How should we follow subscription consumer protection rules?
Our answer
Before payment, show price, frequency, renewal and how to cancel, with a separate consent. Send a confirmation and renewal reminders, let customers cancel online where they signed up and keep consent records at least three years.
- Confidence
- High
- Strongest proof
- 12 official rules
- 1 dataset, 3 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 15 sources
- 17 statements
CGBUFCBCA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentFederal law requires clear terms before billing details, express consent before any charge and a simple way to stop (Goodwin). It is still enforced. Shutterstock agreed in May 2026 to pay $35 million over unclear terms and hard cancellation (Covington).
State laws apply where the customer lives. Benesch (law firm) counts 28 states plus the District of Columbia with automatic renewal laws. Churnkey (cancel flow software maker) says meeting their common core keeps you compliant in most of the country.
Reminders also prevent disputes. More than a quarter of merchants with recurring billing send no reminder before charging, Chargebacks911 (chargeback management service) found, and it calls renewal reminders one of the simplest ways to prevent disputes.
Our judgment
Build one sign-up, reminder and cancellation process to the strictest common rules rather than tracking each state. Churnkey's point that the laws apply where the customer lives, and Davis+Gilbert LLP's and Benesch's account of the same core across states, lead us there. Keep consent records for at least three years for every customer, since California requires it and both federal law and the Shutterstock order turn on whether consent was express and informed. Treat renewal reminders and easy cancellation as cost savers as well as duties, because Chargebacks911 ties missing reminders and hard cancellation to chargebacks.
Our judgment, built from Churnkey, Davis+Gilbert, Benesch, Covington and Chargebacks911: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
17 statements from 15 sourcesMacha, which sells AI helpdesk agents, says California allows a cancellation save offer only with a cancel option beside it; it makes one offer matched to the reason, then cancels promptly.
“The offer should match the reason.”
The EU Commission plans a Digital Fairness Act proposal for late 2026 that names trouble cancelling and renewing digital subscriptions as a problem. It is not law yet.
“difficulties with the cancellation and renewal of digital subscriptions”
Benesch, a law firm, says 28 states and DC regulate auto-renewing subscriptions, and California, Illinois and Virginia require clear terms next to the consent button and separate consent to renewal.
“28 states and the District of Columbia have enacted laws or regulations addressing automatically-renewing consumer subscriptions”
Kelley Drye, a law firm, reports New York City's cancellation rule took effect October 1, 2026, requiring cancellation through every channel used to sign up. Louisiana's Click to Cancel Act starts January 1, 2027.
“if consent was obtained in person, the business must additionally offer an online cancellation option, where practical”
A law firm summarizes Colorado's 2026 auto-renewal update: online subscriptions need immediate online cancellation, and retention offers may show only beside a prominent cancel link.
“Businesses may still display retention offers or discounted pricing during the cancellation process, but the business must simultaneously and prominently display a cancellation link.”
Churnkey, which sells cancellation software, says US auto-renewal laws apply where the customer lives and commonly require clear terms, active consent and renewal notices. Confirm with counsel.
“If you sell auto-renewing subscriptions to consumers in a state, that state's law applies to you.”
Churnkey, which sells cancel-flow software, says Colorado and Massachusetts require easy online cancellation, Virginia does from July 2026, and Minnesota limits save offers. It is not legal advice.
“Offer an online cancel that is at least as easy as signup.”
Chargebacks911, which sells chargeback management, says over 32% of merchants see subscription billing as a chargeback risk and over a quarter of recurring sellers send no pre-billing reminder. No sample given.
“Renewal reminders remain one of the simplest and most effective dispute prevention tools available.”
CMS, a law firm, says Sweden requires online sellers to offer a clear withdrawal button from June 19, 2026, with confirmation, under an EU directive other member states also implement.
Shutterstock agreed to a $35 million FTC settlement over subscriptions buyers didn't know they joined, terms in gray text under the button and hard cancellation. It must now get clear consent and easy cancellation.
“Those consumers who could cancel online were required to navigate multiple pages, prompts, and retention screens to cancel.”
Davis+Gilbert lawyers say subscription terms must be shown before billing details and agreed to separately, ideally with an unchecked box, and warn that 'cancel anytime' is rarely accurate.
“these two words are rarely accurate and can get you into hot water.”
Davis+Gilbert summarizes US state subscription laws: disclose recurring charges and how to cancel, send acknowledgments and renewal reminders, keep consent records, and make cancelling as easy as signing up.
“Both the FTC and virtually all states require that cancellation be as simple and easy as enrollment.”
Lewis Silkin says the UK's subscription rules are delayed to spring 2027. They will require reminders before trials or 12 month+ contracts renew, and 14 days after renewal to cancel with a refund.
“the regime will not come into force until the spring of 2027.”
BCLP says the FTC's click-to-cancel rule was vacated, but ROSCA still requires clear terms, consent before charging and simple cancellation, and the FTC is moving to revive the rule over years.
“Businesses should review their disclosure, consent, and cancellation flows now to ensure they align with ROSCA’s requirements”
The FTC asked for public comment in March 2026 on whether to amend its Negative Option Rule, citing over 100,000 subscription complaints in five years. It is a request for comment, not a new rule.
“continue to be plagued by difficult cancellation processes, unlawful retention tactics, and a suite of other impediments”
Goodwin, a law firm, says US law (ROSCA) still requires clear terms, express consent and a simple way to cancel subscriptions. The FTC restarted its cancellation rulemaking in 2026, and state renewal laws still apply.
“If a company’s cancellation pathway is significantly more difficult than its enrollment path, the FTC may view that imbalance as inherently unfair.”
California's renewal law requires 7 to 30 days' notice before a fee change, 15 to 45 days' notice before yearly plans renew, an annual reminder, and online cancellation for plans bought online.
“If a consumer enrolled in an auto-renewal or continuous-service plan online, they must be able to cancel it online at will”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer