Should we use Google's lookalike segments in Demand Gen, and which seed list works best?
Our answer
Yes, as a test. Seed one lookalike with recent and frequent buyers in its own Demand Gen ad group. Google treats it as a signal and may reach past it, so judge it on holdout sales.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 Google rules
- 2 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 11 statements
- G
EPJCC
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentGoogle offers lookalike segments only in Demand Gen and Video brand campaigns. Since March 2026 Demand Gen treats your seed and reach setting as signals and may show ads beyond the 2.5%, 5% or 10% limits. You can ask to keep the strict limit.
Your best recent buyers make the seed. Google asks for recent converters, frequent purchasers and people who nearly bought. eCommerce Paradise, a high-ticket dropshipping blog, drops refunds, chargebacks and low-value orders and ranks past buyers by order value.
Seed size matters before settings. A strict lookalike needs over 100 active matched people (Google). Relevant Audience, a Google Ads and SEO agency, notes Google recommends at least 1,000 elsewhere for quality.
Proof that lookalikes pay is thin. JumpFly, a paid search agency, credits a lookalike Demand Gen campaign in a launch that lifted one apparel brand's revenue 65% against a year earlier, a comparison rather than a test.
Our judgment
Treat a lookalike as one tested prospecting ad group rather than the core of Demand Gen, since the evidence describes how it works far better than whether it pays. Keep Google’s default suggestion mode unless the seed is small and prices are high, applying eCommerce Paradise’s rule, the only stated threshold.
Our judgment, built from Google, Relevant Audience, JumpFly and eCommerce Paradise: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
11 statements from 6 sourcesGoogle treats health conditions and treatments as a sensitive category: such ads can use Google's predefined audiences but not Customer Match, your data segments, audience expansion or lookalikes.
“You can't use advertiser-curated audiences.”
Google says Demand Gen lookalike segments now act as signals rather than hard limits, may reach beyond the 2.5%, 5% or 10% tiers, no longer need a 100-user seed, and take about 72 hours to populate.
“This change only affects Lookalike segments attached to Demand Gen campaigns in Google Ads.”
Google says Demand Gen lookalikes reach 2.5%, 5% or 10% of users in the target area, need seed lists over 100 matched people, and should be set up 2 to 3 days ahead.
“The sum of all your submitted seed lists must be over 100 active matched people.”
Google says Lookalike segments in Video campaigns aim at 2.5%, 5% or 10% of users in the target location and need seed lists totaling over 100 active matched people.
“The sum of all your submitted seed lists must be over 100 active matched people.”
Google's Demand Gen can target website visitors, YouTube viewers and customer lists, or exclude past customers, and Google advises separate ad groups for audiences with distinct creative.
“Advertisers with distinct targeting strategies and corresponding creatives should separate each target audience into individual ad groups.”
Google's Demand Gen advice: use optimized targeting on prospecting, remarketing for first-party segments, the new customer acquisition goal for new buyers, and wait for 50 conversions before judging.
“Do not evaluate performance until the campaign has generated at least 50 conversions.”
Trevor Fenner suggests that with under about 500 matched buyers and orders over $1,000, keep Demand Gen lookalikes strict, and with thousands, test suggestion mode on a split budget. He calls the cutoffs his judgment.
“Those thresholds are my judgment, not Google guidance.”
Curve Compliance, which sells health ad tracking, says Google bars health advertisers from customer lists, remarketing and lookalikes; keywords and Google's own audiences still work.
“Hashing a patient list before upload changes nothing either”
Relevant Audience, a Google Ads agency, says Lookalikes now act as hard reach caps in Video campaigns. Seeds need over 100 matched people, with 1,000 recommended. No performance data.
“No performance data was published, so there is nothing showing that a Lookalike segment in a Video campaign outperforms any other targeting choice”
PPC Land reports Google Video campaigns kept the narrow, balanced and broad Lookalike reach tiers that Demand Gen dropped in March 2026, with a seed list of more than 100 matched people required.
“There was no accompanying entry on the Google Ads and Commerce Blog and no email to advertisers.”
JumpFly, an agency, says adding a Demand Gen lookalike campaign helped LIJA reach 65% more revenue and 53% more conversions than a year earlier. Several campaigns ran at once, so it is not a test.
“Overall LIJA saw a 65% increase in revenue and a 53% increase in conversions while maintaining their overall ROAS goal.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer