How long should our YouTube ads be, and should we use skippable, non-skippable or Shorts formats?
Our answer
Make your main YouTube ad skippable and 30 seconds or longer, often 60 to 90, with the product in the first 5 seconds. Add a vertical Shorts cut. Keep non-skippable ads and bumpers for reach campaigns.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 Google rules
- 7 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 15 statements
- G
CPAAMBUDYG
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentLonger skippable ads sell better. Brett Curry of OMG Commerce has never seen an ad under 30 seconds do well for direct purchases, and his agency's notes say 60 to 90 second ads often beat short ones. Jones Road Beauty found the same.
The skip sets the first deadline. Viewers can skip after 5 seconds, and a paid view counts only at 30 seconds, the whole ad if shorter, or a click (Google). Marketing Bar lands the product or problem before the skip.
Google's limits leave room. Skippable ads have no maximum, with under 3 minutes recommended. Demand Gen keeps videos under 10 seconds out of in-stream and recommends more than 15.
Non-skippable ads and bumpers remind rather than sell. Google offers them only for reach and bills them per impression. AI Advantage Agency, a Performance Max agency, keeps them for warm viewers.
Our judgment
A main cut of 30 seconds or longer, with a 60 to 90 second version in the test, is the range we drew from Brett Curry’s OMG Commerce, Cody Plofker and AI Advantage Agency. Relevant Audience’s 15 to 60 seconds overlaps its lower end, so its warning shapes the opening rather than the length. Keeping non-skippable ads and bumpers out of sales campaigns is our reading of how Google bills and counts them and of how AI Advantage Agency and Relevant Audience use them, as reminders after a longer ad.
Our judgment, built from Brett Curry, Cody Plofker, AI Advantage Agency, Relevant Audience and Google: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 8 sourcesGoogle's video format rules: skippable in-stream ads can be skipped after 5 seconds, CPV bidding pays at 30 seconds watched, and bumper ads run 5 to 6 seconds.
“Viewers can skip the ad after 5 seconds”
Google lists three non-skippable in-stream formats: bumpers up to 6 seconds, standard ads of 7 to 15 seconds, and 16 to 30 second ads on TV screens.
“For non-skippable in-stream, your ad should be 30 seconds (or shorter).”
Google's Demand Gen video specs require at least 5 seconds, bar videos under 10 seconds from in-stream, recommend over 15 seconds, and need the video on YouTube, though it can be unlisted.
“Videos less than 10 seconds are ineligible to serve on YouTube In-stream.”
Google counts a skippable YouTube in-stream view at 30 seconds or the end of the video, whichever comes first, or a click; Shorts ads count at 10 seconds. Bumper and non-skippable ads count no views.
“A viewer watches 30 seconds or until the end of the video, whichever comes first”
Google counts an engaged-view conversion after 10 seconds of a skippable in-stream ad or 5 seconds of an in-feed or Shorts ad, and includes them in the Conversions column.
“You’ll find Engaged-view conversions included in both the “Conversions” and the “All conversions” columns”
Google advises 10 to 30 second vertical videos for action-oriented Shorts ads, under 60 seconds overall since only the first 60 play in the feed. It says sound lifts conversions over 20%, naming no study.
“For action-oriented ads, use 10-30 second vertical videos”
Relevant Audience, an agency, says skippable YouTube ads for consideration usually run 15 to 60 seconds with the product inside the first five seconds. Bumpers run six seconds or less.
“skippable in-stream rewards a message that can survive being interrupted.”
OMG Commerce, which runs YouTube for Jones Road Beauty, says gritty, longer YouTube ads of 60 to 90 seconds or even 2 minutes often beat short polished ones, if fast-paced. No figures.
“It can be longer, but it's got to be fast-paced.”
Cody Plofker of Jones Road Beauty says long YouTube ads have done better for them, audio hooks matter since half the viewing is on TV, and creative should be tested weekly or biweekly.
“Almost everyone obviously is listening with sound on. So I think audio hooks are really important.”
Brett Curry, whose agency runs YouTube ads, prefers fast-paced direct response ads over 30 seconds and says YouTube looks terrible on one-day click ROAS, so judge it another way.
“It's going to be terrible. If that's all you measure, then we should not do that. Do something else”
Marketing Bar, a YouTube agency, says YouTube needs its own creative, with several cuts in 16:9 and 9:16, and the hook must land in five seconds before the skip; it won't recommend YouTube as a first channel.
“YouTube creative is not Meta creative resized.”
Upscale Digital, which sells YouTube ad management, says ecommerce video ads should show the product early, use captions, be shot vertical for Shorts, and land on a page that matches the concept.
“Compose vertical creative for Shorts rather than cropping a horizontal master.”
AI Advantage Agency says skippable YouTube ads work best at 30 to 90 seconds for ecommerce and Shorts at 15 to 45, and treats non-skippable ads as retargeting. No data behind the lengths.
“Non-skippable ads and bumpers are retargeting tools, not acquisition tools.”
Brett Curry, relaying Haus's study of 190 tests, says in-platform reporting undercounts YouTube by about 70%. One retail matched-market test showed about 25% sales lift over eight weeks.
“If you see a one ROAS in platform for YouTube, you're probably actually getting a 3.4 ROAS”
Brett Curry of OMG Commerce, which sells YouTube management, says in his accounts a 5 to 7% Shorts view rate is great, in-stream in the 20s and 30s is good, and CTR over 0.5% is really good.
“If the ROAS was smashing and the view rate was garbage, I wouldn't really care. I would just keep sending money.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer