Which custom labels should we add to the feed?
Our answer
Use your first custom label for margin tiers and the second for a performance bucket built from months of results, re-sorted more often than quarterly. Add season, stock or price band only where needed, keeping a slot for tests.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 5 Google rules
- 1 dataset, 7 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 11 sources
- 17 statements
- GZG
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentGoogle gives you five custom labels for reporting and bidding in Performance Max, Shopping and Demand Gen. Each holds up to 1,000 values, and Google suggests margin, season and selling rate.
Margin belongs in the first label, where ZenoX and Product Metrics put it, and Jetfuel rates margin labels high impact. A 60% margin product and a 10% margin product can't share one ROAS target (Auke Marketing and Store Growers).
Performance labels need a long look back and frequent re-sorting. GetProfit found 71% of bestsellers stayed on top 3 months or less, and 64.7% of products that reached winner status sold once in one month.
Our judgment
- Margin goes in the first label when margins differ across the catalog. ZenoX and Product Metrics both start there. Where margins are similar, the performance bucket takes the first label.
- Build the performance bucket from several months of results, not the last 30 days, and re-sort it more often than once a quarter. We side with GetProfit's dataset of one-off winners over ZenoX's 30 to 60 day practice.
- Use about three labels and keep one free for a test group (Testing a Google product feed change). ZenoX says three cover most of the value, Google allows five, and Product Metrics warns against overwriting a field another campaign depends on.
- Add season, stock or price band only where the catalog varies on it and you will act on the label. Google and ZenoX list them as options and Top Growth Marketing flags stock and season. GetProfit warns that narrow price bands move products whenever prices change.
- Give untested products their own value inside the performance label, not labels of their own. Jetfuel's Scouts, Product Metrics' insufficient_data and GetProfit's Newcomers all fit there.
Our judgment, built from Auke Marketing, Store Growers, ZenoX, Product Metrics, GetProfit, Google, Top Growth Marketing and Jetfuel Agency: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
17 statements from 11 sourcesGoogle Merchant Center's five custom labels let you group products for reporting and bidding in Performance Max, Shopping and Demand Gen, such as by margin or price range. Shoppers never see them.
“Set up your own definitions for custom labels and include only one type of label per attribute.”
Google lets Shopping and Performance Max campaigns split products with up to 5 custom labels (such as season, margin or clearance), one value per product each, for reporting and bidding.
“Each custom label can only have one value per product.”
Google allows up to 1,000 listing groups per Performance Max asset group, but says more than that may hurt performance and recommends grouping items with custom labels.
“We recommend you use custom labels to group items, and then target those labels in listing groups.”
Google advises running Performance Max feed campaigns at least 6 weeks, starting simple, and splitting campaigns only for needs like separate countries, budgets or ROAS targets. Custom labels can flag priority products.
“When you start a new Performance Max campaign, you should make its structure as simple as possible.”
Product Metrics, which sells feed segmentation software, suggests sending margin bands and performance bands through separate custom labels, and notes labels change nothing until campaigns use them.
“Labels organise products; they change advertising only when your campaigns use them.”
GetProfit's data on 146 stores: in the median store 40.5% of ad budget went to products that never sold, 71% of bestsellers stayed on top 3 months or less, and 35.4% of losers later converted.
“observations, not an experiment”
GetProfit, which sells product segmentation software, says a product segment changes spend only with its own budget or ROAS target, so in Performance Max its own campaign, and only if each gets 30 conversions a month.
“A segment moves money only when it gets its own budget or target ROAS, which in Performance Max means its own campaign.”
Mike Ryan of Smarter Ecommerce, which sells Performance Max tools, says custom labels are how you feed Google business data it lacks, such as margins or return rates.
“custom labels are really a way of you injecting your domain and your first party data beyond your audiences.”
Jetfuel, which sells feed audits, says product titles are the most valuable Shopping feed fix (front-load the main search term), missing GTINs cost impression share and ratings, and changes show in 3 to 7 days.
“Product title structure is the single most valuable feed optimization. Front-load the most relevant search term.”
Top Growth Marketing, which sells Performance Max management, advises feed custom labels for margin tier, stock level and seasonality so you can segment Shopping or Performance Max campaigns.
“flagging margin tier, stock level and seasonality so you can segment in Shopping or PMax.”
Edwin Choi of Jetfuel tiers Shopping products into top-20% revenue Superstars, Workhorses and untested Scouts, with custom labels by margin or stock. One consumer food account's ROAS climbed after the split; no figures.
“Top 20% revenue drivers, proven converters”
Store Growers, which sells Google Ads courses, calls the product feed the most important Performance Max input, starting with product titles, and wants 60 to 80% of spend on Shopping.
“Your product feed is the single most important input to a Performance Max campaign.”
Auke Marketing, a Shopping feed seller, advises custom labels to split Performance Max by margin, since a 60% and a 10% margin product cannot share a ROAS target, and waiting for about 30 conversions a month.
“A 60%-margin product and a 10%-margin product can't share a ROAS target and both stay profitable.”
PPC Land reports Google Merchant Center now supports custom labels 0 to 4 in Demand Gen campaigns for bidding and reporting, so margin, price tier and seasonality labels from Shopping carry over.
“Google Merchant Center now supports custom labels 0-4 in Demand Gen campaigns”
ZenoX, which sells Shopping management and labeling software, says three custom labels cover most of the value: start with margin tier, then a performance bucket from 30 to 60 days of data, then seasonality.
“In practice, three well-defined labels cover most of the value.”
ZenoX, which sells Shopping management, reports one jewelry account spending €120k a month cut CPA 38% by week 9 after feed and ROAS target changes. It says the case does not separate feed work from bid changes.
“This case does not isolate feed work from bid changes.”
Google lets Performance Max and Shopping advertisers raise conversion values for chosen products, by brand or category, to favor profit or best-sellers without restructuring campaigns. No performance figures.
“without altering campaign structure”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer