How should we read competitors' ads in Meta's Ad Library and Google's Ads Transparency Center, and what does a long run tell us?
Our answer
Use both libraries to see which angles and offers competitors keep running, not to copy winners. Treat a long run as a reason to look closer, not proof of profit. Neither library shows spend or results for ordinary ads.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 1 Meta rule
- 8 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 11 statements
PG
GLPMB
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentNeither library shows what an ad earned. Google's Transparency Center shows the advertiser, who paid and the ads served, adding targeting and reach only in some regions. Meta's shows the ad and its run time, not cost or return (Phil Graham).
A long run can mean nobody is watching. Phil Graham, a Facebook ads consultant, sees ads left running on tiny budgets, forgotten or losing money. Relevant Audience, a Google Ads agency, says a long runner may sit in an account nobody has reviewed for months.
Run length still helps when patterns repeat. Flighted, a paid media agency, treats 30 days or more as the best public proxy and weights patterns shared across competitors. AdMakeAI, an ad tool maker, trusts an ad that survives while the advertiser cuts others.
On Google you have to infer run length. The Transparency Center shows a last-shown date but no start date, so AdMakeAI compares a date range ending 3 to 4 months back with the last 7 days. Ads shown in the EU also carry reach ranges.
Our judgment
Treat a long run as a reason to study an ad, and trust it more when the same pattern runs long at several competitors or the ad survives while the advertiser cuts others. Flighted and AdMakeAI read run length as a sign of performance, while Phil Graham, Relevant Audience and AdMakeAI itself say neglected and small-budget ads run long too. Search Meta’s library to discover competitors and angles, then check the same brands on Google for their Search and YouTube ads, and skip brands funded very differently from yours.
Our judgment, built from Flighted, AdMakeAI, Phil Graham, Relevant Audience and Andrew Faris: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
11 statements from 8 sourcesGoogle's Ads Transparency Center lets anyone search an advertiser's ads on Search, Display, Gmail and YouTube by name, date and location. It shows no spend, keyword or performance data for commercial ads.
“a searchable repository of advertisers and the ads they’ve served on Google platforms like Search, Display, Gmail, and YouTube.”
Andrew Faris says to completely ignore the ad library of brands funded very differently from yours.
“completely disregard their ad library. Like, completely. Don't even look at it. It's irrelevant to you.”
Matt Bertulli pulled Meta Ad Library counts, such as about 860 ads for Nutrition Geeks and 169 for SpoiledChild to one quiz funnel, but says counts show which pages to study, not what is profitable.
“Ad count won't tell you what's profitable.”
Relevant Audience, an agency, says Google's Ads Transparency Center shows ads and advertiser identity but no spend or performance, so long-running ads or many variants prove little. Use what you see as test ideas.
“An ad running for a long time is not proof it works. It may be a strong ad, or nobody may have reviewed the account in months.”
Lorenzo Pravata, whose agency sells competitor breakdowns, says the Ad Library shows only which ads Meta shows most, not spend, CPA or ROAS per ad. No data.
“You don't see AG1's spend, CPA or ROAS per ad.”
Flighted, an agency, says competitor ad research shows which hooks survive past 30 days, and 30+ days of runtime is the strongest public proxy for performance. It advises turning it into 3 to 5 hook patterns. No data.
“compresses weeks of blind creative testing into a focused first batch of ads”
Flighted, a paid media agency, says a competitor's Meta ad still live after 30 to 60 days is likely working, since Meta throttles weak ads, though it gives no data. Exact spend for commercial ads is not public.
“So an ad still live after 30, 45, or 60 days is one Meta's own algorithm has decided is worth continuing to serve.”
AdMakeAI, a seller of ad research tools, says to spot long-running rival ads in Google's Transparency Center by comparing ads from 3 to 4 months ago with the last 7 days. Spend is hidden outside the EU.
“A long-running ad can also be a neglected one sitting in a low-spend campaign nobody reviews.”
AdMakeAI, an ad research tool vendor, says Meta's Ad Library allows keyword search but drops ads once they stop, while Google's keeps stopped ads a year but searches only by advertiser. Neither shows spend.
“the practical stack for most teams is discovery on Meta, then cross-referencing the same brands on Google to see their Search and YouTube play.”
Phil Graham, who sells ad management, says Meta's Ad Library shows ads and how long they ran but not costs or profit, so a long-running ad is no proof it works. He uses it for patterns and gaps, not copying.
“just because an ad has been running for a long time does not mean that it is a good or even profitable ad.”
Phil Graham says to study competitors in the Ad Library to find what they all do and then do the opposite, so your ads stand out instead of copying them.
“I look and see what they're doing so I can do the opposite so I can differentiate so I can stand out instead of copying them.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer