All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

How should we choose between percent off, dollars off and free gifts?

The PrevailingUpdated Oct 29, 2026

Our answer

Run the same offer value as percent off, dollars off and a free gift, and keep whichever earns the most profit per visitor. Give dollar offers a minimum spend and set gift thresholds above your usual basket.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
4 controlled tests
2 official rules, 2 datasets, 3 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
Sources
13 sources
16 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Dollars off beat percent off in welcome pop-up tests. In Maestra's test for Nat'v Basics, $15 off beat 12% off by 24% on conversion and 22% on revenue. Convertibles (Shopify conversion agency) found $30 off over $150 beat 15% off.

A minimum spend lifts dollar-off orders. Seguno's data on 182 million codes show dollar-off codes with a minimum averaging $100.79 an order against $39.30 without, while percent-off codes carried higher orders overall.

A gift with purchase costs less than any discount, Matty Martin of Cadence finds. Brandmovers argues a gift pays only if the extra spend it brings covers its cost.

Our judgment

  • We chose testing the offer format over a fixed rule because the evidence splits. The three published welcome pop-up tests favor dollars off, Seguno's code data show higher order values on percent-off codes, and Growth Suite could not verify the Rule of 100 in its own data.
  • Give any dollar-off offer a minimum spend. Seguno's code data and Convertibles' winning $30 off, which required $150, both point this way.
  • Try a free gift only where it costs you far less than its value to the buyer. Set the threshold above most customers' usual basket.
  • On higher-priced items, test showing the calculated sale price beside the crossed-out price rather than only the percentage. Convertibles' one-brand test on a $198 item added $102,350 a month in revenue that way.

Our judgment, built from Maestra, Convertibles, Seguno, Growth Suite, Brandmovers, Matty Martin and Klaviyo: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

16 statements from 13 sources
  • KlaviyoUndatedCaveat

    Klaviyo's coupon forms can give one static code or unique one-time codes, which are harder to share. Klaviyo suggests a free gift with purchase over a discount for cheap-to-make, high-price products like skin care.

    “unique codes are harder to share or misuse”

    Read it on klaviyo.com

  • US Federal Trade CommissionOct 28, 2026Caveat

    The FTC's guide says a free offer must not be recovered by marking up the item bought, terms go up front, and one size shouldn't carry free offers more than 6 months in any 12. US only.

    “should be set forth clearly and conspicuously at the outset of the offer”

    Read it on ecfr.gov

  • IntelligemsOct 15, 2026Supports

    Intelligems, which sells offer testing, says a free gift can mean little to first-time buyers and a lot to repeat ones, and a group's own offer pays only if it earns more profit per visitor than your standard sale.

    “A group’s own offer pays only when it earns more profit per visitor from that group than your standard sale.”

    Read it on intelligems.io

  • Cherene AubertOct 12, 2026Supports

    Cherene Aubert, a former ILIA Beauty SVP, has seen no meaningful sales lift from deepening a sitewide discount past 20%, and suggests bundles and gifts with purchase rather than deeper discounts.

    Read it on operatorscontent.com

  • Growth SuiteOct 11, 2026Supports

    Growth Suite, a discount software vendor, says neither percentage nor fixed-amount discounts is universally better. Its own data could not confirm the rule that percent feels bigger below $100.

    “Neither is universally better; the right choice depends on your price points.”

    Read it on growthsuite.net

  • Brandmovers2026-10Supports

    Brandmovers, which sells promotions, says a gift with purchase beats a discount when protecting price matters and the gift costs far less than it seems worth. Set the spend threshold above the median basket.

    “gifts on orders that would have qualified anyway are pure cost.”

    Read it on blog.brandmovers.com

  • Jetfuel AgencySep 17, 2026Caveat

    Jetfuel, an agency, says gift buyers respond better to curated gift sets, free wrapping or threshold offers than to a flat 20% off, and that the real deadline is the last day a gift can arrive by December 25.

    “Your real deadline is not December 25. It is the last day a gift can arrive by December 25”

    Read it on jetfuel.agency

  • IntelligemsSep 8, 2026Caveat

    Over Labor Day 2026, 34% of 3,000+ Shopify brands ran an offer. Discounters' revenue lift fell to 22% from 31%, brands without offers gained 3%, and 20%+ discounts lifted revenue 89%. Revenue, not profit.

    “a token discount costs you margin and buys you nothing. Go meaningful or skip it.”

    Read it on intelligems.io

  • MaestraAug 11, 2026Supports

    In Maestra's two-week test for one apparel brand across about 20,000 visitors, a $15 off pop-up converted 24% better than the old 12% off offer and drove 22% more revenue.

    “Both dollar variants outperformed the percentage control.”

    Read it on maestra.io

  • Andrew FarisJul 6, 2026Supports

    Michael DeLea says a gift with purchase raises the value of a first order without deep discounts on the main product, which avoids sticker shock when the customer renews at full price.

    “we can discount our main product less, but say we're discounting more”

    Read it on podcasters.spotify.com

  • EightxMay 29, 2026Supports

    Eightx, a fractional CFO firm, keeps normal promotions at 15 to 25% with 25 to 30% sitewide as the ceiling, and prefers bundles, gifts and free shipping thresholds. A finance view, not an ad test.

    “25-30% sitewide as the ceiling”

    Read it on eightx.co

  • Matty MartinMay 5, 2026Supports

    Matty Martin says that in nearly every case a gift with purchase costs his brand less than any discount, and builds more customer affinity.

    “in pretty much every case, a gift with purchase is... cheaper to us than giving any kind of discount amount”

    Read it on podcasters.spotify.com

  • ConvertiblesJan 8, 2026Supports

    Convertibles, an agency, reports one luxury pajama brand's A/B test during Black Friday: showing the discounted price ($148.50) instead of "25% off" added $102,350 a month in revenue. No sample size or profit given.

    “For larger absolute savings (like $49.50 in this case), the calculated price is much more impactful.”

    Read it on convertibles.dev

  • Seguno2026Disagrees

    Seguno's data on 182 million Shopify codes from 1,348 brands: percentage-off orders averaged $95.75 against $67.35 for amount-off, which were redeemed 1.26x more often. Correlation, not a test.

    “Going up to 25% didn’t pay off”

    Read it on seguno.com

  • ConvertiblesDec 28, 2025Supports

    In one wellness brand's pop-up test, $30 off a $150 order with a redesign beat 15% off: +43% email capture, +21% order value. The design and threshold changed too, so dollar framing alone isn't isolated.

    “Cash value is more universally understood than product value, especially for first-time visitors who don't know what a "Play Balm" is worth.”

    Read it on convertibles.dev

  • ConvertiblesDec 28, 2025Supports

    Convertibles, an agency, tested pop-up offers for one dog treats brand: free gifts beat dollar-off, which beat percentage-off. The winner showed +26% email capture and +25% AOV; no significance given.

    “Three gifts beat one gift, one gift beat dollar-off, and dollar-off beat percentage-off.”

    Read it on convertibles.dev

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • What the research saysWhat academic research adds, kept apart from the answer
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Discounts and promotions