All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

Should the site use pop-ups to collect email and SMS sign-ups, and which offer and timing work best?

The PrevailingUpdated Nov 18, 2026

Our answer

Use a sign-up pop-up, but open it after a short delay and a scroll rather than on arrival. Show it at most twice a week, ask for email before phone and test it against no pop-up.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
1 controlled test
6 official rules, 4 datasets, 2 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
Sources
10 sources
15 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Don't let a pop-up cover the page on arrival. Google and Shopify both advise against it. Shopify opens one only after a scroll, tap or click, and Google warns that intrusive dialogs may hurt search performance.

A short wait helps, but its length matters little. Popups shown at once converted 1.9% against 2.4% after 6 to 10 seconds (Omnisend, email and SMS platform). Popupsmart (popup software maker) found the length of the wait made no measurable difference.

Test the pop-up against no pop-up. Onsite campaigns beat a held-back group that saw nothing in about 86% of decided holdout tests, with conversion gains of about 1 to 8% (Wisepops, popup software maker).

Our judgment

  • Open the pop-up after a short delay combined with a scroll, not on page load, and don't tune the exact second. Shopify gates its example dialog on a scroll or exit gesture, Maria Trotta pairs a 5-second delay with a 20% scroll, and Omnisend's popups converted best between 1 and 10 seconds (2.3% and 2.4% against 1.9% at 0 to 1 seconds).
  • Use exit intent as a later, second prompt rather than the main trigger. Omnisend's exit-triggered popups converted below its scroll and page-count triggers and Popupsmart's exit-intent gap could be chance, while Maria Trotta reports higher submit rates for targeted exit-intent forms.
  • Keep the pop-up on unless your own holdout shows it losing sales. Wisepops' holdouts lean that way, though on each campaign's own goal, in a small sample and in tests a popup seller ran.
  • Ask for an email alone on the first step and the phone number on a second. Klaviyo's rule is that multi-step forms are the best way to collect email and SMS consent, and Omnisend and Popupsmart find conversion falls as fields are added.
  • On a page built for Google search ads, keep to one delayed, scroll-gated pop-up or a small banner. Google's ad landing page advice warns against too many ads or pop-ups, and its search guidance suggests small banners for sign-up prompts.

Our judgment, built from Shopify, Maria Trotta (Klaviyo), Omnisend, Popupsmart, Wisepops, Klaviyo and Google: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

15 statements from 10 sources
  • ShopifyUndatedSupports

    Shopify's developer docs say pop-ups that cover content on load hurt mobile and can become the Largest Contentful Paint element. The best fix is no dialog on load; otherwise trigger it by interaction, not a timer.

    “The strongest version of this fix is to not show a dialog on load at all.”

    Read it on shopify.dev

  • KlaviyoUndatedCaveat

    Klaviyo's coupon forms can give one static code or unique one-time codes, which are harder to share. Klaviyo suggests a free gift with purchase over a discount for cheap-to-make, high-price products like skin care.

    “unique codes are harder to share or misuse”

    Read it on klaviyo.com

  • Jon LoomerNov 17, 2026Caveat

    Jon Loomer reports Meta can add promo codes to Sales ads on its own, with no per-ad off switch, and run email sign-up offers that disable your site's pop-up. Both are turned off in Commerce Manager.

    “There's no way to remove promotions from an individual ad while this setting is on.”

    Read it on jonloomer.com

  • GoogleOct 28, 2026Supports

    Google, which sells the ads, says ad text should closely match your keywords and the landing page should match the ad and mirror its call to action. It ties this to Quality Score.

    “Choose a landing page that closely matches your ad and keywords.”

    Read it on support.google.com

  • ShopifyOct 23, 2026Supports

    Shopify's Black Friday checklist says to limit deal pop-ups so they don't interrupt browsing or checkout, and to offer early access to encourage email sign-ups. No data given.

    “Limit pop-ups that promote deals or offers so they don't interrupt browsing or checkout.”

    Read it on shopify.com

  • KlaviyoOct 21, 2026Supports

    Klaviyo says SMS consent must be collected separately from email, can't come from bought lists or be required to make a purchase, and US carriers require double opt-in for cart abandonment flows.

    “Having consent for email does not mean you have consent for SMS.”

    Read it on help.klaviyo.com

  • HexCladOct 19, 2026Supports

    In a sponsored piece, HexClad's Connor Rolain says testing pop-up messaging, design and timing two to three times a week nearly doubled email opt-ins from 5 to 6% and lifted evergreen flow revenue 68%.

    Read it on operatorscontent.com

  • PopupsmartSep 26, 2026Supports

    Popupsmart's benchmark of 28,674 campaigns, from its own customers, found popups that wait converted 0.83% of displays versus 0.61% on page load, and conversion fell from the third view. It counts signups, not purchases.

    “so cap repeat views at two per visitor per week and stop showing the popup after a signup.”

    Read it on popupsmart.com

  • PopupsmartSep 26, 2026Supports

    Popupsmart, which sells popups, found across 28,674 campaigns that signup popups with a discount convert 1.46% vs 0.75% without, but bigger discounts didn't convert measurably better. Sign-ups only.

    “start from the smallest code you're comfortable offering.”

    Read it on popupsmart.com

  • KlaviyoAug 6, 2026Disagrees

    A Klaviyo strategist calls its 3% sign-up form benchmark a low bar, having seen 8 to 20%; pop-ups run 3 to 8%, exit-intent and phone-only forms 10 to 13%. She suggests a 5-second delay plus 20% scroll.

    “Pair a time delay with a scroll trigger, rather than showing the form immediately on page load.”

    Read it on klaviyo.com

  • Data RevoltJun 30, 2026Supports

    Data Revolt, an agency, tested Meta Instant Forms against a signup page for several brands: forms cost about 8x less per lead, but those leads barely bought, while 5-35% of leads captured on site ordered.

    “near-zero purchase conversion from Meta leads”

    Read it on datarevolt.agency

  • OmnisendFeb 9, 2026Supports

    Omnisend, which sells popup software, reports averages from 1.24 billion popup displays in 2025: 2.1% average email popup conversion, best at a 6 to 10 second delay (2.4%). Averages of past campaigns, not tests.

    “The average email popup conversion rate in 2025 is 2.1%, with benchmarks indicating that rates below 1.5% are underperforming, while 5% and above are considered excellent.”

    Read it on omnisend.com

  • Wisepops2026Supports

    Wisepops' holdout tests found popup campaigns beat showing nothing about 86% of the time when a test reached a verdict, with a median gain near 20% on the goal, from a small sample.

    “Set aside a random slice of traffic that sees no campaign. Even 5% to 10% is enough on high-traffic pages”

    Read it on wisepops.com

  • ConvertiblesDec 28, 2025Caveat

    Convertibles says to run a popup A/B test until it reaches 95% confidence, with at least 1,000 visitors per variation, which takes 2 to 3 weeks for most Shopify brands.

    “Until you hit statistical significance at 95% confidence. Minimum 1,000 visitors per variation.”

    Read it on convertibles.dev

  • GoogleDec 10, 2025Supports

    Google says intrusive pop-ups can hurt search performance and trust, and recommends small banners instead of full-page interstitials, including for newsletter sign-ups. Legally required ones such as age gates are exempt.

    “Instead of full page interstitials, use banners that take up only a small fraction of the screen”

    Read it on developers.google.com

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Capture, testing and team