How should we plan campaigns around Black Friday and other peaks?
Our answer
Build email volume gradually from September and give a smaller group early access. At the peak, send most to engaged customers. Adjust flows for the sale and revert them afterwards.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 official rules
- 5 datasets, 9 practitioners, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 23 statements
- AKL
G
O
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA sudden jump in volume costs you. Brands that went to peak volume without a gradual build earned 22% lower return, Attentive found. Google warns that sudden volume spikes hurt delivery.
Shoppers accept more mail at the peak. Of shoppers Attentive surveyed, 62% are open to more messages, and 81% of people who opted out at its clients' 2025 Black Friday had never bought.
The cost of peak sending arrives after the sale. Spam complaints peak 7 to 10 days after Black Friday (Validity), and only 4% of Ometria clients' 2024 Black Friday first buyers bought again within a year.
Our judgment
- Start raising email volume in September and grow it a little each day to the peak. That joins Litmus's advice to start the ramp in September rather than October, Attentive's ramp of 5 to 10% a day and its lower-return finding, Google's warning against sudden spikes and Klaviyo's calendar of audits in summer and tests in fall.
- Give the extra peak sends to engaged customers and VIPs, keep the rest on a lighter schedule, and leave recent buyers out of discount blasts. That draws on Attentive's frequency tiers, Litmus and Validity's case for smaller targeted sends, Omnisend's 30 day buyer exclusion, and the case Zettler Digital and the Klaviyo Community make for a smaller early access group.
- Run the same plan at a smaller scale for other peaks, such as fall Prime Day, Thanksgiving and Green Monday. That follows Ezra Firestone's peak day list, reported by Klaviyo, and Portland Leather Goods' season long calendar.
- Plan the end of the sale as carefully as the start. Revert flows, suppress expired offers, thank buyers and move first time sale buyers into a second order path, going by Validity's complaint timing, Klaviyo's post sale checklist, Yotpo's follow up schedule and Ometria's repeat purchase data.
Our judgment, built from Attentive, Google, Klaviyo, Litmus, Omnisend, Zettler Digital, Portland Leather Goods, Yotpo and Ometria: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
23 statements from 13 sourcesGmail's sender guidelines say raise sending volume slowly, starting with engaged users, avoid sudden spikes such as doubling volume, and cut back if messages bounce or are deferred.
“For example, immediately doubling previously sent volumes suddenly could result in rate limiting or reputation drops.”
Gmail requires senders of 5,000+ messages a day to authenticate and offer easy unsubscribe, and says to keep spam rates below 0.1% and never reach 0.3%. It recommends honoring unsubscribes within 48 hours.
“senders should keep their spam rate below 0.1% and should prevent spam rates from ever reaching 0.3% or higher”
Foxwell Digital suggests several emails a day across Black Friday week, saying you almost cannot email too much then. It cites no test results.
“During BFCM, you almost can't email too much.”
Montana Knife Company runs five product drops over Black Friday week, each with its own email and SMS push, and has never publicly discounted a knife. One brand's practice, with no results shown.
“we've never publicly discounted one.”
Shopify's Black Friday checklist says to plan a longer sale, announce offers before the weekend and extend into December if margins allow. It relays Adobe: 25 days of 2025's holiday season topped $4 billion online.
“communicate any special BFCM offers before the weekend itself, and extend them into December if inventory and margins allow”
Common Thread Collective says across its clients 2025 holiday new-customer revenue surged late, near the shipping cutoff, while returning customers bought earlier, so weight the early-November forecast to email and SMS.
“But I wouldn't count on new customer revenue being able to convert on early discounts.”
Validity's 2025 inbox data shows spam complaints rose 10% in Black Friday week but peaked 7 to 10 days later, as subscribers found expired offers. It advises suppressing expired offers.
“Spam complaints peak 7-10 days after Black Friday, when subscribers find expired offers.”
Luke Austin says offer strategy is the biggest Black Friday lever and describes clients layering hourly offers or gifts on a core sale. One brand's hourly revenue tripled after its bestseller went back into the offer.
“your marketing calendar and your offer strategy is going to be the highest lever impact that you have.”
Klaviyo says US federal rules allow texts from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m., but states like Florida limit them to 8 p.m., and with state quiet hours on it restricts Texas and Pennsylvania further. Not legal advice.
“In Pennsylvania, quiet hours apply all day on Sundays and public holidays.”
Portland Leather Goods' CMO plans a 55-day holiday season from November 1, reaching existing customers by SMS and email rather than Meta, and turns ads on for the Nov 22 to 28 sitewide sale.
“We now plan a 55-day selling season. November 1st all the way through Christmas.”
Ben Zettler, whose agency sells Klaviyo work, says most Black Friday early access is just a sale sent early to a big list; real early access needs real value, a genuinely small group and a short window.
“Most "early access" during BFCM is just a regular sale sent a few hours early to a bigger list, and customers can tell.”
Klaviyo's recap of Tatcha and Far Niente marketers: give subscribers or VIPs early Black Friday access with a perk like a gift or free shipping instead of a bigger discount. No figures given.
“Tatcha's early-access-only merch item gave shoppers a reason to buy right away, and the brand didn't need to add a discount.”
Yotpo, which sells loyalty and SMS software, says Black Friday urgency should rest on real stock or end times, and later win-back offers should be smaller than the sale discount so shoppers don't learn to wait.
“Ground the urgency in something real, like an actual inventory count or an actual end time.”
Omnisend, which sells email and SMS, advises keeping buyers from the last 30 days and VIPs (top 5-10% by lifetime value) out of Black Friday discount blasts. No data behind the rules.
“Exclude recent buyers from your discount blasts to avoid messaging fatigue and buyer's remorse”
Klaviyo publishes agency results from BFCM 2025 with no holdout: Samplize's early access sale to its whole list made over $87,000, and Harmless Harvest's early VIP sale had 110% higher revenue per recipient.
“The early VIP sale drove 110% higher revenue per recipient (RPR) compared to campaigns sent during the core BFCM window.”
Litmus, part of deliverability seller Validity, says opens are skewed by proxy opens, so build engagement segments from clicks, purchases and site behavior. Validity's data favors smaller, targeted lists.
“Senders who shifted to smaller, more targeted email lists saw better outcomes.”
Litmus, which sells deliverability tools, says to clean lists before the holidays, suppress people who ignore a re-engagement campaign, and start the volume ramp in September.
“Start your ramp-up in September, not October”
Klaviyo suggests auditing in July and August, testing offers in September and October, and shortening abandoned cart delays and swapping in BFCM offers in flows during the sale. No data on flows.
“Revert always-on flows back to normal. Run post-purchase flows and loyalty plays.”
Attentive, an SMS and email seller, says from its platform data that more BFCM sends drove more revenue, and advises raising email volume no more than 5 to 10% a day. No sample or holdout given.
“81% of subscribers who opted out during BFCM 2025 had never made a purchase.”
Attentive, which sells email and SMS, says to ramp holiday send volume 5 to 10% a day, since brands that spiked Q4 sends without a ramp in 2024 saw 22% lower ROI. Keep spam complaints under 0.10%.
“Authentication is quick, but volume ramp takes weeks.”
Attentive, which sells SMS software, says carrier congestion peaks 10am to 3pm ET on Black Friday and Cyber Monday, so send outside those hours, avoid the top and half of the hour, and keep MMS off peak.
“Send before 10am or after 3pm ET for fastest delivery.”
Attentive, which sells SMS and email software, says its brands sent 5.7 billion messages in Cyber Week 2025, up 46%; most sent SMS around noon and email at 8am, with Cyber Monday converting best.
“Most brands sent SMS around noon and emails at 8am”
Ometria's retail clients got 55% of 2025 Black Friday revenue from existing customers, and only 4% of Black Friday 2024 new buyers bought again within 12 months. Sample size not given.
“Opting out of Black Friday is a legitimate strategy too”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer