Do we need a dedicated retargeting campaign at our spend level?
Our answer
The answer depends on spend.
Don't run a separate retargeting campaign by default. Add a small one, under 10% of budget, only once spend passes about $1,000 a day.
Optionally run one small retargeting campaign, under 10% of budget, for cart abandoners and high-value products. Keep it only if a holdout test shows it adds sales.
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentBroad campaigns already reach people who know you. They spend about 20 to 25% of budget on past visitors and customers, so a retargeting campaign just reaches them twice (Jon Loomer).
Wait for scale before adding a separate retargeting campaign. Flighted, a paid media agency, advises adding a retargeting campaign only near $1,000 a day and keeping it under 10% of budget.
Many accounts already over-spend on warm audiences. Flighted says its account audits often find about 50% of spend going to existing customers and engaged audiences, and it calls more than 25 to 30% over-indexed.
Our judgment
Kept to a small share, retargeting still pays per dollar. Common Thread Collective (CTC) data for Q1 2026 show non-acquisition spend at 2.65% of all ad spend returning 3.53 times incremental ROAS against 2.07 times for acquisition, on factors measured mostly before Meta's March 2026 click change, so we read it for direction only. With Acquire new customers on, that campaign's warm share is past visitors and engagers only, so existing customers need their own retention campaign (Ads for new versus existing customers). That follows Loomer's note that Meta excludes past purchasers automatically and CTC's separate retention campaigns.
Our judgment, built from Common Thread Collective and Jon Loomer: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
18 statements from 10 sourcesAndrew Faris, an agency operator, merged two Meta prospecting groups (non-engagers and engaged non-buyers) in one account. Spend stayed about 60/40 toward the colder group, with no clear gain or loss.
“It definitely didn't hurt, but it also may not have helped that much.”
Phil Graham suggests segmented retargeting by product, service or pain point, saying it works better than broad retargeting alone.
“The other retargeting I think a lot of advertisers should consider is called segmented retargeting.”
Phil Kiel's agency says Meta spend on engaged audiences has climbed since August, with purchases 7% to 34% cheaper on Meta attribution. He advises ring-fencing one prospecting campaign that excludes them.
“Ring-fence one prospecting campaign that excludes engaged and existing users, with a fixed slice of budget, so cold reach doesn't get starved going into Black Friday.”
Meta has removed the existing customer budget cap from Advantage+ sales campaigns, but says you can do the same by hand with an audience exclusion or two ad sets with a spend limit.
“Existing customer budget cap, which allowed Advantage+ sales campaign advertisers to choose whether or not to spend on existing customers, is no longer available.”
Jon Loomer says remarketing does not scale because those audiences are small and run out quickly.
“remarketing isn't scalable because you can exhaust these audiences quickly.”
Jon Loomer relays that Meta's "Acquire new customers" setting fixes an automatic exclusion of purchasers from your conversion data, 730 days by default. He advises keeping remarketing and judging it in breakdowns.
“the automatic exclusions are fixed. They aren't an option.”
Measured, drawing on 25,000+ experiments across 160+ enterprise brands, says platforms heavily over-report retargeting, while social prospecting is reported accurately or under-reported. It gives no adjustment figures.
“within a single platform, prospecting and remarketing routinely sit far apart in measured incrementality while showing near-identical platform-reported ROAS.”
Flighted says to add a separate retargeting campaign only near $1,000 a day, keeping it under 10% of budget and aimed at cart abandoners and high-value products.
“Once you cross that spend level, add retargeting at under 10% of total budget, cart-abandonment and high-value SKUs only, not a general warm-audience catch-all.”
Pushes back on dropping retargeting under broad delivery: Jetfuel, an agency, keeps a separate manual retargeting campaign outside Advantage+ Shopping for site visitors, cart abandoners and video engagers.
“Running retargeting separately from ASC gives us cleaner performance data on each and prevents ASC's own retargeting activity from blurring the picture.”
CTC says catalog ads are usually an account's highest-ROAS item, but instead of using them only for retargeting, launch them broad with Advantage+ across the whole catalog and budget them as a separate line.
“to a broad audience and Advantage+ with a catalog for your entire portfolio”
Jon Loomer says Meta now prioritizes remarketing audiences by default, so most advertisers don't need separate remarketing ad sets.
“meta prioritizes your remarketing audiences by default now.”
Jetfuel's Edwin Choi sets aside 10-15% of budget for retargeting, if needed, aimed at warm audiences only: website visitors and cart abandoners over a 30-day window. No data given.
“Warm audiences only. Website visitors + cart abandoners, 30-day window.”
Jon Loomer says broad or Advantage+ delivery already spends roughly 20% to 25% of budget on past visitors, engagers and customers, so a separate retargeting campaign reaches them twice.
“just reaches them twice”
CTC's geo-holdout tests give Facebook acquisition campaigns a median incrementality factor of 1.14 against 7-day-click platform ROAS, and retargeting or retention campaigns 0.60.
Flighted, an agency, says brands under $50K a month on Meta and durable goods sellers should exclude existing customers from prospecting, and that over 25-30% of budget on existing buyers is too much.
“If more than 25-30% of your Meta budget goes to existing buyers and engaged audiences, you are likely over-indexed.”
Blue Sense Digital says hyper-segmenting retargeting raises CPMs and has almost no direct upside.
“That hyper segmentation in retargeting, all it does is increase CPMs.”
CTC's Connor McLaughlin says the agency runs separate prospecting, retention and remarketing campaigns on Meta, and on AppLovin adds about 10% of spend in a prospecting campaign. No Meta data.
“on Google we have brand non-brand, meta we have prospecting, retention, remarketing”
In CTC's Q1 2026 data on 299 DTC brands and $231M, Meta retargeting and retention took 2.65% of spend at an estimated 3.53x incremental ROAS, versus 2.07x for acquisition, using pooled factors.
“The gap between these numbers is where misallocation lives.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer