How should we grow the list through quizzes and giveaways?
Our answer
Run a product-finder quiz that asks for the email just before the result, and expect about 40% of starters to leave it. Run giveaways for 8 to 14 days with a prize tied to what you sell.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 2 datasets, 7 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 11 sources
- 12 statements
- CM
EMOO
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA quiz turns a large share of starters into leads. Interact's data shows its quizzes convert 40.1% of the people who start them, and 37.6% for ecommerce quizzes. Interact says quizzes convert existing traffic rather than create it.
Ask for the email late, not up front. Evolve Media (ecommerce marketing agency) asks just before the result reveal and Omnisend after the questions. Okendo (reviews and loyalty software maker) warns that requiring email raises drop-off and fake addresses.
Generic prizes draw freebie hunters, Top Growth Marketing and Omnisend argue. Length matters too. Across more than 70,000 contests, those run 8 to 14 days drew the most entrants, 956 on average (SweepWidget, giveaway software maker).
Our judgment
- Put the email ask after the questions and just before the result, with a stated reason to give it. This combines Evolve Media's capture before the result reveal, Omnisend's advice that the ask come after the quiz and Okendo's warning against requiring email.
- Tie the giveaway prize to what you sell, unless you run a full-price sweepstakes that gives extra entries for purchases. Top Growth Marketing and Omnisend say generic prizes draw freebie hunters, while Ridge's attention-grabbing prizes sit beside purchase entries.
- Run giveaways for 8 to 14 days, and longer only when the giveaway builds a list ahead of a big sale, as Ridge's six-week campaign does. Keep entry to two or three actions with the opt-in first, because SweepWidget's gain from more entry methods counts entrants rather than buyers and Top Growth Marketing keeps its best giveaways to 2 to 3 actions.
- Judge quizzes and giveaways on what their sign-ups buy over the following months, tagged by source, rather than on entries or capture rates. That follows Ridge's advice to track entrants' purchases, HexClad's 86 days to first purchase and Omnisend's tagging of entrants.
Our judgment, built from Evolve Media, Omnisend, Okendo, Top Growth Marketing, Connor MacDonald (Ridge), SweepWidget and HexClad: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
12 statements from 11 sourcesBrad Ploch says a quiz page for a single-product brand took Meta spend like other landing pages, and split tests improved it: six problem-focused questions doubled revenue per visitor. Sample sizes are not given.
“sit in the problem longer”
HexClad says its 2024 sweepstakes opt-ins took 86 days on average to first purchase, and it ties extra entries to purchase size to deter unserious entrants. A Ridge guest calls such leads very unqualified.
“The value of those emails is obviously questionable. It's a very unqualified lead that you're gathering at that point.”
Top Growth Marketing, which sells giveaway campaigns, says giveaways fail by default on freebie hunters: offer your own product worth $200 to $1,000, add opt-in friction, then follow up with an offer.
“never an iPhone, gift card, or generic prize that attracts non-buyers”
Ridge says sweepstakes leads are less qualified, but list growth and visibility pay off for months; it tags entrants and tracks what they buy. Lift is strongest for lower-priced items. No purchase rates are given.
“Tag everyone who enters and track what they buy over the next few months. Many free entries convert later, often during your next big sale.”
Ridge's CMO says its six-week sweepstakes, run in a slow season at full price, drove about 50% revenue growth year over year at a better MER. He suggests holding out ads by region to read the lift.
“Comparing this year's campaign with last year's tells us whether it grew. It doesn't tell us how much revenue we would have generated without it.”
Interact, which sells quiz software, says its quizzes average 40.1% of starters becoming leads, 37.6% for ecommerce quizzes; that is not a share of all site visitors, and results range from none to over 80%.
“The 40.1% figure is not the percentage of all website visitors who become leads.”
Jacob of Pilothouse, an agency, suggests a giveaway ending before Black Friday, with a squeeze page and lead gen ads to collect emails, saying non-winners often buy anyway. No results or costs given.
“Everyone that signed up that didn't win. There's a bit of FOMO there and a lot of the time they're going to come purchase anyways.”
Evolve Media, which builds quiz funnels, says from 40+ client builds that a 4 to 7 question quiz with email capture before the result captures 3 to 5x more emails than a static form. No method shown.
“4-7 questions. 30-50% completion rate. Email capture immediately before the result reveal.”
Okendo, which sells quiz software, says a reward can lift email capture in quizzes, but requiring an email likely raises drop-off and invites fake addresses.
“requiring email is likely to increase drop-off rate and reduce overall completions and conversions.”
Omnisend says ask for the email after a quiz to unlock results, not before, and give away prizes tied to your products, since generic prizes draw freebie hunters who unsubscribe.
“Visitors will not start a quiz they know is just a lead capture.”
CTC says each audience needs its own landing page, offer and creative together, and warns against copying a big brand's quiz funnel by default.
SweepWidget, a giveaway platform, reports that across 70,000+ contests, 8 to 14 day giveaways drew 956 entrants on average versus 525 for 4 to 7 days. Contests with 12 entry methods drew 1,926. No sales data.
“Our data from 70,000+ giveaways shows a clear correlation: more entry methods means more entrants.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer