Subscriptions

Offer subscriptions only on products customers reorder on a predictable cycle, at the smallest discount that converts. Then keep subscribers by fixing failed payments first and making changes and cancelling easy.

11 answers · 2 new or changed since Nov 16 · Data as of Nov 22, 2026

Answers for any spend, own site only, general category, United States.

The short version

Our judgment, drawn from the 11 answers below.

Offer subscriptions only on products customers already reorder on a predictable cycle, and launch only if monthly churn stays below about 16%.

From Whether to offer subscriptions

Start the discount at 10 to 15% and test a shallower one, keeping the smallest that converts about as well on retention and margin.

From Setting a subscription discount

Fix failed payments first, then add self-serve skip, delay, swap and frequency changes with a reminder before each charge.

From Reducing subscription cancellations, Failed subscription payments

Before payment, show price, frequency, renewal and how to cancel with a separate consent, and let customers cancel online where they signed up.

From Subscription consumer protection rules

The 11 answers

Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:

Decide and set up

Which products fit, which app to use, how to switch apps and the legal steps.

  1. Should we offer subscriptions, and for which products?

    Offer subscriptions on products customers already reorder on a predictable cycle. Skip them for products bought once or twice a year. Launch only if monthly churn stays below about 16%, the ceiling for a six-month payback.

    Medium confidence · 12 sources

  2. Which subscription app should we use on Shopify?

    Start subscriptions on a free plan: Shopify Subscriptions, Appstle or Seal. Move to Loop, Recharge or Skio past about $10,000 a month of subscription sales, or when you need bundles, prepaid plans or save flows, comparing total fees first.

    Updated Nov 17 Medium confidence · 10 sources

  3. How do we move subscribers to a new subscription app without losing renewals?

    Before you set a date, find out where each subscriber's card is stored. Then switch billing on one day, keep the old app installed with billing off, and point every portal link at the new app.

    New Nov 17 Medium confidence · 8 sources

  4. How should we follow subscription consumer protection rules?

    Before payment, show price, frequency, renewal and how to cancel, with a separate consent. Send a confirmation and renewal reminders, let customers cancel online where they signed up and keep consent records at least three years.

    High confidence · 15 sources

Price and forecast

Subscription and prepaid discounts, and the retention to expect by month.

  1. What subscription discount should we offer?

    Start subscribe and save in the 10 to 15% range and test it against a shallower discount. Keep the smallest that converts about as well, judged on retention and margin at 60 to 90 days and six months.

    Low confidence · 11 sources

  2. How should we price prepaid subscriptions?

    Bill several deliveries up front at a deeper discount than your monthly subscription, near the 10 to 20% Eightx suggests for annual plans. Offer quarterly right after the first order. Set cancellation and renewal rules first.

    Medium confidence · 6 sources

  3. What subscription retention rate should we expect by month?

    Expect 63 to 75% of new monthly subscribers to reorder once, 27 to 34% to reach about month 3, 12 to 19% month 6 and 5 to 8% a year. Compare by renewal within your vertical.

    Medium confidence · 7 sources

Keep subscribers

Failed payments, self-serve changes, the cancel flow and win-back emails.

  1. How should we reduce subscription cancellations?

    Fix failed payments first. Then offer self-serve skip, delay, swap and frequency changes with a reminder before each charge, and coach subscribers past the first few orders. Build the cancel flow last.

    Medium confidence · 10 sources

  2. How should we handle failed subscription payments?

    Let your subscription app retry failed payments for about two weeks. Message customers only once they must act, with a one-click card update link, warn before cards expire, and pause rather than cancel when retries run out.

    Medium confidence · 9 sources

  3. How should the cancellation flow work, and what offers should it make?

    Keep a cancel link visible on every screen, ask one reason and make one matching offer. Offer pause or skip before discounts, and none when the product failed. Cancel promptly if declined, and expect about 15 to 25% saved.

    Medium confidence · 16 sources

  4. How should we win back cancelled subscribers?

    Confirm the cancellation without an offer, then email cancelled subscribers at 30, 60 and 90 days with a one-click way back. Match the offer to their reason, start modest and stop after three or four emails.

    Medium confidence · 7 sources

More in Email and SMS

86 answers in 9 subjects

Guides that use these answers: How to market a local service business

See all 86 Email and SMS answers in one list