Risk and team
Stay inside Google's spam policies, audit your site and any agency from accounts you own, keep URLs stable in a migration, and find a traffic drop's cause before you fix it.
5 answers · Data as of Nov 22, 2026
The short version
Our judgment, drawn from the 5 answers below.
Never buy or trade product for followed links or publish AI or template pages in bulk, review AI copy by hand, and remember you answer for any SEO you hire.
Audit an agency from accounts you own, comparing non-brand clicks and organic leads with the period before it started, and judge results only after month four.
In a migration, keep URLs the same where you can, 301 redirect every valuable old URL to its closest new page, and keep the redirects at least 1 year.
After a sudden traffic drop, rule out tracking errors, Google reporting errors and seasonality first, then fix only the cause the Search Console pattern points to.
The 5 answers
Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:
Stay safe and hire well
Avoiding penalties and checking an SEO agency's work.
How do we avoid SEO practices that get a site penalized?
Never buy or trade product for followed links, or publish AI or template pages in bulk. Review AI copy by hand and watch Search Console for manual actions. You answer for any SEO you hire.
High confidence · 5 sources
How should we audit an SEO agency's work?
Work from accounts you own. Compare non-brand clicks and organic leads with the period before the agency started, count delivered pages and named link domains against the contract and judge results only after month four.
Medium confidence · 6 sources
Audit and fix the site
Store audits, migrations and redesigns, and sudden traffic drops.
What should an SEO audit of a Shopify store cover?
Audit from Search Console and a full crawl. Check indexing blockers, duplicate URLs, redirects, page basics, markup and app scripts, then rank fixes by impact and re-audit every 3 to 6 months.
Medium confidence · 13 sources
How should we protect rankings during a site migration or redesign?
Keep URLs the same where you can and change one thing at a time. Map every valuable old URL to its closest new page with 301 redirects, test before launch and keep the redirects at least 1 year.
Medium confidence · 8 sources
How do we handle a sudden traffic drop from search?
Before changing anything, rule out tracking errors, Google reporting errors and seasonality. Then match the Search Console pattern, by page and query, to updates, technical faults, manual actions or AI Overviews, and fix only that cause.
High confidence · 8 sources
More in Search and AI
63 answers in 10 subjects
Guides that use these answers: How to get found in Google search · How to hire and work with a marketing agency