How should we protect rankings during a site migration or redesign?
Our answer
Keep URLs the same where you can and change one thing at a time. Map every valuable old URL to its closest new page with 301 redirects, test before launch and keep the redirects at least 1 year.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 5 official rules
- 4 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 11 statements
- G
KSCM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentChange one thing at a time (Google). Use permanent redirects from each old URL to its matching new page, not the home page, and keep them at least 1 year. A move plus a redesign will probably lose traffic, Google warns.
Bad redirects and nobody watching can sink a move. Koozai (UK digital marketing agency) traced a client's loss to incomplete or wrong redirects, content changed during the move and no one checking Search Console. The drop had built for two or three weeks.
A full inventory of old URLs is the base of the redirect map. Pattern (Amazon marketplace agency) and SEOJuice (SEO automation software maker) both build the map that way. John Mueller of Google says a move's outcome is impossible to know fully ahead of time.
Our judgment
On a redesign, we would keep URLs and content where they are and ship the design alone, because Google expects some loss when a move is combined with a redesign. Build and test the redirect map before launch rather than repairing after, since Google sees people redirect to URLs that don't exist. Plan for weeks of ranking swings and judge the move by page type against a saved baseline rather than by a fixed recovery date. Pattern's 8 to 12 weeks and SEOJuice's view that no deadline exists both rest on their own client work.
Our judgment, built from Google, Koozai, SEOJuice and Pattern: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
11 statements from 8 sourcesGoogle says use the Change of Address tool only for domain or subdomain moves, keep the site structure, 301 the old pages, keep redirects at least 180 days and the old domain at least a year.
“When moving a site, keeping the same site architecture in the new location helps to pass the signals more directly to the new site.”
Shopify says when migrating, redirect your most-visited old pages to the new store, possibly by CSV, keep the site out of private mode, and expect Google to take days to weeks to index it.
“You can set up redirects for all your important pages to help preserve your SEO ranking.”
Shopify lets you redirect only URLs that return a 404, such as a deleted or draft product, to a similar page, up to 100,000 redirects (20,000,000 on Plus).
“If the URL still loads a valid webpage, then the URL redirect won't work.”
Search Engine Journal reports one site whose domain move reverted after four months. Google's John Mueller suggested setting Change of Address for both www and non-www, without saying that caused it.
“Sometimes things just take a particularly long time to be fully processed.”
Google's site move guide says to change one thing at a time, 301 redirect each old URL server-side to its final new URL, keep redirects at least a year, and expect weeks before the new URLs show.
“301 and other permanent redirects don't cause a loss in PageRank”
SEOJuice, which sells SEO software, draws on its own domain move: keep existing URLs where you can, map old pages from several data sources, and use a 404 or 410 rather than an irrelevant redirect.
“There is no credible universal percentage or recovery deadline.”
Google's John Mueller says a site move is always a big deal whose outcome cannot be fully known ahead, and a mostly global site need not switch from .ca to a gTLD.
“A site move is always a big deal, even if you take the time to do it right. It's a lot of work, and the outcome is impossible to know fully ahead of time.”
Koozai, an SEO agency, says a failed migration had incomplete redirects and content changes at once, and drops show up two or three weeks late; audit every ranking URL and watch Search Console from day one.
“By the time a business notices the traffic drop, it's usually been building for two or three weeks”
Catch Metrics, which sells speed audits, says most headless Shopify builds it audits are slower on LCP and INP than the Liquid themes they replaced, and Liquid likely wins for most catalog stores.
“Most headless migrations we audit regress on LCP and INP”
Pattern, which sells SEO services, says a design-only migration with the same URLs is lowest risk, most good migrations settle in 8-12 weeks, and you should export Search Console data first.
“Most well-executed migrations stabilise within 8-12 weeks.”
Google says use a permanent redirect for a removed page when you won't revert it, since Google treats the target as the canonical page. Platforms like Shopify may have built-in redirects.
“Use permanent redirects when you're sure that the redirect won't be reverted.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer