How should we run pre-orders and back-in-stock alerts?
Our answer
Take pre-orders only with a confirmed ship date you show and can refund against. Otherwise collect back-in-stock signups. In the US, ship by the stated date, or within 30 days if you state none, or offer a delay or refund.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 10 official rules
- 2 datasets, 8 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 21 statements
KPG
FUFK
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA pre-order is a promise about a date. Fudge and Shopify tie it to a confirmed ship date shown on the product page. The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) rule requires sellers to ship by that date, or within 30 days, or offer a refund.
Most stores keep pre-orders out of mixed carts, and many charge later on long waits. PreProduct (Shopify preorder app maker) found this across more than $85 million of Shopify pre-order sales.
Back-in-stock alerts convert well. Omnisend (email and SMS platform) found 6.46% for its alert emails, and Kulin (ecommerce retention agency) saw one client's convert at 7.9%. Klaviyo advises one prompt message, and Kulin prefers batches when stock is short.
Our judgment
- Choose by how certain the restock date is. Pre-orders when the date is confirmed, signups when it isn't, sold out when the product is gone. Fudge draws that line, and Shopify and the FTC rule make the stated date the promise a pre-order rests on.
- Don't read PreProduct's comparison of pre-order cancellations with alert conversions as proof that pre-orders earn more. It sets a 5.4% average pre-order cancellation rate, given without a source, against Omnisend's 6.46% alert conversion rate, but one counts buyers who already ordered and the other everyone who signed up.
- Charge in full at checkout for waits under 30 days, and charge later or take a deposit for longer ones, as PreProduct advises. Shopify warns that later card charges can fail, and that a Shop Cash authorization, valid about 30 days, may be voided before a later pre-order ships.
- Keep pre-orders in their own carts at first, as 62.1% of stores in PreProduct's data do. Fudge says mixed carts become one order with one shipping charge.
- Send one alert as soon as stock lands, and release signups in batches when the restock is small. Klaviyo can't recheck stock before a second message.
Our judgment, built from Fudge, Shopify, FTC, PreProduct, Omnisend, Klaviyo and Kulin: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
21 statements from 13 sourcesUS FTC rule: sellers must ship within the stated time, or 30 days if none is stated, and if they can't, must offer the buyer a delay or a cancellation with a prompt refund.
“an option either to consent to a delay in shipping or to cancel the buyer`s order and receive a prompt refund”
Shopify pre-orders need a pre-order app and Shopify Payments or PayPal Express. You can take full, partial or no payment upfront; uninstalling the app deletes pre-order data after 48 hours.
“Pre-orders are currently only available to merchants using Shopify Payments or Paypal Express.”
Shopify's pre-order options let apps ship ASAP, on a set date or later, commit inventory at sale or at fulfillment, and charge part at checkout with the rest later on a stored payment method.
“Shopify will store a customer's payment method so that merchants can collect the remaining balance amount without contacting the customer.”
Shopify says Shop Cash authorizations last about 30 days, so for pre-orders that ship later the Shop Cash authorization might be voided before fulfillment.
“Shop Cash authorizations are valid for approximately 30 days from the time the order is placed.”
Google requires feed availability to match the landing page, structured data and checkout, or the product is disapproved. Discontinued items should be deleted, not marked out of stock.
“The values in your data source should always match the information on your website.”
Shopify says customers cannot buy out-of-stock tracked items by default, but you can turn on Continue selling when out of stock for preorders or stock arriving soon.
“You have stock coming soon and you want to continue selling before it arrives.”
Klaviyo's back in stock form adds a Notify me button when a variant is out of stock, with an optional box to opt in to marketing that requires explicit consent.
“Shoppers must provide explicit consent to receive promotional messages through the selected channels.”
Klaviyo says its back-in-stock flows cannot check whether an item is still in stock before sending a second message.
“it's not possible to check if the item is still in stock before sending a second message.”
Klaviyo says a back in stock flow usually needs one message with Smart Sending off and no delays, and lets you cap how many subscribers are notified per restocked unit.
“Typically, you will only need a single message in this flow as a notification that the item is back. Make sure to turn Smart Sending off for this message to ensure everyone gets the alert.”
Fudge, which sells a Shopify AI tool, says to offer pre-orders only with a confirmed date you can state and honor, use back in stock signups when the date is uncertain, and warns of setting pitfalls.
“A ship date is a legal promise in the US.”
1Digital, which sells ecommerce SEO, says to keep temporarily out of stock product pages live with a restock alert, not redirect or 404 them, and to link 3 to 5 alternatives.
“Do not redirect. Do not 404. The page retains its ranking signals and converts waitlist signups.”
Google says product markup should give one availability value (such as OutOfStock, BackOrder or PreOrder), and warns that dynamically generated markup can make Shopping crawls less reliable.
“Don't specify more than one value.”
Shopify says preorders need an app, work with Shopify Payments or PayPal Express but not express wallets, and the product page should state the expected ship date. Missed dates bring cancellations.
“Accelerated checkouts such as Shop Pay, Apple Pay, and Google Pay are unavailable for preorder purchases.”
Evoluted, an agency, says keep a temporarily out-of-stock page live with a clear label, restock date, pre-order and related links, but large sites cannot keep thousands of dead pages forever.
“If the product will be available in the near future and you’re able to offer a pre-order option, that’s your best bet.”
Eightx, a fractional CFO firm, says most apparel brands should stock core items and preorder new drops, accepting slower conversion and refund risk. It says no reliable figure exists for preorder's conversion hit.
“There is no clean universal number for how much pre-order hurts conversion, and you should distrust anyone who quotes you one.”
SEO Bangkok, an SEO agency, says keep temporarily out-of-stock product pages live with a clear status, links to similar items and a back-in-stock signup, and don't redirect them. No data.
“Do not redirect a temporarily unavailable product, because you would lose the page just before you need it again.”
Charle, a Shopify agency, launches welcome, browse abandonment and abandoned cart flows in weeks 1 to 4, then post-purchase, back-in-stock and win-back flows in weeks 5 to 8.
“Launch your three highest-impact flows first: welcome series, browse abandonment, and abandoned cart.”
PreProduct, a pre-order app seller, says pre-orders beat back in stock signups, comparing its 5.4% pre-order cancellation rate with a 6.46% back in stock email conversion rate, two different measures.
“Long waitlists signal you should be taking pre-orders.”
Kulin, an agency, says for one client back in stock email converted at 7.9% and SMS at 8.5%, and SMS clicks ran 5.3% against 1.9% for email. It says batching sends is safer for most brands.
“for most brands, batching is the safer choice.”
Omnisend's data on 150,000 brands shows automations were 2% of email sends but 30% of email revenue, at $2.87 per send against $0.18 for campaigns, by Omnisend's own attribution.
“Abandoned cart and Welcome messages drove 76% of all automation-generated orders”
PreProduct, a pre-order app, says across $85 million of its merchants' pre-order sales, 43.8% charge later, 62.1% of stores keep pre-orders in separate carts, and 90.4% of listings carry no discount.
“Charge-upfront works best for lead times under 30 days.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer