List growth
Grow the list only with people who sign up with you directly. Judge sign-up offers and partners on what their subscribers do later, not on raw sign-ups.
9 answers · 1 new or changed since Nov 16 · Data as of Nov 22, 2026
The short version
Our judgment, drawn from the 9 answers below.
Never buy, rent or use co-registration lists, and don't pay to identify visitors who never signed up.
From Buying, renting or co-registration lists, Tools that identify anonymous visitors
Offer a small welcome discount, about 10% off as a unique one-time code, and judge it on what sign-ups buy at 30, 60 and 90 days.
Text marketing only to people who opted in themselves through a separate SMS checkbox or keyword after seeing your disclosure.
From Collecting SMS consent legally, SMS keywords and text-to-join
Add an unticked checkout opt-in where you rely on consent, then invite buyers who skipped it again after purchase.
The 9 answers
Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:
Pick the offer
Sign-up offers, quizzes, giveaways and partner swaps.
Which sign-up offers grow the list without attracting discount hunters?
Offer a small welcome discount, about 10% off, as a unique one-time code. Test the pop-up before a bigger discount, and judge each offer on what its sign-ups buy at 30, 60 and 90 days.
Updated Nov 18 Low confidence · 13 sources
How should we grow the list through quizzes and giveaways?
Run a product-finder quiz that asks for the email just before the result, and expect about 40% of starters to leave it. Run giveaways for 8 to 14 days with a prize tied to what you sell.
Medium confidence · 11 sources
How should we grow the list through partner brands and swaps?
Trade mentions with non-competing partner brands, never lists. Each brand features the other in its own emails, linking to the partner's sign-up or offer. Keep the partners whose sign-ups still engage a month later.
Medium confidence · 13 sources
Capture at every touchpoint
Checkout, post-purchase, text-to-join and in-store sign-ups.
How should we capture emails at checkout and after purchase?
Add a checkout opt-in box, unticked by default where you rely on consent, with a separate SMS box. Then invite buyers who skipped it in the first post-purchase email, at account sign-up and in the package.
High confidence · 9 sources
How should we use SMS keywords and text-to-join?
Use keywords where a form can't reach: packaging, receipts, store signs, events and social posts. Add tap to text to mobile forms. Have subscribers reply to confirm, show disclosure text beside every keyword and use one keyword per channel.
High confidence · 9 sources
How should we capture emails from in-store or event customers?
Ask for the address at the till or booth with a digital receipt and a separate marketing question. Add QR codes with consent wording, tag each sign-up by store or event, and count sign-ups per store, shift and event.
Medium confidence · 12 sources
Stay within the rules
SMS consent, bought lists and tools that identify anonymous visitors.
How should we collect SMS consent legally?
Text marketing only to people who opted in themselves through a separate SMS checkbox or keyword after seeing your disclosure. Confirm each sign-up by text, keep a record of every consent and honor STOP within 10 business days.
High confidence · 10 sources
Should we buy or rent lists or use co-registration?
Don't buy, rent or use co-registration lists. Email platforms ban them, Spamhaus calls bought and rented lists the top source of spam trap hits, and consent never transfers. Get partner reach only by having people sign up with you directly.
High confidence · 11 sources
Should we pay for list growth tools that identify anonymous site visitors?
Don't pay to identify site visitors who never signed up and then email or text them. Spend on recognizing your own subscribers instead, and test any vendor only in a holdout that counts complaints.
High confidence · 13 sources
More in Email and SMS
86 answers in 9 subjects
Guides that use these answers: How to start email and SMS marketing