Measurement

Treat the revenue your email and SMS tools report as credit, not cause. Judge results by cohort and against your own past results, and test what they cause with a holdout.

10 answers · 2 new or changed since Nov 16 · Data as of Nov 22, 2026

Answers for any spend, own site only, general category, United States.

The short version

Our judgment, drawn from the 10 answers below.

Report email and SMS revenue as a share of store net revenue, never add it to ad revenue and test causes with a holdout.

From Measuring email and SMS revenue

Judge each email on clicks with bot clicks filtered out, placed orders and revenue per recipient, and keep opens only as a trend.

From Email metrics now that opens are unreliable

Value subscribers and customers by cohort, and judge each cohort only once it is old enough, against your own earlier cohorts.

From The value of a subscriber, Lifetime value by acquisition channel, Building and reading cohort reports

Benchmark revenue per recipient like for like, starting with your own past sends, and never compare campaigns against flows.

From Revenue per recipient benchmarks

The 10 answers

Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:

Credit revenue fairly

How much revenue to credit email, SMS and loyalty, and what to compare it against.

  1. How should we measure email and SMS revenue without overcounting?

    Treat the revenue your email and SMS tools report as credit, not cause. Tighten and log the settings, report it as a share of store net revenue and never add it to ad revenue. Test causes with a holdout.

    Updated Nov 20 Medium confidence · 9 sources

  2. What revenue share from email and SMS should a consumer brand expect?

    Expect email and SMS to be credited with about 20 to 40% of store revenue once core flows run, and less while the program is young. Judge the share against your own past months on locked attribution settings.

    Medium confidence · 10 sources

  3. How should we benchmark flow and campaign revenue per recipient?

    Benchmark revenue per recipient like for like. Start with your own last 8 to 12 comparable sends, then your platform's peer group, then published figures for the same flow type and order value. Never compare campaigns against flows.

    Medium confidence · 8 sources

  4. How should we measure loyalty program profit?

    Measure loyalty profit as incremental gross profit against a random holdout not offered the program. Subtract rewards at cost, outstanding points and platform and staff costs. Treat any gap between members and non-members as an upper bound.

    Medium confidence · 7 sources

Judge sends and growth

Which email metrics to trust and how to track list growth.

  1. Which email metrics matter now that open rates are unreliable?

    Judge each email on clicks with bot clicks filtered out, placed orders and revenue per recipient. Watch unsubscribes, bounces and spam complaints. Keep opens only as a trend against your own past sends.

    Medium confidence · 10 sources

  2. What list growth rate should a consumer brand our size aim for?

    Published growth targets disagree. Track net list growth each month against your own trend and keep sign-ups ahead of what the list loses. Drive them through a sign-up form submit rate of at least 3%.

    Low confidence · 9 sources

Value customers by cohort

How to build cohorts and measure subscriber value, lifetime value and churn.

  1. How should we build and read cohort reports?

    Build cohorts by first-order month in Shopify or Klaviyo, grouping by quarter below about 100 new customers a month. Read rows, columns and diagonals. Judge a cohort only after 90 days, against your own earlier cohorts.

    Medium confidence · 11 sources

  2. How should we measure the value of a subscriber?

    Value subscribers by sign-up cohort. Track what each month's and each source's new subscribers buy in store orders at 30, 60 and 90 days against what they cost. Treat list-wide revenue per subscriber as a trend only.

    Medium confidence · 14 sources

  3. How should we measure customer lifetime value by acquisition channel?

    Tag each customer with the channel that won the first order and keep it on later orders. Compare channels on contribution per customer at 3, 6 and 12 months, using only cohorts old enough to have reached each age.

    Updated Nov 17 Medium confidence · 15 sources

  4. How should we measure churn for one-time buyers?

    Flag a one-time buyer as at risk at 1.5 times your median first-to-second order gap, and as lapsed at about twice it. Report each first-order cohort's lapsed share and month 12 churn apart from subscription cancellations.

    Medium confidence · 12 sources

More in Email and SMS

86 answers in 9 subjects

Guides that use these answers: How to start email and SMS marketing

See all 86 Email and SMS answers in one list