Should we offer gift cards, and how should we sell them?
Our answer
Offer digital gift cards, which Shopify includes on every plan at no added fee. Link them from the main menu, promote them before gifting dates and after shipping cutoffs, set no expiry date and follow up recipients after they redeem.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 official rules
- 1 practitioner, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 13 statements
NR
UCOBNE
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentShoppers want gift cards. US shoppers were expected to spend $29B on gift cards in the 2025 holidays, and 43% planned to buy one (National Retail Federation, US retail trade association). Its 2026 survey finds Gen X and Boomers most want them.
The law rules out short expiry dates on gift cards. US federal rules bar gift card funds expiring within five years (US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau), and Shopify notes California generally bans expiry dates.
Digital gift cards sell once shipping cutoffs pass. Jetfuel Agency turns to them once shipping cutoffs pass. OneOnic (Shopify development agency) pushes digital cards from December 20 and follows up recipients after they redeem.
Our judgment
- Offer gift cards by default. Demand is broad in the National Retail Federation's surveys, Shopify includes them at no added fee, and recipients arrive through someone else's purchase, as Business News Daily and OneOnic describe.
- Set no expiry date on cards people buy. The federal rule sets a five-year floor, Shopify says local law may not allow an expiry date at all, and California generally bans one.
- Promote digital cards hardest once physical orders can no longer arrive in time. That follows Jetfuel Agency's holiday order of shipping-cutoff countdowns, then expedited shipping, then digital gift cards, and OneOnic's push from December 20.
- Treat the gift card sales figures from sellers of Shopify apps and store work as claims, not planning numbers. EasyApps' overspend and sales multiples and OneOnic's unredeemed value, set out under who disagrees, come with no source.
Our judgment, built from National Retail Federation, Shopify, Business News Daily, OneOnic, CFPB, Jetfuel and EasyApps: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 7 sourcesNRF's 2026 holiday survey: 64% of US shoppers say they will likely wait until Thanksgiving weekend to do most holiday shopping, up from 51% five years ago. Gift cards top Gen X and Boomer wish lists.
“More than one-quarter of holiday shoppers, 27%, plan to give an experiential gift”
US federal rules bar selling gift cards whose funds expire within five years, allow dormancy fees only after a year of no use, and exempt promotional cards labeled as such on the front. State laws can add more.
“Not more than one dormancy, inactivity, or service fee is imposed in any given calendar month.”
Shopify caps admin gift cards at $2,000 USD, recommends Flow to issue them for spend thresholds, and notes they create a liability; a discount code gives more control over amount, limits and expiry.
“Gift cards can create a liability to provide future sales.”
Shopify lets you discount gift cards, for example selling a $100 card for $80, or give one free with a buy X get Y offer. Collection-wide discounts don't apply to gift cards in that collection.
“Discounts that apply to specific collections don't apply to gift card products within the collection.”
Shopify says gift card pages use the theme's product template, buyers can add a recipient only if the theme supports it, and the 16 character redemption codes can't be customized.
“The 16 character gift card redemption codes are randomized, and can't be customized.”
Shopify says gift cards can cover taxes and shipping and combine with discount codes and other gift cards, but cannot pay recurring subscription charges or buy another gift card.
“Gift cards can be used together with discount codes.”
Shopify's blog says gift cards bring cash before redemption and new customers, and suggests bonus cards redeemable in January. Under US federal rules, funds generally cannot expire for five years.
“Make the bonus card redeemable after the holidays to encourage a return visit in January.”
Jetfuel, an agency, says gift buyers respond better to curated gift sets, free wrapping or threshold offers than to a flat 20% off, and that the real deadline is the last day a gift can arrive by December 25.
“Your real deadline is not December 25. It is the last day a gift can arrive by December 25”
OneOnic, a Shopify agency, says to promote gift cards from 1 December, push digital ones from 20 December, and send recipients a second-purchase offer within 30 days of redemption.
“Promote from 1 December. Especially push digital gift cards from 20 December when physical products can no longer arrive before Christmas.”
Shopify stores selling in several markets can now issue gift cards in local currencies, redeemable only in that currency or in any store currency at the current rate. The choice can't be changed later.
“This setting is selected at creation and can't be changed afterward.”
Business News Daily, which earns commissions from tools it lists, gives gift card tips and notes US federal law bars cards expiring within five years or inactivity fees before a year.
“federal law prohibits businesses from selling gift cards that expire less than five years from the time of purchase”
EasyApps, which sells Shopify apps, advises 4 to 6 gift card amounts matched to average order value, a custom amount option and bonus value offers. Its overspend and redemption figures have no source.
“One of the most effective gift card promotions is the bonus value offer: "Buy a $100 gift card, get $120 in value."”
The NRF's US holiday survey expected gift card spending of $29 billion in 2025, with 43% of shoppers planning to buy at least one. These are planned purchases, not measured sales.
“Consumers say they like how gift cards let recipients pick out their own gifts and can be easier and faster to purchase than other items.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer