Do our model and creator releases let us turn their photos into AI-altered ads?
Our answer
Count on an ordinary release only for routine retouching. Before AI puts a model or creator in a new pose, outfit, setting or product, get separate signed consent naming the use, purpose, pay and term.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 5 Meta rules
- 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 9 statements
- NYTFBASLGLLBN
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentNew York requires it for models. Its Fashion Workers Act requires brands to get a model's written approval naming scope, purpose, pay and term before creating or using a digital replica (New York State Department of Labor). Minor retouching doesn't count as a replica.
Broad old wording may not hold. New York and California void a digital replica clause without a reasonably specific description of its use, unless the person had a lawyer or union (BakerHostetler). A catch-all grant of all media may fall short (ArentFox Schiff).
No court has decided whether an old release covers AI images. Rainbow Shops argues its release, which lets it alter, distort or composite photos, covers them with any tool. A New York court declined to halt its ads while the case runs (The Fashion Law).
Check the finished ad. One app blamed Meta's automatic Advantage+ creative enhancements for lightening a creator's skin in a Facebook ad, which she disputes, and admitted it never reviewed the ad (The Fashion Law). Consent doesn't excuse a misleading replica (BBB National Programs).
Our judgment
Apply the reshoot test to every model and creator, not only those hired in New York, since the New York act, the New York and California contract laws and the union contract all separate routine edits from new depictions. Rewrite old releases and creator contracts before AI tools touch their photos rather than rely on broad edit-and-alter wording, since no court has yet read such wording to cover AI images.
Our judgment, built from ArentFox Schiff, BakerHostetler, New York State Department of Labor, The Fashion Law, Loeb & Loeb and Lathrop GPM: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
9 statements from 7 sourcesNew York's Fashion Workers Act, in force since June 19, 2025, requires clients to get a model's clear written approval before creating or using a digital replica, stating scope, purpose, pay and duration.
“Obtain clear written approval from a model before creating or using a model’s digital replica.”
New York's labor department defines a digital replica as a computer-made or AI-enhanced version of a model's face, body or voice. Routine edits like color correction or minor retouching do not count.
“A digital replica does not include routine photographic edits like color correction, minor retouching, or other standard post-production modifications.”
A lawsuit (allegations only) says an app's paid Facebook ad altered a creator's skin and features against her license. The app blamed Meta's automatic Advantage+ creative enhancements, which she disputes.
“Pin Trading App attributed the alterations to Meta’s automatically enabled Advantage+ Creative Standard Enhancements and acknowledged failing to review the advertisements before publication.”
ArentFox Schiff, a law firm, says standard photo rights are not consent to AI replicas of a model. Under New York's Fashion Workers Act, routine retouching is fine, but new AI poses or outfits need written consent.
“standard photo-use rights should not be treated as consent to automatically authorize AI-generated replicas unless the agreement expressly authorizes that use.”
Lathrop GPM, a law firm, says old "edit and reuse" clauses may not cover AI recreations of a person. It advises separate consent and pricing for digital replicas, and no AI training on likeness without consent.
“Price AI and digital-replica rights separately from ordinary content fees.”
Loeb & Loeb, a law firm, says licenses that let brands edit photos rarely cover AI creating new images of a recognizable person, the issue in the Rainbow USA lawsuit, which is at its earliest stages.
“When does an authorized modification of a licensed image become an entirely new depiction of an individual requiring separate permission?”
A model is suing Rainbow, saying her 2024 release did not cover new AI images of her. Rainbow says it allows any alteration. These are allegations, and denying her early injunction was not a ruling on the release.
“may turn less on the novelty of generative AI than on a more familiar question: what rights did the parties’ contracts actually grant?”
A BBB National Programs attorney says that even with a person's consent, AI replicas in ads can mislead, for example by faking an endorsement or a product result, and disclosures cannot cure that.
“Even with consent to use a person’s likeness, certain uses of AI‑generated replicas can violate advertising law.”
BakerHostetler, a law firm, says New York and California require specific written consent for AI replicas of people in ads, with New York fines of $3,000 to $5,000 a violation. Old perpetual rights may not cover AI use.
“You would need to get renewed, specific consent from the model.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer