Should our abandoned cart emails offer a discount, and to which shoppers?
Our answer
Don't discount every cart reminder. Send the first emails without an offer and save a small one, free shipping or 5 to 10% off, for the last email to shoppers who have never bought. Test it against no offer.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 datasets
- 6 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 12 statements
- KBI
C1TGS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentMost orders need no discount. Across 958 stores using Growth Suite’s targeted offers, 75 to 85% of completed carts checked out with none. Growth Suite argues that offers aimed at everyone mostly pay shoppers who were ready to buy.
Early coupons teach shoppers to abandon on purpose. Klaviyo advises against a coupon in the first email and suggests holding any incentive for the final email or for people who have never bought. Charle and 1Digital wait for the third email.
Returning customers and repeat abandoners get no code. Darkroom gives returning customers no offer in most cases and suppresses offers for repeat abandoners. ATTN Agency gives first-time abandoners 10% off and repeat abandoners urgency only.
Late coded messages convert a larger share of the shoppers who receive them. At one pet store, Yespo, an email and messaging platform, found coded cart messages converted 3.75% of recipients, against 1.26% for messages without a code.
Our judgment
- Use both limits at once. Klaviyo offers holding an incentive for the final email or keeping it for people who have never bought. We do both, because Darkroom and ATTN Agency also keep offers from returning customers and repeat abandoners, and Charle and 1Digital wait for the third email.
- Lead with free shipping where shipping adds to the cost. Extra costs are the top reason shoppers abandon a checkout (Baymard), and free shipping is the second thing hesitant shoppers say would move them (Attentive). Darkroom and 1Digital both use it as the cart offer.
- Send big carts a service email before any offer. We side with Darkroom, whose routing keeps an offer for new customers after the service email, and treat Klaviyo’s high-value-cart offer as something to test.
- Keep an offer only if it beats no offer. Yespo’s own retention marketer says a code’s effect shows only when identical emails with and without it are compared. We extend that to a random group of first-time abandoners held out of the offer (Testing discounts for incrementality).
Our judgment, built from Klaviyo, Darkroom, ATTN Agency, Charle, 1Digital, Baymard Institute, Attentive and Yespo: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
12 statements from 10 sourcesGrowth Suite, which sells targeted-offer software, says a few genuine events a year is the ceiling for storewide sales, because frequency trains customers to wait. It says to measure the weeks after each campaign.
“The campaign's true cost shows up in the full-price dip that follows it.”
Klaviyo advises sending the first abandoned cart message 2-4 hours after checkout starts and a second 20-48 hours later, with longer delays for big-ticket items. It gives no data for the timing.
“We recommend sending your first message between 2-4 hours after someone starts a checkout, and then sending a second email 20-48 hours later.”
Klaviyo says an abandoned cart flow does not need a discount, since discounts can train shoppers to wait. It suggests offering one only on high-value carts and testing offers and timing.
“Consider segmenting high-value carts and only offering an incentive on those where you stand to make more revenue from a single purchase.”
1Digital, an ecommerce agency, suggests abandoned cart emails at 1, 24 and 72 hours, with a time-limited incentive on the third, and browse emails at 4 to 6 and 24 hours. No data for the timing.
“Simple reminder, show the cart, no discount yet”
In Yespo's client flows, cart messages with a code converted 3.75% against 1.26% without, but codes went to shoppers who ignored earlier reminders. Yespo says only a test of identical emails isolates the effect.
“To assess the specific incremental effect of the promo code, the Apteka 9-1-1 team should test identical emails with and without the promo code at the same stage of the scenario.”
Darkroom, a retention agency, sends three cart emails over 72 hours and treats discounts as a gate: none by default, free shipping first for new customers, no offers for repeat abandoners. No test results given.
“a predictable coupon at hour 48 trains the entire list to abandon on purpose”
Tribe, which builds Klaviyo flows, recommends three abandoned checkout emails at one hour, 24 hours and 48 to 72 hours, and one or two for browse abandonment. It gives no data for the timing.
“Browse abandonment emails sent four hours after the visit are too late for most traffic.”
Baymard, a UX research firm, says discount popups and recovery emails win back some distracted or price-sensitive shoppers but do not fix the checkout problems that cause abandonment.
“If your checkout is broken, a discount pop-up won't fix it; it just makes the broken experience cheaper.”
Baymard says 39% of shoppers in its survey abandoned checkout over extra costs, and advises showing the full order cost, or a clear estimate, in the cart.
Charle, a Shopify agency, specifies an abandoned cart flow of 3 emails at 1, 24 and 72 hours with a discount only on email 3, and 1 to 2 browse abandonment emails. It shows no data for the timing.
“only add a discount on email 3.”
Attentive, an SMS and email vendor, surveyed 600 US consumers: 87% of hesitant shoppers said something besides a discount could move them, though a better price still led at 82%, then free shipping at 49%.
“All of these motivators can be added to abandonment flows to speak directly to shoppers who have shown interest but haven't committed yet.”
ATTN Agency advises no discount in the first cart email, saving any offer for email 2 or 3: urgency for high-margin brands and repeat abandoners, a small 10% discount for mid-market brands or first-time abandoners.
“Don't train customers to abandon for discount”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer