How should we handle failed subscription payments?
Our answer
Let your subscription app retry failed payments for about two weeks. Message customers only once they must act, with a one-click card update link, warn before cards expire, and pause rather than cancel when retries run out.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 7 official rules
- 1 dataset, 3 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 14 statements
- S
LSS
RR
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentMany failures clear without the customer. About 15% recover with no customer action, Skio claims, and 90% of recovered payments come back within 10 days in Recurly's data.
Retries can't fix a dead card. Stripe won't retry hard declines without a new payment method, and Loop Subscriptions and Recurpay advise sending those customers straight to a card update.
About half of failed payments is a realistic target to win back. Darkroom (paid media agency) uses that figure and routes a final failure to a grace period and then a pause.
Our judgment
- Retry for about two weeks, with 2 or 3 retries in the first few days. That joins Stripe's recommended default of 8 tries within 2 weeks, Recurpay's 2 to 3 retries in the first 48 to 72 hours and at least 4 over a 14-day window, Loop Subscriptions' front-loaded schedule and Recurly's 10-day finding.
- Hold the first failed payment email until a retry has failed or the card must be replaced. That follows Skio's advice to notify only after multiple retries, the quiet first retries of Loop Subscriptions and Recurpay, and Churn Buster's note that often 10% or more resolve before anyone contacts the customer.
- Skip or pause rather than cancel when retries run out. That follows Darkroom's grace period then pause, Loop Subscriptions' skip, pause and cancel order, and the pause options Shopify and Stripe both offer.
- Keep any recovery discount small, one use per customer and late in the sequence. That follows Skio's one-per-customer advice and Loop Subscriptions' escalating incentive.
Our judgment, built from Stripe, Recurpay, Loop Subscriptions, Recurly, Skio, Churn Buster, Darkroom and Shopify: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
14 statements from 9 sourcesShopify says its Subscriptions app lets merchants set the number and spacing of retries for failed payments or low inventory, and whether to skip, pause or cancel after the last one. No defaults given.
“You can also choose to skip, pause, or cancel the subscription when all retry attempts have failed.”
Stripe recommends Smart Retries for failed subscription payments, by default 8 tries within 2 weeks; hard declines such as lost or stolen cards only go through with a new payment method.
“The recommended default setting is 8 tries within 2 weeks.”
Stripe Billing can automatically email customers after each failed subscription payment so they can update their payment method, and 1 month before their default card expires.
“Customer emails help prevent involuntary churn by notifying customers and giving them a chance to intervene when churn is likely, like when a payment fails.”
Stripe says it automatically tries to update saved cards when banks issue replacements. This is widely supported for most major US cards, but international support varies by country.
“Saved payment method details can continue to work even if the issuing bank replaces the physical card.”
Skio, a subscription app, says retries recover about 15% of failed payments without customer action; it suggests 7 retries 3 days apart before emailing subscribers, then a one-use discount in a third phase.
“A significant portion of failed payments can be recovered automatically without customer action, about 15 percent on average.”
Skio, a subscription app, lets subscribers add one backup card that is charged automatically if the main card fails. It suggests reminding customers to update cards and a small discount for adding one.
“Offer a small discount for customers who add a backup payment method to incentivize setup.”
Shopify Subscriptions emails customers 3 days before each recurring charge so they can skip, pause or cancel, and lets them manage subscriptions themselves. Third-party apps follow their own schedule.
“Shopify Subscriptions emails your customer 3 days before each recurring order is charged.”
Churn Buster, which sells dunning software, says on Shopify the subscription app controls payment retries; often 10%+ of failed payments resolve before the customer is contacted.
“Often 10%+ of failed payments resolve before anyone contacts the customer.”
Recurpay, a subscription app seller, advises 2 to 3 retries in the first 48 to 72 hours, later retries around payday, and stopping on hard declines. Its recovery rates come with no source.
“Stop retrying immediately on hard declines or fraud flags and route those customers straight to a payment-update prompt instead.”
Darkroom, a retention agency, says tuned billing recovers about half of failed subscription payments and a pause-first cancel flow saves 15 to 25% of attempts, from its own clients with no sample size.
“A generic 10% coupon shown to everyone overpays customers who would have stayed and underpays your high-value defectors.”
Eightx, a fractional CFO firm, puts monthly churn at 4 to 7% for replenishment subscriptions and 8 to 12% for curated boxes, and says 1 to 3 points of churn are often fixable through billing retries alone.
“If your monthly churn is 8%, somewhere between 1 and 3 of those points is fixable purely via dunning and card retry, before you touch the save flow.”
Recurly, which sells billing software, says 90% of recovered payments come within 10 days of failure, and one membership retailer's modeled recovery rose from about 53% to 71% with its retries.
“90% of recovered transactions occur within the first 10 days of a failed payment”
Loop, which sells a subscription app, says expired cards and voluntary cancels need different fixes: card retries and expiry alerts for one, pause, skip and swap options for the other. It gives benchmarks with no method.
“A cancellation flow won't fix expired cards. Payment retries won't help a subscriber drowning in overstock.”
Loop Subscriptions, which sells a subscription app, says retry soft declines across the billing cycle, stop retrying fraud declines, ask for new cards on hard declines, and pause before cancelling.
“Immediate cancellation shouldn't be the default.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer