How does Pinterest perform for gifting and holiday sales?
Our answer
Pinterest suits gifts and holiday products people plan. Launch in September or October while searches climb, shift to product-led creative into Cyber Monday, expect pricier auctions at the peak and keep running into early January.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 dataset
- 5 practitioners, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 12 statements
- P
STEBPCT
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentHoliday shoppers start early on Pinterest. Its own data shows holiday activity spiking as early as September, with most decisions made before November. Stackmatix (paid media agency) launches 30 to 60 days before the peak and says gift searches begin in October.
A late launch spends the holiday peak on learning. Tailored Edge Marketing (consumer brand marketing agency) says a campaign launched at the peak burns its learning period then. Trackbee (Shopify conversion tracking app) says bids may need to rise 20 to 50% in peak periods.
Buying carries on after Christmas. Pinterest says 55% of weekly users keep buying online in the week after Christmas, when the mindset shifts from gifting to self-purchase.
Our judgment
Launching holiday campaigns in September or October is our call. It combines Pinterest's data on early activity, Stackmatix's 30 to 60 day lead with gift searches starting in October, and Tailored Edge Marketing's point about the learning period. Keep campaigns running into early January with self-purchase creative, going by Pinterest's post-Christmas figure and its advice. Judge the season on incremental sales, consistent with Advertising on Pinterest. The holiday return figures, an average incremental return on ad spend of 3.71 and Caraway's 47% above goal, are Pinterest grading itself, and ContentGrip calls Pinterest's holiday spending figures platform-reported context.
Our judgment, built from Pinterest, Stackmatix, Tailored Edge Marketing and ContentGrip: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
12 statements from 8 sourcesPinterest says its formats shift from saves to clicks in the run-up to Cyber 5, with shopping engagement peaking during it, so move from video and carousel ads to product-led ads. It gives no figures.
“Standard, video and carousel ads shift from saves to clicks, while shopping engagement peaks sharply during Cyber 5 itself.”
Pinterest says people on Pinterest are 93% more likely than non-users to make a detailed Cyber 5 shopping list, and 45% plan to start earlier. It does not say how the figures were gathered.
“If your Black Friday plan starts when the offer goes live, you’re late.”
Pinterest says after Christmas its users shift from gifting to buying for themselves and planning, so ads still built on gifts and countdowns feel out of step. It gives no figures.
“Move away from gift-led or occasion-led imagery and show the product in a more personal, everyday context.”
ContentGrip relays Pinterest's figure that its users spent 22% more than non-users last holiday season, and notes this is platform-reported context, not proof the optimization score drives spending.
“they are platform-reported context, not evidence that the score itself drives higher spending.”
Measured's panel of enterprise consumer brands indexed Pinterest at 1.1x the panel average, with catalog, DPA and Performance+ formats reaching 2x to 3.5x. Traffic and awareness buys pooled near zero.
“It rarely produced the panel's top line item, but it almost never produced a disaster either.”
Stackmatix, an agency, says Pinterest users plan weeks or months ahead, so launch seasonal campaigns 30 to 60 days before the peak to build saves first. No data given.
“Launch seasonal campaigns 30 to 60 days before the peak shopping window so your pins accumulate saves and engagement ahead of the purchase burst.”
Charle, a Shopify agency, says a US store testing Pinterest should spend $40 to $65 a day on its strongest margin category for four weeks, and that visual, considered purchases do best.
“For a US Shopify store starting out, $40 to $65 a day against your strongest margin category for four weeks produces a readable answer.”
Pinterest says holiday activity on it spikes as early as September and advises going live between September and November; it claims a 3.71 average iROAS from a study it does not name.
“If you wait until November to show up, most holiday decisions have already been made.”
Tailored Edge Marketing says Pinterest seasonal demand rises months early, so launch while searches climb, weight budget toward the rise, and avoid spending the learning period at the peak. It gives no data.
“Seasonal demand shows up months early. Launch on the searcher’s calendar.”
Black Propeller, an agency, says Pinterest has shifted to vertical and video: use 2:3 images and 9:16 video, keep video under 15 seconds with captions, show products in use, and refresh creative every 4 to 6 weeks.
“Horizontal or square assets are penalised by the format: they occupy less visual space and perform consistently worse on CPC and engagement metrics.”
Trackbee, an ad cost guide, says Pinterest is unusually seasonal. Q4 and holidays push prices up, so bids may need to rise 20 to 50% in peak periods. Conversions often arrive on a longer lag.
“Bids may need to rise 20 to 50% in peak periods to hold visibility.”
Pinterest says Caraway, tested with measurement firm Haus, saw new-customer incremental ROAS 47% above goal after moving to a Performance+ campaign in Q4. The post gives no test details.
“new‑customer incremental return on ad spend (iROAS) came in 47% above goal.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer