Should we run sitewide discounts, product-level offers or loyalty rewards, and how often?
Our answer
Keep sitewide discounts to a few planned moments a year. In between, use product or customer-segment offers for a stated job. Keep hero products at full price, and favor loyalty perks over points that become discounts.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 official rules
- 1 dataset, 3 practitioners, 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 13 statements
GSQ
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentFrequent sales wear down full-price buying, Intelligems (price testing software maker) argues. It says brands promoting monthly or more see full-price purchase rates fall within 6 to 12 months, while quarterly or tentpole-only promoters protect pricing best.
Targeted offers keep most carts at full price. Growth Suite (Shopify discount app maker) caps storewide sales at a handful of public events a year. In its data 75 to 85% of carts checked out without a discount when offers targeted hesitant visitors.
Points paid out as discounts often reward purchases customers would have made anyway, BLOY (Shopify loyalty app maker) and BlueTuskr (ecommerce marketing agency) warn. Smile.io (loyalty app maker) found 36% of shoppers mostly return for another discount.
Our judgment
Hold sitewide discounts to a few planned moments a year and use targeted offers in between. That combines Intelligems's frequency patterns, Growth Suite's ceiling and Quikly's rule on how often a sitewide sale is allowed. Give each product-level offer a named job, such as clearance or slow sellers, and keep hero products at full price, following Growth Suite's clearance rule, Quikly's excluded categories and Cherene Aubert's advice not to discount core products. Prefer loyalty perks such as early access, gifts with purchase or store credit over points that redeem as discount codes, and check any program against a held-out group. That rests on Intelligems's list of incentives that don't train waiting and its segment pause test, BLOY's and BlueTuskr's warnings on points programs and Skio's store credit claim.
Our judgment, built from Intelligems, Growth Suite, Quikly, Cherene Aubert, BLOY, BlueTuskr and Skio: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 13 sourcesShopify says merchants can offer discounts through codes, automatic discounts or sale prices, and can use a rollout to schedule a discount or test it against existing ones.
“or to test a discount against the discounts that your store offers already”
Ireland's regulator, applying EU price rules, says a sale's reference price must be the lowest price charged in the 30 days before the cut; successive cuts in one campaign can use the price before the first cut.
“lowest price […] applied to a product no less than 30 calendar days before applying a price reduction”
In a Smile.io-sponsored survey of 700+ shoppers, 36% said they mostly return to a brand when another discount shows up. No date, country or method is given, and Smile.io sells loyalty software.
“36% said they mostly return when another discount shows up.”
Growth Suite, which sells targeted-offer software, says a few genuine events a year is the ceiling for storewide sales, because frequency trains customers to wait. It says to measure the weeks after each campaign.
“The campaign's true cost shows up in the full-price dip that follows it.”
CTC's Joy says Black Friday discounts below 20% don't move shoppers: keep offers simple (20%+ sitewide), raise order value, add a high-priced bundle, and turn off first-order discount pop-ups.
“Anything below 20%, people don't care.”
Cherene Aubert, a former ILIA Beauty SVP, has seen no meaningful sales lift from deepening a sitewide discount past 20%, and suggests bundles and gifts with purchase rather than deeper discounts.
Jetfuel, an agency, says gift buyers respond better to curated gift sets, free wrapping or threshold offers than to a flat 20% off, and that the real deadline is the last day a gift can arrive by December 25.
“Your real deadline is not December 25. It is the last day a gift can arrive by December 25”
Quikly, which sells promotion software, says plan promotions around the business outcome, limit sitewide sales, and save broad offers for a few periods, since constant sales teach customers to wait.
“If your store never has quiet weeks, customers never feel urgency. They feel patience.”
Skio, which sells subscription software, claims discount-acquired subscribers churn 18-35% faster than full-price ones and recommends store credit over percentage discounts. No method or sample.
“discount-acquired subscribers churn 18-35% faster than full-price subscribers”
Eightx, a fractional CFO firm, keeps normal promotions at 15 to 25% with 25 to 30% sitewide as the ceiling, and prefers bundles, gifts and free shipping thresholds. A finance view, not an ad test.
“25-30% sitewide as the ceiling”
BLOY, which sells loyalty software, says points-for-discounts programs see engagement fade, redemptions cluster around sales, and they struggle to prove incremental value. It shows no data.
“The program may increase repeat orders, but it struggles to prove incremental value.”
Intelligems, which sells offer testing, says brands running promotions monthly or more see full-price purchase rates fall within 6 to 12 months, while quarterly or tentpole-only brands fare better. It shows no data.
“If 15% converts nearly as well as 25%, you've found margin you can protect”
Andrew Maff of BlueTuskr warns loyalty programs often reward purchases customers would have made anyway, eroding margin with no real lift. He says to check monthly what behavior loyalty changed.
“they end up rewarding purchases customers would've made anyway. That creates discount addiction, erodes margin, and produces no meaningful incremental lift.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer