Should we use Subscribe and Save on Amazon?
Our answer
Use Subscribe and Save on products customers reorder on a steady cycle, if they are in Brand Registry and reliably in stock. Fund 5%, and move to 10% only if sign-ups rise and margin holds.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 Amazon rules
- 5 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 10 statements
- AMASEMVSM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentSubscribe and Save's default gives shoppers little. Amazon enrolls eligible Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) products at a 0% seller-funded discount and adds its own 5% only when a delivery has 5 or more items. It requires Brand Registry and an in-stock rate above 90%.
Losing money on each delivery is not retention. SalesDuo works back from contribution margin and leaves its example $8.50 a delivery at 10% against $10.00 at 5%. Evolve Media warns the discount also lands on buyers who would have reordered anyway.
A deeper discount eats margin fast. My Amazon Guy works out that 10% off a $30 product with a 30% contribution margin cuts contribution by a third.
Our judgment
We start true replenishment products at 5% and move to 10% only when sign-ups rise and each delivery still makes money at 10%. Amazon advises starting at 5% and raising it if sales do not move, and SalesDuo says to work back from contribution margin. We check the program after 2 to 3 months and judge it over about two quarters on whether subscribers keep reordering, since Velocity Sellers says subscription share takes that long to show and 6 months or more to settle, and Evolve Media says the discount has to buy extra reorders. We leave Subscribe and Save off products without a reorder cycle and off products whose margin per delivery turns negative after the discount.
Our judgment, built from Amazon, SalesDuo, Velocity Sellers and Evolve Media: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 6 sourcesAmazon's Subscribe & Save needs Brand Registry, over 90% in-stock and a buyable offer. Sellers fund 0%, 5% or 10% discounts; Amazon suggests starting at 5% and moving to 10% if sales don't change.
“Sellers have three base funding options to choose from: 0%, 5%, or 10%.”
Amazon says Subscribe & Save adds no selling fee but requires Brand Registry, with eligibility based on category, price, sales and in-stock rate. Its example brand grew the program to over 35% of revenue.
“There are no additional selling costs for the Subscribe & Save program.”
Amazon's Subscribe & Save enrolls FBA products at a 0% seller discount with Amazon funding 5%, and sellers can add 5% or 10%. Amazon claims 10 to 15% discounts can lift conversion up to 1.8x.
“On average, Subscribe & Save products with a 10%-15% discount can drive up to a 1.8x increase in conversion”
Amazon US coupons cost a $5 flat fee each plus 2.5% of coupon sales, capped at $2,000, on top of the discount budget, and fees are not refunded on returns.
“Coupon fees aren't refunded if a customer returns the item.”
SalesDuo, an Amazon agency, says to set the Subscribe & Save discount from contribution margin, avoid it for long-lasting, seasonal or thin-margin products, and check stock weekly for the first 90 days.
“If you lose money every time a subscription order ships, that is not customer retention. It is a profit leak.”
My Amazon Guy, an Amazon agency, says Prime's 10% Reorder and Save discount may be seller-funded (unconfirmed); in its example a 10% cut lowers profit 21.8% on repeat buyers who would reorder anyway.
“Until Amazon publishes something seller-facing, the honest answer is that the funding source is unconfirmed and the overlap is strong.”
My Amazon Guy, an agency, says eligible FBA products enter Subscribe and Save at a 0% default where shoppers see little saving, and its example shows 10% funding cutting a 30% margin by a third.
“Eligible FBA products auto-enroll at a 0% default, which is where most sellers quietly stall.”
Velocity Sellers, an Amazon agency, says to fund Subscribe & Save at 10% on true replenishables; in one client case, subscription share of units rose from 1.4% to 12.3% over seven months.
“At 0% funding, your S&S offer displays as roughly nothing”
Denny Smolinski, an Amazon agency founder, says Subscribe & Save suits consumables with steady reorders, and sellers should check margins after seller-funded discounts before enrolling. No data.
“Subscribe & Save is not a fit for every product”
Evolve Media, an Amazon agency, says Subscribe and Save is a margin trap for non-consumables, for buyers who would repurchase anyway, or when margins can't absorb the discount. No data.
“A subscribed customer who would have repurchased at full price anyway costs you the discount on every order forever.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer