Should we show comparison charts against competitors or between our own products?
Our answer
Show a comparison table within your own range when similar products differ on the specs that decide the purchase. Compare against rivals only on provable points, let them win where they do, and test it.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 2 controlled tests
- 2 official rules, 5 practitioners, 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 14 sources
- 16 statements
BC
FUFASBIS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentComparison tables pay off for stores with several similar products. They do not help with color or size variants, one or two products, or commodities (Fudge).
A chart where the rival loses every row reads as an ad. Taylor Sicard, a consumer growth consultant, praises Everyday Dose for letting Ryze win two of five rows.
The law allows naming rivals if the comparison is fair. The FTC encourages naming competitors when comparisons are clear and not deceptive. UK rules require like for like products, verifiable features and no denigration (Advertising Standards Authority).
Our judgment
We would start within your own range, since Fudge and Blend Commerce describe it as a way to help shoppers choose between options they already weigh, and most large sites leave out price per unit (Baymard Institute). Against a rival, we read the advice and the rules together: stick to objective points you can prove and concede the rows it wins. Put rival comparisons on a dedicated comparison page or a product page reached from comparison searches, not on every product page, since Echelonn, Web Tonic and 1Digital tie them to shoppers at the final stage of choosing.
Our judgment, built from Fudge, Blend Commerce, Baymard Institute, Taylor Sicard, US Federal Trade Commission, Advertising Standards Authority, Echelonn, Web Tonic and 1Digital Agency: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
16 statements from 14 sourcesThe FTC's policy encourages naming competitors in comparative ads as long as the comparison is clear, and allows disparaging ads that are truthful and not deceptive.
“disparaging advertising is permissible so long as it is truthful and not deceptive.”
The UK CAP Code says superiority claims need evidence unless obvious puffery, and comparisons must be like for like, objective, clear on price basis and must not denigrate competitors.
“Superiority claims must be supported by evidence unless they are obvious puffery”
Fudge, which sells a theme tool, notes Shopify has no native product comparison and says tables pay off for stores with several similar products, using 3 to 4 columns on desktop and 2 on mobile.
“Shopify has no native side-by-side product comparison feature.”
In a 14-day test on about 19,000 visitors per arm, a 'Help me choose' comparison lifted revenue per visitor 2.6%, all on desktop (+11.9%). None of it reached 95% confidence.
“None of that got close to 95%.”
A University of Toronto study of 158,099 AI answers found ChatGPT consults 26 pages on average and cites 3, and at equal rank cites brand pages more (x1.71) than lists, comparisons or Reddit threads.
“at equal rank, concise pages from the original source win over roundups and forums.”
Taylor Sicard, a consultant, says a comparison chart against a named rival is more credible when the rival wins some rows, and faults Everyday Dose's landing page for a price that doesn't match its ad.
“the two ticks are what make the three crosses credible, and most brands are too nervous to give them up.”
In a Blend Commerce test, adding price per serving to collection-page product cards lifted revenue per visitor 8.25% and conversion 5.96%. Sample not stated; the page calls the results directional.
“No confidence level was supplied, so the uplifts should be treated as directional.”
Taylor Sicard's teardown of a Bellroy landing page says comparing against an unnamed generic rival keeps the us-versus-them pull while avoiding legal risk and free attention for a competitor. No performance data.
“Make sure the anonymous rival resembles something people genuinely own, or the comparison reads as a strawman rather than a choice.”
Web Tonic, a PPC agency, says bidding on rivals' brand names costs 2-4x your own brand CPC, so pick 5-10 rivals you lose deals to, set a 90-day cap and kill line, and keep your own brand campaign funded.
“Bidding on the pure brand name of a market leader is the version of the tactic that burns money quietly.”
1Digital, an ecommerce SEO agency, says blog posts build awareness but rarely close sales, while buying guides, comparison pages and category pages reach shoppers close to buying.
“The takeaway is blunt: blog posts build awareness, but they rarely close sales on their own.”
Blend Commerce's Peter Gardner says stores should build comparison pages against rivals, cheaper dupes, DIY options and doing nothing, saying who should and shouldn't buy.
“The purpose of a Battle Card is not to pick fights but make the decision easier for your customers.”
Velocity Sellers, an Amazon agency, says Manage Your Experiments runs about 4 to 10 weeks and low-volume products won't qualify. Test the main image first, then the title, then A+ Content.
“Start at the top of the hierarchy and stay there until the main image is a confirmed winner.”
SalesDuo, an Amazon agency, ranks the comparison chart as the strongest A+ Content module, suggests a 7-module layout to start, and says A+ is not a direct ranking factor. No data shown.
“This does not mean A+ Content is a direct ranking factor like keywords in your title.”
Echelonn, which sells Google Ads management, says ecommerce brands should test comparison keywords such as competitor reviews and alternatives; it cites client campaigns at 3.7 and 2.7 platform ROAS.
“That’s why I believe every ecom brand should test comparison keywords.”
Atticus Li, a CRO consultant, reports 19 comparison page tests (7 winners): a few deciding attributes beat exhaustive feature tables, and testimonials in the grid cut conversion. No sites or sample sizes given.
“changing how comparison information is structured produces more reliable conversion lifts than changing what information is shown.”
Baymard's benchmark of 155+ large US and European sites rates most product pages mediocre or worse (52% desktop, 62% mobile) and lists fixes such as size buttons, in-scale images and a return policy link.
“52% of desktop, 62% of mobile, and 64% of app ecommerce sites have an overall “mediocre or worse” UX performance for their product pages.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer