How should we grow the list through partner brands and swaps?
Our answer
Trade mentions with non-competing partner brands, never lists. Each brand features the other in its own emails, linking to the partner's sign-up or offer. Keep the partners whose sign-ups still engage a month later.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 7 official rules
- 4 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 15 statements
- KBMSDCBEIAW
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentEach new subscriber has to join on your own form. Klaviyo and Mailchimp ban sending to partner or third-party lists, and Spamhaus (email blocklist operator) requires permission that does not pass from one organization to another.
A well-targeted swap turns 1 to 5% of the partner's audience into subscribers, Benchmark Email advises. Linda Hwang, a consultant writing on beehiiv's blog, sees 3 to 5% from a dedicated email and 1 to 2% from an in-issue mention.
Engagement matters more than size. Destini Copp (creator coach) says a list of 3,000 at a 50% open rate sends more subscribers than 12,000 at 15%, and she caps swaps at about one a month.
Our judgment
Sending people to sign up with each brand directly, with no exchange of contacts, is our choice because it keeps consent with the business people joined. That combines the swap practice Benchmark Email, beehiiv and Destini Copp describe with the bans on partner lists from Klaviyo, Mailchimp and Spamhaus. We apply this newsletter method to consumer brands, since WiserNotify and Omnisend describe the same partner fit for stores: the same customer with a different product. The sign-up rates stay a newsletter benchmark. Judging partners on engagement read on clicks or on opens with Apple privacy opens filtered out (Subject lines and preview text), and rotating three or four of them, joins Destini Copp's one-month check and her three or four partners a quarter with Benchmark Email's engagement and unsubscribe checks.
Our judgment, built from Benchmark Email, beehiiv, Destini Copp, Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Spamhaus, WiserNotify and Omnisend: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 13 sourcesbeehiiv says paid recommendations let newsletters pay other publishers per verified subscriber, with a 20% fee built into the price, for example $2.50 paid and $2 to the recommender.
“You are only charged for subscribers who pass verification.”
SparkLoop offers free newsletter recommendation swaps, or paid partner programs from $100 a month where you pay only for subscribers still subscribed after 14 days.
“you only pay for subscribers who are still subscribed after 14 days”
Spamhaus, the blocklist operator, says lack of permission is a leading reason for listing: never mail bought, rented or harvested lists, use confirmed opt-in, and keep timestamped consent records.
“Do not send emails to purchased, rented, or harvested lists, as these are the most common source of spam trap hits.”
Klaviyo says SMS consent must be collected separately from email, can't come from bought lists or be required to make a purchase, and US carriers require double opt-in for cart abandonment flows.
“Having consent for email does not mean you have consent for SMS.”
WiserNotify, which sells pop-up widgets, says cross-promote with a partner that shares your customer but not your product, track each campaign with unique links or codes, and start with a newsletter swap.
“Pick a partner with the same customer but a different product.”
Jacob of Pilothouse, an agency, suggests a giveaway ending before Black Friday, with a squeeze page and lead gen ads to collect emails, saying non-winners often buy anyway. No results or costs given.
“Everyone that signed up that didn't win. There's a bit of FOMO there and a lot of the time they're going to come purchase anyways.”
Benchmark Email says newsletter swaps work best between lists of similar size and strong engagement, placed near the top, and a good swap typically converts 1 to 5% of the partner's audience. No data given.
“A 30,000-subscriber newsletter with 10% open rates is a worse partner than a 5,000-subscriber newsletter with 50% open rates.”
Creator coach Destini Copp says swap with engaged lists over big ones, link to a resource placed after your first section, tag each swap's link, and check signups and opens a month later. No data.
“A list of 3,000 people with a 50 percent open rate will send you more subscribers than a list of 12,000 at 15 percent.”
Admailr, which sells newsletter placements, says consumer newsletters typically cost $15 to $35 CPM, and advises running three to four consecutive issues in well-matched newsletters before expanding.
“Two or three well-matched newsletters run consistently will teach you more than a dozen one-off placements.”
Omnisend, which sells email software, suggests joint giveaways with a complementary brand that require sign-up to both lists, stated in the entry terms, and paying affiliates for confirmed sign-ups.
“participation should require an email sign-up with both brands.”
The UK's ICO says a bought email list is usable only if the consent named your organisation and was recorded, and no third-party list can rely on the soft opt-in, which needs details collected directly.
“There is no such thing as a third-party marketing list that is compliant with the soft opt-in.”
Klaviyo's acceptable use policy bars sending to purchased, rented, borrowed or third-party lists, or any contacts who have not consented to hear from your business.
“Harvest or otherwise collect information about individuals without their consent.”
A consultant on beehiiv's blog says newsletter swaps won her clients 200 to 500 subscribers each, with 3 to 5% conversion from dedicated emails and 1 to 2% from mentions. No sample or method given.
“Mismatched audiences will kill your swap”
Indie Author Magazine tells self-published authors newsletter swaps are a low-cost way to reach readers when partners share values, swaps read as recommendations, and results are checked a day and a week after.
“Present Swaps as Recommendations Rather than Ads.”
Mailchimp's policy bans sending to purchased, rented, third-party, co-registration, publicly available or partner lists of any kind.
“Upload or send email Campaigns to purchased, rented, third-party, co-reg, publicly available data, or partner lists of any kind.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer