Should we use Target Impression Share bidding, and what impression share should we aim for?
Our answer
Use it on your brand campaign, at about 90%, with a maximum CPC limit high enough to reach it. Elsewhere bid for sales or leads, and treat impression share as a result, not a goal.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 Google rules
- 5 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 11 statements
G
EPNCOPKA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentIt buys position, not sales. It bids to show your ad in a chosen share of eligible auctions. Google names brand terms and a local store facing bigger rivals as uses. Like Maximize clicks, it doesn't optimize for conversions (One PPC, a Google Ads agency).
Aim high on your own name, but short of 100%. Konvtrack, a Google Ads agency, uses a target such as 90% with a maximum CPC limit, as the last slice costs most. Excella PPC reads brand share under 90% as rivals taking your cheapest conversions.
A good share on other searches depends on profit. Excella PPC calls 30 to 50% healthy on competitive non-brand terms if the auctions you win convert, while Dotidot, a feed tool maker, puts high-intent non-brand at 60 to 80%.
Our judgment
- About 90% on brand. Konvtrack, Dotidot and Excella PPC all put the brand line near 90%, and Google’s 100% is an example of how the setting works rather than advice, consistent with Reading Google's Auction Insights.
- Top of page first. One PPC finds Top of page a more balanced goal for brand than Absolute top, and North Country Growth, which reserves Absolute top for brand, still finds Top of page more forgiving for a first target. Move to Absolute top only when rivals show above you on your name.
- No share target outside brand. Every source that gives a non-brand range ties it to profit, and One PPC and North Country Growth call the strategy a poor fit where sales or leads can be measured, so non-brand bidding follows Choosing a Google bid strategy.
- Local searches are the one other use. A local business’s key searches in its service area fit, judged on calls, appointments and sales.
Our judgment, built from Konvtrack, Dotidot, Excella PPC, One PPC, North Country Growth and Google: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
11 statements from 9 sourcesOne PPC, a UK agency, says Target Impression Share suits brand visibility but gets expensive, a target below 100% often balances cost better, and it fits poorly when leads or sales are the real goal.
“For many campaigns, a target below 100% provides a better balance between presence and cost.”
Google says Target impression share bidding can suit brand campaigns, and warns that setting the max CPC limit too low can stop you reaching your impression share goal.
“Target impression share can be useful for campaigns with brand terms.”
Google defines Search lost impression share (budget) as time ads didn't show for lack of budget and (rank) as time lost to poor Ad Rank. Figures are per campaign type and update within 1 to 2 days.
“Impression share metrics are reported separately for each campaign type and aren’t aggregated across the account.”
Store Growers' 122 Google Ads audits list rules its experts repeated, such as running brand search on manual CPC and needing about 30 conversions per campaign a month for smart bidding.
“Smart bidding needs about 30 conversions per campaign per month”
North Country Growth, an agency, advises target impression share for brand defense or a few key queries, starting at 70 to 80% top of page, and judging after a week of stable spend.
“A common hybrid: keep brand keywords on Target Impression Share for defense, while shifting non-brand campaigns to value-based bidding where performance data is stronger.”
Konvtrack, a Google Ads agency, says bid on your brand name if competitors do; otherwise prove it pays with a 4 to 6 week geo holdout on all brand conversions. It shows no test data of its own.
“A 4-6 week geographic holdout, measured on all brand conversions rather than paid ones alone, is the most honest way to decide.”
Kick Ads, an ads agency, says manual CPC is now mainly for tiny budgets or accounts without conversion tracking, and target impression share is best for brand defence. No data.
“Manual bidding is now mainly for thin-data or high-control edge cases.”
Dotidot, a feed tool vendor, says brand bidding pays when competitors bid on your terms and may waste budget when they do not. Test it for at least 14 days, or with a 2 to 4 week geo holdout.
“If competitors capture 20% or more impression share when you reduce bids, that's a clear signal that brand campaigns serve a defensive purpose.”
Chris Shaver prefers automated target impression share bidding over maximize conversions for branded search campaigns.
“impression share bidding, you know, automated impression share bidding, I think is a much better choice.”
Dotidot, a feed and PPC tool seller, suggests 90 to 95% search impression share for brand campaigns, 60 to 80% for high-intent non-brand and 40 to 70% for Shopping. No data behind the ranges.
“Your brand should dominate its own terms.”
Excella PPC, an agency, says brand terms under 90% impression share mean someone is taking your cheapest conversions, while 30 to 50% is healthy on competitive non-brand terms if profitable.
“Chasing a bigger share is only a goal when the economics already work.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer