How do we tell whether our product photos are driving returns, and what do we change when they are?
Our answer
Read return reasons product by product, then fix the photos where returns say the item was not as described or not as pictured. Shoot true to color without over-editing, add scale and close-ups, and compare that product's returns afterward.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 official rules
- 1 dataset, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 9 statements
ATCIAHBS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentYour platform already records why each item came back. Shopify suggests return reasons that fit each product's category and lets you view them in analytics. Amazon tells sellers to track return rate and reasons by product to spot listing problems.
Not-as-described returns point to the listing. TikTok Shop's answer to them is accurate descriptions and clear, honest images. Claimlane (returns software maker) advises reshooting products often returned as not as described, fixing the most-returned products one at a time.
Accuracy matters more than polish. Branvas (private label sourcing platform) argues over-edited brightness, saturation and contrast are among the most common hidden causes of returns. It asks for true-to-color photos, scale shots and a color check under natural light.
Tie returns to the images you used. Many clothing and furniture returns come from images that don't match the product delivered, a Journal du Net article argues, and brands should link return rates to the images used (reported by the International Association of Department Stores).
Our judgment
- Start from return reasons product by product rather than from the photos. Shopify and Amazon record reasons and advise reading them per product, Claimlane and Hubfluence read them by product, and Signifyd’s data shows the not-as-described label also covers damage.
- Treat a product as having a photo problem when its returns say not as described or not as pictured and the comments point to color, size or look rather than damage. This combines TikTok Shop’s and Claimlane’s link between those returns and images with Branvas’s list of photo causes.
- Judge a photo fix by comparing the product’s returns on orders placed after the change with orders before, allowing the 4 to 8 weeks Claimlane gives, since a Journal du Net article reported by the International Association of Department Stores says brands should link return rates to the images used.
Our judgment, built from Shopify, Amazon, Claimlane, Hubfluence, Signifyd, TikTok, Branvas and International Association of Department Stores: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
9 statements from 8 sourcesShopify says a refund without a return records no return reason, so create the return before refunding. Return reasons vary by product category and can be tracked in analytics.
“A refund without a return doesn't record a return reason.”
TikTok Shop's NBFR is the share of delivered orders over 90 days with returns or refunds due to seller or carrier fault. It counts in the Shop Performance Score; TikTok gives no target rate.
“Non-Buyer Fault Return and Refund Rate (NBFR) is the % of delivered orders that had return or refund requests due to seller- or logistics carrier-fault.”
Hubfluence says TikTok Shop returns are driven mostly by what creators imply on camera, so brief them on scale, timeline and sizing, track return rate by creator, and rank creators on sales net of returns.
“Return rate by creator. This is the step almost nobody takes, and it is the one that pays.”
Branvas, a sourcing platform, ranks accurate product photography as the second biggest lever on returns: shoot true to color, add scale shots and avoid over-editing.
“True-to-color photography is non-negotiable.”
Claimlane, a returns software company, says to track return rate by SKU, reason, customer segment and ad channel, and to fix the top 10 most-returned products one by one.
“Find your top 10 most-returned products and fix the specific issue for each one.”
A department store association argues AI visuals pay off through consistent image sets across a catalogue and accurate images that can cut returns, and advises A/B testing image formats. No data.
“Accurate visuals can also reduce returns, especially in clothing and furniture, where many returns stem from mismatches between online images and delivered products.”
Signifyd, a fraud screening vendor, says returns of items significantly not as described, including damaged ones, were 48% of all its retail clients' returns in 2025, and in January rose 9% from a year earlier.
“SNAD returns accounted for nearly half (48%) of all returns in 2025, according to Signifyd.”
Shopify now suggests return reasons specific to each product category, like Too big or Too small for apparel, with no setup, so merchants can spot sizing or quality problems sooner.
“Reduce future returns by addressing product issues faster (like sizing problems or quality concerns)”
Amazon staff on its seller forum name product not as described as a common return reason, and advise accurate listings, images from multiple angles, full dimensions and a monthly review of return reasons by ASIN.
“Pay attention to return reasons to spot listing or product issues”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer