Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

Full price, on a schedule

Black Friday is 10 days out, so this issue opens with where your discount belongs, and the Meta setting that can put it where it doesn't. After that: a vendor's read on why new customers cost more this week, day six of Meta's delivery trouble, a shorter ThruPlay, Google Maps making phone calls for your customers and the Answer Book's Monday.

By Scott Stroud, Editor

Risograph print: a shopper admires a product with a gift box at full price; beside it a percent sign packed in a box under a calendar

Our answer on leading with a discount or value says lead always-on ads with the reason to buy at full price, and keep discount-led ads in separate sale campaigns that start and stop on dates you set. When you do add an offer, it prefers a bundle or a gift to a sitewide percentage off. That's the next 10 days in two sentences. Your evergreen campaigns keep selling the product, and the Black Friday campaign sells the deal.

Not everyone runs it that way. Nick Theriot says the format depends on the brand: a new-customer brand with few products did $3.3 million in November running 40% off from November 1, while a brand with 40% of revenue from returning customers and 30 or more products did $633,000 in one day from a hyped event (Nick Theriot). I read that as an argument about when the sale runs, and the answer's split between sale campaigns and full-price ads survives it.

Now the catch, and a callback. Two weeks ago, one agency reported that Meta added discounts it detected on the advertiser's website to copies of ads whose originals had promotions turned off. The switch sits in Commerce Manager under Settings, Offer merchandising, where a "Detected offers" box covers all ads, and in the one account shown it was ticked along with "Sale events" and "Seasonal event names" (PPC Land). So the minute your sale goes live on the site, your full-price ads may start advertising it. Our answer on Meta's creative enhancements says set each feature on purpose, and Jon Loomer says he has now documented 47 of them, many buried outside ad creation (Jon Loomer). Check Commerce Manager before Black Friday week, not during it.

Lead generation readers: the same answer's lead-gen version changed on Monday. It now offers cold audiences a free tool tied to what you sell, in place of a free first lesson, and keeps audits and demos for people already considering you.

The squeeze

The attribution software seller Wicked Reports put Meta's cost per verified new customer at $111 in the week of November 8 to 14, 46% above its September baseline, and Google's at $169, above its own baseline for the first time this fall (Wicked Reports). New-visit conversion fell 10% on both while Meta's click prices rose only 5% and Google's fell 6%, so Wicked Reports reads it as shoppers waiting for the sale rather than ads getting worse, and says hold planned spend through the two weeks before the deal window. That's a vendor reading its own panel, but it fits our answer on Google budgets around sales peaks, which funds the whole run-up rather than judging pre-sale weeks on daily efficiency.

Charley Tichenor offered a quick test for whether it's the season or you. Cost per thousand impressions and cost per purchase both up with flat order value is seasonal. Flat CPM with rising cost per purchase is your account. Falling CPM with rising cost per purchase points to conversion rate and offer (Charley Tichenor). Our answer on benchmarking your CPMs runs the same logic against Meta's own price per ad, which rose 23% in the US and Canada in the third quarter.

The same Wicked Reports data had TikTok at $31 per customer blended but $60 per verified new customer, because only 52% of its buyers were new, against 86% on Meta. Our answer on new and repeat revenue in reporting keeps those as two lines for exactly this reason. YouTube hit $1,007 per verified new customer, its first four-figure week in the series, on click-credited data that undercounts video, so I wouldn't cut YouTube on that number alone. Our answer on YouTube ad costs and budget judges it over about a month.

Operators' Black Friday checklist adds the boring one that bites: check your Meta account spending limit, confirm the payment method and add a backup card. Ridge once hit its cap and stopped delivering until its Meta rep raised it (Operators). Our answer on Meta spending limits and billing says raise the limit above expected spend before a sale.

Meta, take four

Day six. Across seven r/FacebookAds threads on Monday, advertisers described results collapsing from about November 12 to 15: near-zero new customers on $3,500 a day, campaigns spending a fraction of budget, and one account that spent $6,500 against a $4,000 daily budget with impressions about 20 times normal and no results (r/FacebookAds). These are forum posts, and Meta still hasn't acknowledged anything. Our answer on a Meta campaign not spending separates blocked delivery from short delivery before you touch bids. And that $6,500 day sits inside the 175% rule from Monday's issue, which is cold comfort with no sales attached.

Phil Kiel says Meta's November 12 Pixel change, said to report more sales, showed no lift in his agency's US accounts against Shopify orders. His advice is to log Meta purchases and Shopify orders by day before Black Friday and not scale on a jump Shopify doesn't show (Phil Kiel). That's one agency, and Meta's own announcement isn't in our sources yet. Our answer on auditing your tracking setup runs the Conversions API beside the pixel with a shared event ID, which is the setup you want before that comparison.

Meta notes

  • Ads Manager now offers a ThruPlay length of 6 or 15 seconds under "Maximize ThruPlay views" in Awareness and Engagement campaigns, from a practitioner's screenshots and not announced by Meta (PPC Land). A 6-second ThruPlay makes video numbers look better without anyone watching more.
  • Our answer on when to run Awareness or Traffic campaigns keeps those campaigns as time-boxed flights that a holdout test has to justify, and a shorter ThruPlay doesn't change that.
  • Jon Loomer spotted Meta's video custom audiences cutting seven watch thresholds to three tiers, All, Engaged and Highly Engaged Video Viewers, and Meta hasn't defined the last two (Jon Loomer). Loomer calls video viewers some of the weakest custom audiences anyway.
  • Our answer on a dedicated retargeting campaign skips one by default, since broad campaigns already spend about 20 to 25% of budget on past visitors and customers.
  • Cody Wittick says a static image was the top-spending ad over 7 days under cost caps in two of his agency's brands (Cody Wittick).
  • Our answer on the mix of static, video and carousel says don't go video-only, and the statics keep earning their spot.
  • Another attribution software seller, Northbeam, says its best brands by return on ad spend launch more than 180 new ads a week, with no spend given (Bryan Bumgardner). That's well above the top pace in our answer on new creative volume, which scales new ads with spend. Without the spend, 180 is a number looking for a denominator.

Google

  • Ask Maps can now phone local businesses for users to check open appointments in beauty, pet care, auto and home repair, rolling out in the US from Monday (Google). If you're a plumber, your next caller may be a robot. Google hasn't said how the assistant identifies itself. Our answer on Google Business Profile says keep the address and hours exact, which now matters to the robot too.
  • Google said on its third-quarter earnings call that it isn't yet showing as many ads in AI search as in traditional search (AdExchanger). Our answer on ads in AI Mode and AI Overviews treats them as part of Search, with no separate budget to buy.
  • Operators says don't bid on generic searches like "black friday sale", citing HexClad spending about $120,000 on them for essentially nothing back (Operators). Our answer on broad category terms or product terms bids on specific product searches first. The same checklist recommends seasonal bid adjustments for Black Friday, and there we part ways: our answer on seasonality adjustments for short promotions keeps them for short sales of your own that Google can't see coming and skips them for recurring peaks like Black Friday.
  • YouTube has replaced "Skip" with "Next" on some ad buttons, seen in one screenshot and not announced (PPC Land). Nobody knows yet whether a tap ends the ad or loads another. Our answer on YouTube and Demand Gen for sales judges on purchases, so a renamed button changes nothing until it changes what you pay for.
  • Google's Regulatory Operating Cost surcharge on ads served in France rises from 2% to 3%, and in Italy from 2.5% to 3%, on January 1 (Google Ads Help). Our answer on Google campaigns for international markets gives each country its own budget, so build the extra point into those.
  • Fine print: finance offers in vehicle feeds now count as credit offers under Google's restricted targeting rules (PPC News Feed), and Google rewrote its sexual content policy for the second time in 33 days, adding allowed lingerie examples while saying enforcement doesn't change (PPC Land). Our answer on advertising restricted products on Google says check each product and market before launch.
  • Google is converting standalone Google tags into Tag Manager containers and says tag behavior on the page won't change, from one analyst's report (PPC Land). Our answer on Google conversion tracking setup holds, but check your conversion tags still fire after the switch.

Elsewhere

  • Operators also says take recent buyers out of Black Friday follow-up emails unless the offer or products change (Operators).
  • Our answer on email campaigns for Black Friday and peaks plans the peak as a season, not a weekend.
  • Chase Dimond relays the luggage brand LEVEL8's storyorder value rose about 10 to 15% during the gift-with-purchase phases of its Black Friday campaign, though other parts of the campaign changed too (Chase Dimond).
  • Chase Dimond relays the luggage brand LEVEL8's storyOur answer on percent off, dollars off or free gifts says test a gift against your usual offer and keep whichever earns more profit per visitor.
  • On r/shopify, merchants and a Klaviyo employee say that during a sitewide sale, welcome emails should point new subscribers to the sale and move the welcome code's start date past it, rather than hand out a code that adds nothing (r/shopify). That's forum advice.
  • Our answer on welcome discounts already makes the code single-use and expiring, which makes it easy to date.
  • Businesses in ChatGPT, in beta since November 10, lets verified businesses see their ChatGPT mentions and correct address, hours and services, and OpenAI says claiming doesn't guarantee better placement (Cardinal Digital Marketing).
  • Our answer on how AI assistants pick brands to recommend covers what does move placement.
  • In AirOps' study of 548,534 pages ChatGPT retrieved, 85% were never cited, from Kevin Indig's roundup of the research (Kevin Indig). Being found isn't being named, which is why our answer on measuring AI assistant mentions counts answers that name you.

New in the book

Five new answers on Monday. Meta daily budget overspend was in Monday's issue. The featured one: our answer on clearing excess inventory with Meta ads says clear truly excess stock in its own time-boxed campaign for a few overstocked products, sent to a sale page your site doesn't link to, while evergreen campaigns keep selling at full price. It also flags the detected offers setting from the lead.

Four more calls changed on Monday, besides the lead-gen one above.

  • Subscribe and Save on Amazon now checks after 2 to 3 months whether subscribers keep reordering and each delivery still makes money, rather than waiting for the fourth delivery.
  • Pretesting creative with AI attention tools now uses the scores only to cut the clearly weakest drafts, video and static alike, and lets real spend judge the rest.
  • Testing AppLovin incrementality adds about a week of reading after the 2 to 3 week holdout to catch late sales, as Ridge does.
  • Judging channels with less data now compares a smaller channel with Meta on 7-day click alone, after a Haus holdout benchmark from October found adding 1-day view didn't bring Meta's numbers closer to measured lift.

Another 51 answers went live overnight. Wednesday's issue walks through them.

Thanksgiving is in 9 days. Black Friday is in 10 days.

Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.

Every issue