How should we audit an SEO agency's work?
Our answer
Work from accounts you own. Compare non-brand clicks and organic leads with the period before the agency started, count delivered pages and named link domains against the contract and judge results only after month four.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 official rules
- 5 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 10 statements
- GPC
SSE
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentYou carry the risk of any SEO you hire, so ask the agency for proof. Google says you are responsible for the actions of any SEO you hire and no one can guarantee a top ranking. Ask for every change explained against Google's own documentation.
An agency's report is written by the people being judged (PalV's DM). Searchmaxxed, an SEO agency, tests reports against the source accounts and traces a test enquiry through to the report.
Some shortfall is normal, and results take months. Stridec, an SEO agency, treats a 20% shortfall against the contract as normal slack and 60% as under-delivery. eSEOspace expects early gains in months 4 to 6 and attributable leads in months 7 to 12.
Our judgment
- Audit from accounts you own rather than the agency's report. We draw on PalV's DM's point that the report is written by the people being judged, Searchmaxxed's test of reports against source data and Google's rule that a property needs a verified owner.
- Split brand from non-brand before judging results. A ranking or click rise on your own name says little about the agency's work, given Searchmaxxed's point on brand rankings and Google's description of non-branded queries as new users finding you.
- Judge results only after month four and activity before it. We take the earliest month at which PalV's DM and eSEOspace expect meaningful movement.
- Ask before acting on a gap, then coach or replace by the kind of problem. This follows PalV's DM's warning about unexplained priority calls and Stridec's split between coachable and structural problems.
Our judgment, built from PalV's DM, Searchmaxxed, Google, eSEOspace and Stridec: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 6 sourcesGoogle says a Search Console property needs at least one verified owner or no one has access. Owners have full control, full users can view all data and take some actions, and restricted users get simple view rights.
“A property must have at least one verified owner, or no users will have access to the property.”
Searchmaxxed, an SEO agency, advises testing an agency's report against source data by following a test enquiry into analytics and the CRM. One client's GA4 event names over 40 characters never counted.
“Test the report against source data.”
Search Engine Roundtable reports SEO consultants seeing more Google manual action penalties in 2026, for thin content, pure spam and scaled content, often on long-standing businesses. No counts given.
“Went from essentially no requests to several per week.”
PalV's DM, an SEO agency, says audit an agency with your own Search Console data, ask for link domains and a changelog, and expect meaningful results in 4 to 12 months.
“Every SEO report is, to some degree, a summary written by the people being evaluated.”
PalV's DM, which sells one-time audits, says to have an agency audited by someone with no stake in the contract, without telling them what the agency claims, and compare results to recent monthly reports.
“Commission the audit from someone with no financial stake in your current contract”
Google says small local businesses can do much SEO themselves, nobody can guarantee a #1 ranking, an auditing SEO should get read-only Search Console access, and you answer for what any SEO you hire does.
“No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.”
Google says good SEO advice cites data, experience or official guidance, that it does not evaluate third-party services, and that outside tools cannot see its ranking data or guarantee results.
“Third-party tools don't have access to our internal ranking data. They can't guarantee performance.”
Stridec, an SEO seller, says to audit an agency by listing what was promised against what was delivered. It calls a 20% shortfall normal slack and a 60% shortfall under-delivery or unapproved scope change.
“A 20% shortfall against the promise is normal slack; a 60% shortfall is the agency under-delivering or scope-changing without your sign-off.”
eSEOspace, an SEO seller, advises judging SEO agencies by qualified leads and organic revenue, not rankings or impressions, and insisting on admin access to your own analytics accounts.
“Judge SEO by qualified leads and revenue from organic search, not by keyword rankings or total impressions”
Google's Search Console filter splits queries into branded and non-branded using an AI-assisted system that may misclassify some. It says branded queries usually rank higher and earn higher click-through rates.
“some queries may occasionally be misidentified.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer