Meta says cross-channel conversion optimization counts website and app conversions in one campaign, which may lower cost per action. It needs both pixel and app SDK and supports two bid strategies.
“Both app SDK and pixel are required.”
Simply's head of growth says a web funnel made Facebook ads work for Simply for the first time and reached new audiences; about 20% of Simply Piano's revenue last year came through it. No test figures.
“About 20% of our revenue from Simply Piano, like in the past year, came from a webflow.”
Meta says optimizing one Advantage+ shopping campaign for both website and app conversions captures more data and may lower cost per action, with no figure. Ads can send app users to the app and others to the site.
“Selecting a website and app as the places you want conversions to happen captures more data, which may help lower cost per action (CPA) and can lead to an increase in conversions.”
An agency with no comparison data says neither web-to-app nor direct install wins universally. Run both as separate campaigns with a holdout, and optimize toward the event closest to revenue that measurement delivers.
“Neither approach wins universally”
Samet Durgun, a consultant with no controlled test, advises testing install cost first, then purchase optimization, then value optimization with enough volume. He cites Meta's roughly 50 events per week per ad set.
“Meta recommends roughly 50 conversion events per week per ad set”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer