Which email metrics matter now that open rates are unreliable?
Our answer
Judge each email on clicks with bot clicks filtered out, placed orders and revenue per recipient. Watch unsubscribes, bounces and spam complaints. Keep opens only as a trend against your own past sends.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 7 official rules
- 3 datasets, 5 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 18 statements
- KL
MZDEKCC
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentOpens no longer show who read an email. Apple accounted for 76.56% of over 1.5 billion opens in September 2026 (Litmus, email testing software maker). Apple Mail preloads the tracking pixel, so emails show as opened whether or not anyone read them (Mailchimp).
Clicks and purchases are stronger signs of engagement than opens, Mailchimp says. Klaviyo's community manager pairs attributed revenue with revenue per recipient, placed order rate, click rate and unsubscribe rate.
Opens keep one use, as a directional health signal against your own baseline. Suped (email deliverability software maker) keeps them only for that and picks test winners on filtered clicks or conversions.
Our judgment
Score each send on filtered click rate, placed order rate and revenue per recipient, and the program on store revenue share and a holdout, with opens kept only as a trend. Use Klaviyo's and CustomersAI's click figures as rough reference points rather than targets. Both describe online stores on one email platform, and CustomersAI's link between clicks and revenue is a correlation. A sudden fall in opens across sends is a reason to check delivery before changing content, following Suped's advice and Google's spam rate limits.
Our judgment, built from Litmus, Mailchimp, Klaviyo, Suped, Everboost, CustomersAI and Google: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
18 statements from 10 sourcesMailchimp says Apple Mail Privacy Protection marks emails as opened whether or not they were, so open rates, open-based A/B tests and open-triggered automations mislead; use clicks and purchases instead.
“Clicks and purchases are stronger signs of engagement than opens, and aren't impacted by Apple MPP.”
Gmail requires senders of 5,000+ messages a day to authenticate and offer easy unsubscribe, and says to keep spam rates below 0.1% and never reach 0.3%. It recommends honoring unsubscribes within 48 hours.
“senders should keep their spam rate below 0.1% and should prevent spam rates from ever reaching 0.3% or higher”
Suped, which sells deliverability software, says open rates are now only a directional health signal, not a primary KPI, and subject-line tests should be judged on bot-filtered clicks or conversions.
“Do not use opens as a primary KPI, individual lead score trigger, or revenue attribution metric.”
Litmus counted 1.5 billion opens: Apple 76.56%, Gmail 16.10%. It says Apple's privacy feature affects about 55-60% of opens, so track clicks and conversions rather than open rates.
“shift from tracking “open rates” to more reliable engagement metrics like click-through rates and conversion data.”
A Klaviyo community manager tells an account whose attributed share fell from 40% to 26% after tighter settings to keep settings fixed, pair attributed revenue with other metrics, and use holdouts for lift.
“treat attributed revenue as a measurement and optimization signal, not as a direct measure of incremental revenue.”
Klaviyo's 2026 benchmarks from over 183,000 customers put a good open rate at 31% for campaigns and 32.2% for flows, and a good click rate at 1.69% for campaigns and 5.58% for flows.
“Email flows deliver over 3× higher click rates (5.58% vs. 1.69%) and 13× higher placed order rates than campaigns”
One Klaviyo user saw email and SMS attributed revenue fall from over 40% to about 26% after excluding Apple privacy opens and bot clicks. Klaviyo replied the two figures aren't directly comparable.
“Email + SMS attributed revenue dropped to around 26%”
Everboost, a retention agency, says Klaviyo's attributed revenue counts refunds and renewals and is not cash. It suggests tighter windows, holdouts, and judging email on repeat buying cohort by cohort.
“is a claim about influence, not a ledger of cash”
Litmus, part of deliverability seller Validity, says opens are skewed by proxy opens, so build engagement segments from clicks, purchases and site behavior. Validity's data favors smaller, targeted lists.
“Senders who shifted to smaller, more targeted email lists saw better outcomes.”
Eightx says Klaviyo's default 5-day attribution counts opens, including Apple privacy opens, which inflates email revenue. Switching to click-based attribution can cut it by a third or more in its clients.
“Switch to click-based attribution before you trust the dashboard number.”
CustomersAI, which sells email software, studied 619 brands' Klaviyo accounts and found brands with click rates above 10% make over 20 times the revenue per email of those below 2%. That is a correlation, not a test.
“Brands with click rates above 10% generate more than 20x the revenue per email than brands with click rates below 2%”
Ben Zettler, a Klaviyo consultant, says sending on opens can hurt deliverability because opens are unreliable, and wide sends should exclude subscribers who got many messages without engaging.
“These exclusions protect deliverability, reduce wasted sends, and improve relevance.”
Klaviyo warns that Apple Mail Privacy Protection can record opens nobody read, and suggests a separate re-engagement segment for lapsed subscribers and tighter criteria if clicks fall or complaints rise.
“Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) can record an open without the recipient reading your email.”
Klaviyo divides campaign conversion rate and revenue per recipient by delivered emails, and breaks engagement out by inbox provider, domain and country.
Klaviyo says excluding Apple Mail Privacy Protection opens removes them from attribution but not from open-rate reporting. Bot clicks are excluded from both by default for new accounts.
“Note that this does not include removal from reporting.”
Klaviyo credits sales by last touch by default, within 5 days of an email click, email open or text click and 12 hours of a text delivery. Bot clicks are excluded by default, and changes apply to past data too.
“selecting a longer email open window instead of clicks may introduce a bias towards opens, which may not be conclusive indicators of conversions.”
Klaviyo says bot clicks from inbox providers and security tools inflate engagement. Campaign and flow reports exclude them when the setting is on, but Single Metric Deep Dive reports do not.
“Single Metric Deep Dive Reports do not automatically apply your account’s bot click exclusion setting.”
Klaviyo calls a campaign A/B result significant when each email variant has 50+ deliveries and win probability tops 90%. Open rate tests count MPP opens, so click rate may read cleaner.
“Consider click rate if MPP makes open-rate results difficult to interpret.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer