Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

About The Prevailing

We don't ask you to trust us. We show the work.

Answers on Meta and Google ads, and the rest of marketing, for consumer businesses, built from what the people running the ads report. No single expert: 1,624 sources so far, and three must agree before we answer.

Ink portrait of Scott StroudEdited by Scott Stroud, who spent the last two decades running marketing and ecommerce at Hasbro, Weber, and Rue La La, and now advises consumer brands on where their ad money goes.

1

How an answer is made

One real answer, taken apart: What ad frequency is too high We read 12 sources from the last six months, 20 statements in all, each dated and linked.

7 statements agree
  • Jetfuel Agency ×2
  • Hawke Media
  • Segwise
  • Meta
  • Interconnections
  • Alex Neiman
9 statements add a condition
  • Meta ×2
  • Hawke Media
  • Jetfuel Agency
  • Web Tonic
  • Wicked Reports
  • Biddyco
  • Marketing Operators podcast
  • Segwise
4 statements disagree
  • Jon Loomer ×3
  • Rich From Anywhere
2

How to read it

Every answer has the same parts, so you always know what is fact, what is our call and what is still argued.

1

Watch 7-day prospecting frequency from about 2.5. Act only after a week above about 3 to 3.5, with the ad's cost per purchase up about 20% on its early weeks and no market-wide rise.

Our answer

Where the evidence lands, in plain words.

2

Our judgment: the act level of about 3 to 3.5 held for a week spans Jetfuel's 3.5 held for a week (its Monday audit flags 3.0), Segwise's measurable drops above 3.0, and the 3.0 fatigue signal and 3.5 refresh-now bands in Alex Neiman's guide for GoodMorning, from Jetfuel, Segwise and Alex Neiman.

Our judgment

Where we weigh evidence ourselves, it says so and names its sources.

3

Low: agencies agree on a watch level near 2

How sure we are

Low, Medium or High, with the reason.

4

Interconnections, whose 15-brand benchmark this answer uses, found no original source for the 2.5 and 3.5 levels and advises refreshing on cost per purchase against target, not on frequency.

Who disagrees

The strongest dissent is on the page, not buried.

5

If you are running retargeting or other small, warm audiences, allow more, though sources differ: up to 4 to 5 (Jetfuel) or 6 or more (Hawke Media).

What would change it

The cases where the answer flips.

Read the full answer

3

Who we read

The most quoted in each group, with how often we cite them. Every source has its own page with how often it agrees with the consensus.

Platforms and their rules

83 sources

Agencies

554 sources

Brands and the people running them

149 sources

Tools and measurement firms

628 sources

Press and research

210 sources

Quoted here?

See your record, and where you part ways with the consensus. Want your portrait removed? We take it down the same day.

Find your page
4

The rules

  1. Three sources or no answer. We answer a question only when at least three independent sources from the last six months speak to it.
  2. Sellers are flagged. When a source sells the thing it recommends, the answer says so, every time.
  3. Our judgment is labeled. Where we weigh the evidence ourselves, it reads "Our judgment" and names the sources it rests on.
  4. Answers change with the evidence. When new evidence moves an answer, we change it and log what changed and when.
928answers
1,624sources quoted
8,755statements

Questions, corrections or a source we should read: [email hidden]