Should we pay for list growth tools that identify anonymous site visitors?
Our answer
Don't pay to identify site visitors who never signed up and then email or text them. Spend on recognizing your own subscribers instead, and test any vendor only in a holdout that counts complaints.
- Confidence
- High
- Strongest proof
- 10 official rules
- 1 practitioner, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 16 statements
- KGSMJJAUFI
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentMailing people who never signed up breaks sender rules. Klaviyo says to email only subscribed profiles and bars lists that never consented to your business. Gmail says not to mail people who didn't sign up, and Spamhaus (email blocklist operator) says permission doesn't transfer.
These tools can cost a lot and are hard to justify. Joy Joya (email and SMS agency) does not recommend them, because extra revenue can be hard to prove and the potential harm to deliverability and trust is real.
Sellers of visitor identification tools make conflicting accuracy claims. Opensend (visitor identification software maker) claims a 73% match rate. CustomersAI (email revenue software maker), which sells a rival tool, says most tools get the person right only 5 to 30% of the time.
Our judgment
We extend the sender rules to contacts from a visitor identification tool, so you may not email or text them. Beyond the rules above, Mailchimp bans partner and publicly available lists, and Klaviyo rules that a phone number is not SMS consent. Putting recognition of people who already subscribed or bought first is the side we take. Klaviyo identifies browsers from its forms, email clicks and checkout and backfills their earlier browsing, Attentive defines identity resolution as recognizing opted-in subscribers, and Joy Joya says the smartest strategy starts with clean first-party data and strong opt-ins. Judging any vendor in a holdout beside your existing abandonment flows, with complaints and unsubscribes counted beside revenue, follows Joy Joya's advice, because the match rates are the sellers' own claims.
Our judgment, built from Klaviyo, Google, Spamhaus, Mailchimp, Attentive, Joy Joya, CustomersAI and Opensend: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
16 statements from 13 sourcesGmail tells senders not to buy email lists or mail people who didn't sign up, since those recipients may mark messages as spam and future mail to them will be marked as spam.
“Don't purchase email addresses from other companies.”
The FTC says CAN-SPAM covers all commercial email, with penalties up to $53,088 per email. It needs no opt-in consent, but opt-outs must be honored within 10 business days, even if another firm sends.
“Each separate email in violation of the CAN-SPAM Act is subject to penalties of up to $53,088”
An academic audit of two identity-resolution vendors, on 2019 to 2020 data, found a high match rate does not mean matches are the right people: match quality was 21.8% and 23.6%, about 15% and 13% precision.
“Yet a high match rate does not necessarily mean that those matched identifiers belong to the submitted records (i.e., the intended targets).”
Spamhaus, the blocklist operator, says lack of permission is a leading reason for listing: never mail bought, rented or harvested lists, use confirmed opt-in, and keep timestamped consent records.
“Do not send emails to purchased, rented, or harvested lists, as these are the most common source of spam trap hits.”
Klaviyo says SMS consent must be collected separately from email, can't come from bought lists or be required to make a purchase, and US carriers require double opt-in for cart abandonment flows.
“Having consent for email does not mean you have consent for SMS.”
Klaviyo warns that emailing people who have not opted in can get emails marked as spam and hurt deliverability. It says not to email broad segments, such as everyone active on site.
“Emailing contacts who haven't opted in can cause your emails to be marked as spam and negatively impact your deliverability.”
Apple says Safari in its version 27 releases blocks network access to identity resolution services that collect emails to track people across sites, while first-party personalization is not blocked.
“First party personalization is not tracking, and is not what our technologies seek to prevent.”
Joy Joya, an email agency, advises against identity tools that email people never on your list: costly, hard to prove incremental, and risky for deliverability. First-party matching is the safer use.
“Probabilistic matching means inference, not certainty.”
Attentive, which sells email and SMS software, says recognizing returning opted-in subscribers matters more as Apple cut cookie life to 7 days. Its customer and survey figures have no method.
“Apple shortened first-party cookie lifespans from 30 days to 7 and turns off third-party cookies by default.”
Opensend, ranking its own tool first, claims its identity graph of 180M+ US shoppers matches 73% of anonymous visitors to contacts, with no method and no word on how those contacts consented.
The UK's ICO says a bought email list is usable only if the consent named your organisation and was recorded, and no third-party list can rely on the soft opt-in, which needs details collected directly.
“There is no such thing as a third-party marketing list that is compliant with the soft opt-in.”
DirectMail.io, which sells this service, says a pixel can match 25 to 50% of anonymous site visitors to a postal address for direct mail, and calls it legal with a disclosure. It gives no data or legal citation.
“Mailing every anonymous visitor is creepy.”
Klaviyo's acceptable use policy bars sending to purchased, rented, borrowed or third-party lists, or any contacts who have not consented to hear from your business.
“Harvest or otherwise collect information about individuals without their consent.”
Klaviyo identifies shoppers who submit its forms, click its emails or go through checkout, can backfill their earlier browsing still in local storage, and merges profiles linked by email or phone.
“Only activity that was captured and is still available in that browser’s local storage can be backfilled.”
CustomersAI, which sells visitor identification, claims rival tools identify visitors correctly 5 to 30% of the time and its own is 2 to 7 times more accurate, with no method shown.
“Most visitor ID solutions get identities right 5-30% of the time.”
Mailchimp's policy bans sending to purchased, rented, third-party, co-registration, publicly available or partner lists of any kind.
“Upload or send email Campaigns to purchased, rented, third-party, co-reg, publicly available data, or partner lists of any kind.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer