All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

Should we charge for shipping protection or package insurance at checkout?

The PrevailingPublished Oct 29, 2026

Our answer

Charge for shipping protection only if you will pay claims fast. Offer it as an unticked add-on in the cart with its price and cover shown. Never pre-check it or imply shoppers are unprotected without it.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
1 official rule
1 practitioner, 5 opinions or claims
Sources
7 sources
7 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Shopify's App Store rules bar apps from automatically adding or pre-selecting optional charges. They require the cost shown clearly and the buyer's explicit consent.

Pre-ticked fees carry legal risk. A New York court let deception claims proceed over Thursday Boot's pre-ticked $2.98 fee, which told shoppers who removed it the store was not responsible for lost items, though its carrier covered up to $100 (DLA Piper).

Extra costs drive shoppers away. In Baymard Institute's survey, 39% of shoppers abandoned a checkout over extra costs. Ninety9 (Shopify app maker) argues pre-ticked protection boxes turn into chargebacks and support tickets.

Our judgment

  • If you charge for it, make it an unticked add-on with its price and cover shown in the cart. Shopify's App Store rules require explicit consent for optional charges, DLA Piper reads the Demarco ruling as showing that automatically added optional fees create litigation risk, and Ninety9 says pre-ticked boxes turn into chargebacks and tickets.
  • Carty Labs' case for a pre-ticked protection toggle doesn't change the advice to leave it unticked. Carty Labs sells the toggle, gives no source for its take rates, and pre-selection runs against Shopify's rule for App Store apps.
  • Never tell shoppers who remove it that they have no recourse when your carrier or the law already covers them. This goes by DLA Piper's account of the Demarco ruling.
  • Sell it only if you will make lost, stolen or damaged orders right quickly. Judge it on take rate, refunds and complaints about the fee rather than revenue alone.

Our judgment, built from Shopify, DLA Piper, Ninety9 and Carty Labs: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

7 statements from 7 sources
  • ShopifyUndatedSupports

    Shopify's App Store rules bar apps, such as shipping protection apps, from adding or pre-selecting optional charges without showing the cost clearly and getting the buyer's explicit consent.

    “Apps can't automatically add or pre-select optional charges to a buyer's cart that increase the total checkout price.”

    Read it on shopify.dev

  • RouteAug 28, 2026Caveat

    Route, which sells shopper-paid package protection, says the shopper opts in and pays a small fee, claims are settled with the provider, and programs that work as insurance are regulated.

    “An unlicensed provider creates compliance risk for the merchant offering it.”

    Read it on route.com

  • Ninety9Jul 2, 2026Supports

    Ninety9, which builds Shopify cart apps, says to offer shipping protection as an opt-in add-on below the line items, priced with a floor, and not to sell it unless you will make a lost parcel whole. No data.

    “Pre-ticked boxes convert once, then create chargebacks and tickets.”

    Read it on ninety9.dev

  • ClassAction.orgJun 24, 2026Supports

    A class action, not yet ruled on, alleges Route's widget adds pre-selected shipping protection fees, even on free shipping orders, and that Route keeps roughly half the fees.

    “Per the suit, Route retains roughly half of the fees consumers pay.”

    Read it on classaction.org

  • Baymard InstituteMay 19, 2026Supports

    Baymard says 39% of shoppers in its survey abandoned checkout over extra costs, and advises showing the full order cost, or a clear estimate, in the cart.

    Read it on baymard.com

  • DLA PiperFeb 9, 2026Supports

    A New York court let consumer claims proceed over Thursday Boot's $2.98 shipping protection fee, added to carts by default (not a ruling that it was unlawful). DLA Piper says auto-added optional fees invite lawsuits.

    “automatically adding optional fees to a cart creates litigation risk, as a court may find it could mislead a reasonable customer into believing that the fee is mandatory.”

    Read it on dlapiper.com

  • Carty LabsJan 21, 2026Disagrees

    Carty Labs, which sells a cart app, says shipping protection opt-in runs 60 to 80% when pre-checked and 25 to 45% when not, with no source. Pre-checking conflicts with Shopify's App Store rule.

    “If you sell protection but reject claims, you’ve created a worse brand experience than not offering it at all.”

    Read it on cartylabs.com

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Offers, shipping and returns