Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

New, or just new to Meta

Black Friday is 11 days out, which means a wave of first-time buyers is about to hit your store and your ad accounts, and Meta needs to know which of them are actually new. So this issue opens with who counts as a new customer, and what a holiday one is worth, on a weekend when the Answer Book changed its mind on one and added two more. After that: Meta delivery trouble on days four and five, a new answer for anyone whose Meta bill ran double the daily budget, Meta's new AI video app, a busy weekend of Google fine print and a Cloudflare setting that can quietly block Google from your store.

By Scott Stroud, Editor

Pen sketch of a customer card stack with a looping refresh arrow, and a crowd where the matching existing customers are marked red

On Sunday, our answer on feeding Meta your customer data changed its call on excluding past customers. It still says don't blanket-exclude past customers. What moved is where the exclusions go: active subscribers and buyers from about the past 90 days now come out of a separate retention campaign, rather than out of every ad you run. Andrew Faris, whose advice the answer follows, gave those exclusions for retention campaigns, and the old wording had drifted wider than he did. The rest holds. Bid existing customers down with value rules if you'd rather (on highest-volume or cost cap bidding only), and lift-test whatever you spend on them.

Saturday's issue closed with two operators warning that Black Friday customers can be cheap to win and cheap to keep. The book now has an answer for it. Our answer on holiday sale customer value expects customers won in a Black Friday sale to be worth less than full-price ones, but sets your sale ceiling on new-customer cost from your own past sale cohorts rather than a fixed cut. Compare your 2025 Black Friday first-time buyers with a normal month's on second orders without a discount and gross profit per customer, and lower the ceiling only as far as they fall short. It's homework, and it's due in 11 days.

Its sibling, also new on Sunday: our answer on new-customer cost targets by channel gives each sales channel its own ceiling, built from what that channel's customers earn back in contribution margin over your payback window. TikTok Shop customers have to pay back on the first order unless your own Shop data shows them buying again. I like this one. A blended target lets your cheapest channel subsidize the one nobody wants to look at.

Meta, take three

The delivery trouble that started on November 11 kept going through the weekend. On Saturday, one advertiser spending about $850 a day watched return on ad spend fall from its usual 3 to 0.5, with 4 or 5 add-to-carts against a usual 30 to 50, checked on its own site (r/FacebookAds). On Sunday, across four more threads, one store reported its first zero-sale Saturday in 3 years and a 14-year-old company went from 190 orders the previous Saturday to 79 while its campaigns spent about $1,500 of a $3,600 daily budget (r/FacebookAds). Meta still hasn't said anything. Five days is an episode with a long tail. Our answer on diagnosing a Meta cost per purchase drop has been the right first stop all week: confirm it in store orders, then split the drop into price, mix and conversion before you touch the campaign. A Saturday commenter's advice, don't edit anything on a bad day and judge on three days, is the short version.

One bright spot in the same thread: two advertisers say opening their Black Friday sale at the start of November made cost per purchase much healthier, one citing a 60% cut, while full-price advertisers watched shoppers wait. That's two self-reports with no categories named, but it lines up with our answer on budgets and launch timing for seasonal peaks, which opens the offer early in the run-up.

Double the budget, by the rules

Another Saturday thread had advertisers watching Meta spend about twice their daily budget for several days (r/FacebookAds). It's allowed. Our answer on Meta daily budget overspend, new today, says Meta can spend up to 175% of a daily budget in a day (210% with ad set budget sharing) and up to 7 times it in a Sunday to Saturday week, so plan cash by the week and the heaviest day, and put any total you can't exceed on a lifetime budget or a spending limit. The rule comes from Meta's own help pages. During Black Friday week, a 175% day is one to budget for, not one to be surprised by.

Meta notes

  • Meta launched Dream Render, a browser app that makes product videos from a photo or description for small businesses and creators to post as content or ads, with a label saying they're AI-made (Meta). Meta doesn't say where it's available or what it costs.
  • Our answer on ads made entirely with AI tools covers how to test what it makes.
  • The enhancements kept freelancing. One advertiser says the related media enhancement switched itself on and added 10 or more creatives to an ad that was already working (r/FacebookAds), and others say duplicating an ad drops all headlines, primary text and descriptions about half the time after the AI text step (r/FacebookAds). Saturday I called the duplicate button the riskiest button in Ads Manager. It's defending the title.
  • Our answer on Meta's creative enhancements says set each one on purpose, so check them and your ad text after every duplicate.
  • One advertiser says Meta asked for personal identity verification on Sunday even though the business was already verified. It cleared in 2 minutes, and others in its country waited more than 48 hours (r/FacebookAds).
  • Our answer on Meta Verified for ad account support is the place to start if you're stuck in the queue.
  • Also on account safetyagencies on r/PPC are getting a phishing email from "furniturebox.uk", which redirects to a real furniture store and uses a made-up staff name, aimed at getting into their manager accounts (r/PPC).
  • Also on account safetyOur answer on avoiding disapprovals, restrictions and hacks says lock down admin access, and this is why.
  • A clothing store says Meta rejected 5 or 6 Advantage+ catalog campaigns under a scam policy on false imagery, after a year of AI-generated product images with no trouble (r/PPC). It's one unconfirmed report.
  • Our answer on AI product photos already says never use AI to change how the product itself looks.
  • Several advertisers report 80 to 90% of paid visitors leaving within about a second without scrolling, one with about 1,000 visits and 0 add-to-carts on EUR 600 of spend, and suspect bots (r/FacebookAds). That's the fourth straight week of these reports and still no proof of cause.
  • Our answer on bot traffic and fake sign-ups covers filtering at the server.
  • An advertiser on Highest Volume bidding at $500 a day got 70 and 80 sales on days one and two, then about 30 a day and a $300 daily loss, and Meta's own Marketing Pro team told it to raise the budget (r/FacebookAds). Commenters say days one and two were the cheapest buyers.
  • Our answer on choosing a starting bid strategy moves you to a cost per result goal once you have a baseline, which is the fix they landed on.

Google

  • Our answer on turning on AI Max for Search changed its call today. Google says URL exclusions in AI Max work only while text customization and Final URL expansion are on, so set them when you test Final URL expansion rather than before launch (Google). Google also added a {search_term_matchtype} parameter that returns "a" for AI Max matches, which means a click credited to an exact keyword can really be an AI Max expansion (PPC Land). Our answer on match types and negative keywords keeps AI Max terms on a short leash, and now you can see the leash.
  • Performance Max household income exclusions are now on Google's setup help page as a beta for select advertisers, with brackets from the top 10% down to the lower 50% plus Unknown (PPC Land). Google calls the income an estimate, and excluding Unknown narrows reach. Our answer on excluding household income ranges covers when it's worth it.
  • Merchant Center raised the limit on carrier shipping entries per product from 10 to 100 (PPC Land). Handy for complex carrier rates. Our answer on shipping and returns in Merchant Center has the setup.
  • Google is testing a "Limit audience reach" setting with three options, from no limit (Google's recommendation) to people matching all selected segments, with a warning that the strictest option "could significantly lower campaign performance and impressions" (PPC Land). Our answer on Demand Gen retargeting is where it would matter.
  • The click fraud and bidding software seller Lunio launched a tool that lowers Google brand bids when no rival is in the auction. Its headline case claims more than $6.4 million saved in 2025 for an unnamed food delivery company, and PPC Land notes there was no baseline or control (PPC Land). That's a vendor grading itself. Our answer on spending on your own brand name tests brand spend with a holdout before trusting anyone's savings.

Elsewhere

  • Since September 15, Cloudflare's AI Training block also blocks Googlebot, Applebot and Bingbot, while its robots.txt option for training leaves them alone (Cloudflare). If you ticked that box to keep AI companies off your site, you may have kept Google off it too.
  • Our answer on bot blocking and Google Shopping, new on Sunday, says exempt Google's verified crawlers, opt out of AI training by name instead and check Merchant Center and Search Console for blocked requests after any bot setting change.
  • Shopify rebuilt its Store activity log to keep 18 months of changes, up from the last 250 events, and show who made each one (Common Thread Collective). Common Thread Collective, an agency, suggests a 5-minute weekly review starting with payments, discounts and shipping profiles.
  • Our answer on checking for broken pages and errors now has a better place to look first.
  • Across about 119,000 sites in October, AI assistants sent 0.46% of visits against 27.55% from search engines, by Ahrefs's count (Ahrefs). Ahrefs sells SEO software.
  • Our answer on monthly SEO metrics keeps AI traffic in the report as a trend line, and at 0.46% it's a short one.

New in the book

Four new answers since Saturday, all in the stories above: holiday sale customer value, new-customer cost targets by channel, bot blocking and Google Shopping, and Meta daily budget overspend. Two calls changed above, on customer data and AI Max, plus one more.

  • Prioritizing site improvements now starts testing on the pages most shoppers see, such as product pages or sitewide elements, rather than the checkout step where most abandon, since busier pages reach a result sooner. It judges tests on revenue per visitor, and price tests on profit per visitor.

Thanksgiving is in 10 days. Black Friday is in 11 days.

Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.

Every issue