Should we use seasonality adjustments in Smart Bidding for short promotions?
Our answer
Use a seasonality adjustment only for a short sale of your own, 1 to 7 days, whose conversion rate lift past sales have shown. Set it at or below that lift and add budget for those days.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 8 Google rules
- 1 dataset, 5 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 11 sources
- 18 statements
- GDN
RDA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentSmart Bidding already manages seasonal events, so seasonality adjustments are for big, short changes. Google calls seasonality adjustments ideal for events of 1 to 7 days and says to use them only for major conversion rate changes.
Adjustments came with higher costs in a large account study. Optmyzr, a bid software maker, tracked 6,000 advertisers over three years and found cost-per-click inflation doubled for those that used them. It advises leaving them off unless Google has no history for the event.
Size seasonality adjustments from past sales, because costs rise with them. GrowthSpree says a 100% adjustment typically raises cost per click by about 100%. Relevant Audience sizes adjustments from your own history for the same event and treats a past lift as an upper bound.
Our judgment
- Keep adjustments for short sales of your own whose lift you have seen before. Google calls the tool ideal for short events with major changes, Optmyzr limits it to events Google has no history for, and RichClicks and Digital Applied send short flash sales to it.
- Set the adjustment at or below the lift your last comparable sale showed on the same campaigns, and leave it off when you have no such sale. Google asks for your estimated change, Relevant Audience treats a past lift as an upper bound, Optmyzr says an estimate that is off overpays on every auction and GrowthSpree advises modest values.
- Add budget for the sale days whenever you add an adjustment. GrowthSpree says rising cost per click can drain a daily budget before midday, Digital Applied pairs the adjustment with manual budget headroom, and Google's seasonal budget adjustment adds budget to Search and Shopping for 3 to 14 days.
- Choose promotion mode or a lower target over an adjustment when the goal is more volume at a lower return. Both smec (Smarter Ecommerce) and Digital Applied say an adjustment leaves the target unchanged while promotion mode loosens it.
Our judgment, built from Google, Optmyzr, RichClicks, Digital Applied, Relevant Audience, GrowthSpree and smec (Smarter Ecommerce): our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
18 statements from 11 sourcesA Pilothouse Google media buyer says to use seasonality adjustments, not data exclusions, for sale periods like Black Friday, so bidding can pace ahead of expected conversion rate changes.
“it's really important that we do seasonality adjustments here and not exclusions”
A Pilothouse Google media buyer says to use Google Ads' seasonality adjustments tool for unusual periods so bidding anticipates the change.
“you can basically preempt the algorithm to know what might happen and to treat that as an unusual period”
Nils Rooijmans will not switch on Google's beta promotion mode everywhere for Black Friday: he gives it a 50% chance of success and it skips portfolio bid strategies. He will test it on one small campaign.
“For many of my clients, Black Friday is the most expensive week of the year to find a bug.”
Google Ads API v26.2 adds beta seasonality adjustments for Demand Gen campaigns, covering YouTube, Display, Gmail and Maps inventory but not Discover.
“Seasonality adjustments have no effect on the Discover channel.”
Google's help page calls Promotion Mode an open beta for standard Search and Performance Max campaigns on campaign-level Target ROAS, with a 5% to 90% tolerance for 3 to 14 days and no portfolio strategies or shared budgets.
“Promotion Mode is currently in an open beta.”
Google says use seasonality adjustments only for major expected conversion rate changes in short events of 1 to 7 days; they may not work as well past 14 days, and Smart Bidding already handles seasons.
“Use seasonality adjustments only if you expect major changes to conversion rates, because Smart Bidding already manages seasonal events.”
Google says to use seasonality adjustments only when you expect major conversion rate changes, ideally for events of 1 to 7 days, and less well beyond 14 days, since Smart Bidding already handles seasons.
“Because Smart Bidding already manages seasonal events, only use seasonality adjustments if you expect major changes to conversion rates.”
Google says to use seasonality adjustments when you expect a sale to change conversion rate, including short events such as a 3-day flash sale.
“You can also use tools like seasonality adjustments for a short period, like a 3-day flash sale, expecting CVR to increase significantly.”
Google's seasonal budget adjustment raises Search and Shopping budgets for 3 to 14 days around a sale Google would not foresee; the next one waits 7 days after the last ends.
“The boost can start today or anytime in the future and it can last between 3 to 14 days.”
Joey Biddner advises against trying Google's Promotion Mode on a key sale like Black Friday; test it on smaller sales first.
“I think that that is a way too risky of a time to try a new tool like this.”
Relevant Audience, an agency, says Google's seasonality adjustments now list Demand Gen, and advises sizing one from your own past lift for the same event, set to the real sale dates and account time zone.
“if the sale's offer is weaker than last year's, the past lift is an upper bound, not a forecast.”
RichClicks, which sells Google Ads management, says budget and target ROAS do different jobs: a tight target can block profitable volume, so ease it gradually. Black Friday alone needs no seasonality adjustment.
“Budget and Target ROAS do two different jobs”
GrowthSpree, a B2B paid media agency, says Google seasonality adjustments suit 1 to 7 day events, and that a 100 percent adjustment typically raises CPCs roughly 100 percent, so use modest values.
“They are ideal for short events of 1 to 7 days and work poorly beyond about 14 days.”
Optmyzr, which sells PPC automation, says leave Google seasonality adjustments off: in its study of 6,000 advertisers, users saw CPC inflation double and ROAS fall each year. Exception: events Google has no history for.
“leave the seasonality adjustment switched off unless you're dealing with something Google genuinely has no history for you on.”
smec, which sells Google Shopping tools, says Promotion Mode loosens your ROAS target and adds budget for a set window, then reverts. Seasonality adjustments differ: the target never moves.
“Once a promo window is active, you can’t change your baseline ROAS target”
Digital Applied, an agency, says Google's promotion mode lifts ROAS tolerance and budget for 3 to 14 days, while seasonality adjustments suit sales under a day or conversion spikes without budget changes.
“Promotion Mode acts directly on the ROAS-tolerance and budget levers. They answer different questions and can run in parallel for the same event.”
Google's Ginny Marvin, via PPC Land, says promotion mode runs a set 3 to 14 day promotion and turns itself off, and can run alongside seasonality adjustments; Google doesn't say how the two interact.
“With Promotion mode, there's no need to remember to come back to turn it off,”
Google's promotion mode beta for Search and Performance Max lets you schedule temporary ROAS tolerance changes and extra daily budget for demand spikes such as sales and launches. Access is through your account team.
“This feature lets you schedule temporary changes to your ROAS tolerance and add extra daily budget during peaking periods”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer
Read next
More in Budget, channel mix and seasonality- How should we plan Google spend for a new product launch?
- Should we run Google Ads in markets where we do not yet sell, to test demand?
- What is the smallest monthly Google budget that gives automated bidding enough data?
- How should Google spend change when we start selling on Amazon or in retail stores?