How should we judge an advertorial or pre-sell page: which click-through and conversion targets, and how do price-hidden pages change them?
Our answer
Judge an advertorial with its product page against the same ad sent straight to the product page. Expect about 25 to 30% of readers to click through, and set separate targets for pages that hide the price.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 5 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 8 statements
- MI
ENT
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA typical advertorial sends about 25 to 30% of its readers to the product page, argues Marin Istvanic, a creative strategist. Hiding the price can inflate that click-through, he adds, so those pages need their own targets.
A well-built listicle does better. It sends 35 to 50% or more of its readers to the product page (Nik Sharma).
The advertorial and product page work as one pair. EcomLabs360 judges them together on cost per product page visit, blended conversion and new-customer cost per purchase.
Our judgment
- Break-even depends on click-through. When a click costs the same on both routes, the product page has to convert advertorial visitors at your direct rate divided by the click-through share, about 3 times at 30%, as Marin Istvanic and EcomLabs360 both work out.
- Judge the pair on cost, not only on how many times better the product page must convert. Use cost per product page visit and new-customer cost per purchase, because a pre-sell page can also change what each click costs, as in Nick Theriot's listicle test and Nik Sharma's point that listicles bring a cheaper click.
- Test inside the live campaign. Send the same ad to both pages, as Nick Theriot did (Where to send cold traffic and How many landing pages to run).
- Read the two click-through targets as fitting different pages. Nik Sharma's 35 to 50% or more fits listicles that show the price, since his build advice puts the price in each entry. Marin Istvanic's 25 to 30% fits a typical advertorial, and neither gives a sample.
Our judgment, built from Marin Istvanic, EcomLabs360, Nick Theriot and Nik Sharma: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
8 statements from 7 sourcesMarin Istvanic says to track advertorial click-through to the product page: at 30%, the product page must convert about 3 times its baseline to match direct ROAS. Illustrative math, not a result.
“Your CTR can look artificially “great” if the advertorial doesn't reveal the price.”
Marin Istvanic, who sells account audits, says a typical advertorial loses 60 to 75% of traffic before the product page, but those who click through convert at 4 to 6 times direct traffic. A rule of thumb, no data.
“the 25-30% who click through convert at 4-6x the rate of direct traffic!”
Brad Ploch says a quiz page for a single-product brand took Meta spend like other landing pages, and split tests improved it: six problem-focused questions doubled revenue per visitor. Sample sizes are not given.
“sit in the problem longer”
EcomLabs360, which writes advertorials, says to judge ad and page together on cost per product page visit, blended conversion and new-customer CPA, sending the same ad to both pages. Its figures are illustrative.
“Never judge either page alone. Judge the pair: ad plus destination, measured on cost per PDP visit, blended conversion rate, and new-customer CPA.”
Agency owner Nick Theriot ran the same ads to a listicle and a product page in one CBO. Over 45 days Meta spent $12,000 on the listicle at $62 per purchase vs $1,200 at $85. Conversion rate was about equal.
“the listicle actually got a much better cost per purchase of $62 versus the $85”
Zach Stuck of Motion says that across 500 or 600 brands audited over 9 years, sending ads to a listicle before the product or collection page almost always performed better, even with okay copy. No figures given.
Nik Sharma says well-built listicles send 35 to 50%+ of readers on to the product page, which converts better off warmer traffic; a roughly $9M brand's CAC dropped after the switch. No data behind the figures.
“When listicles aren't built right, they can be an expensive waste of a click.”
CTC says there is no flat 2% conversion target: a $40 product should convert around 6% and a $1,000 product far lower. Offer and perceived value matter more than page friction.
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer